Class anthology: Against the Odds
What does it take to survive?
The mystery: Students get a survival kit list and must cut it to five items, then read the opening of “To Build a Fire”.
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
use details from a National Park Service page to explain what gold rush travelers needed to survive, and choose a survival book to read independently this unit.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. Yesterday you chose five items. Imagine instead that the law said you must carry a whole year of food before you could enter a new land. How much do you think that would weigh? Write a guess in pounds.
Travelers to the Klondike gold fields in 1897-98 had to bring a year of supplies. What do you predict the total load was called?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Why read a nonfiction page in a story unit? “To Build a Fire” is set in the Yukon during the gold rush years. Real records of that time help us picture the setting and judge the man’s choices. Fiction and fact work together.
Worked example 1: a detail becomes evidence. Sofia wants to show that survival in the north took planning. She quotes the page: Canada “required every stampeder bring a year’s supply of goods before crossing the border.” She explains: “The government did not trust people to guess. It made a rule.”
Worked example 2: a first-person voice. Jamal notices the quote from stampeder Ed Lung in 1897. Lung says the trips “was hard to bear.” Jamal writes, “Survival was not only about supplies. It also took the strength to keep going on a trail that was ‘narrow and slippery.’”
People who knew the land. The page reminds us that the Yukon and Alaska were not empty. Tlingit people lived on this coast and knew its trails and weather. Their knowledge kept people alive, and losing it cost lives.
Your reading life. All unit you will read a book of your choice about a character who survives against the odds. It can be a classic or a library book. Choose one you can read and understand on your own. Use the five-finger check: read one page, and if you meet more than five words you cannot figure out, try another book.
The reading log. After each reading session, write the date, the pages and one sentence: What is my character up against, and how is the character responding? You will bring these notes to our discussions.
Read the page passage silently first. Then answer with your partner.
Choose and start your survival book.
Reading life: write your book's title and author, why you chose it and what the main character seems to be up against. Read for 15 minutes, then do the five-finger check. Is this a book you can read and understand on your own? Explain.
Start your reading log: date, pages read and one sentence: What is my character up against, and how is the character responding?
We learned what real survival in the far north took, and we started our own survival reading. Next time we return to the man on the trail and read for clues.
Exit ticket: name one item on the real supply list (socks, mittens, matches) that matters in “To Build a Fire” and predict why.
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading 9, mini lesson 8, guided practice 8, book choice and log 11.
Source note: the NPS page is a U.S. government work. Ed Lung’s words are quoted on that page and date from 1897. The page also includes a harsh account of how thieves were punished on the trail; it is not in our passage, so preview the page before projecting it whole. The full 1897 supply list on the page includes “1 tin matches (for four men),” “1 dozen heavy wool socks” and “1/2 dozen heavy wool mittens,” useful links to the story.
Native peoples: name the Tlingit as a living people. The page’s point is that their knowledge of the trails and weather mattered; do not let the gold rush be framed as entering an empty land.
Independent reading: offer a range of survival books at many levels, chosen with your school librarian. Preview any older title for dated depictions; our scope flags The Call of the Wild and Robinson Crusoe, so do not offer them. Logs are evidence for CC.1.3.6.K all unit.
Likely misconceptions: that a heavier pack is always better; that the Klondike is in Alaska (the gold fields were in Canada’s Yukon; the trails began in Alaska).
Answer guide: an experienced traveler would think he is careless: the government demanded a year of supplies, and stampeders carried “hundreds of pounds,” while he carries only lunch.
National Park Service, Klondike Gold Rush National Historical Park, Ton of Goods · U.S. government work, public domain
About the page. The National Park Service runs Klondike Gold Rush National Historical Park in Alaska. This page explains the “ton of goods” that gold seekers, called stampeders, carried north in 1897 and 1898. Canada required each person to bring a year of supplies so that people would not starve in the remote Yukon. That meant three pounds of food a day for a whole year.
What to notice. Stampeders had to haul all of it over steep mountain trails, often in many trips. The page says many Tlingit people, the Native people of this coast, were hired as packers and made good money. When fewer Tlingit packers worked the trails, their local knowledge of the land and weather was lost, and an avalanche on April 3, 1898, killed many stampeders who kept packing after the Tlingit packers had quit because conditions were dangerous.
Words to know. A stampeder was a person rushing to the gold fields. A cache is a stored pile of supplies. Precipitous means very steep.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the story and once with a pencil.
To prevent mass starvation in the remote and inaccessible Yukon Territory, the Canadian government required every stampeder bring a year’s supply of goods before crossing the border.
[…]
The Canadian government determined each person going to Dawson from Skagway or Dyea needed three pounds of food per day for a whole year. Food alone would weigh in at a minimum of 1,095 pounds (~497 kg) or just over half a ton. But for a prospector, adding necessary clothes and equipment to the food could easily double the total load, and thus came to be known as a “ton of goods.”
[…]
Stampeders who carried their own goods had the choice of carrying more weight or walking more miles. A light pack of 50 pounds meant more trips. A heavy pack of 80 pounds meant fewer trips, but extra weight and slower pace. Every mile walked with a load meant another mile back empty.
[…]
“Stacey and I viewed our hundreds of pounds of supplies with much concern, especially when we saw the steep, slippery trail leading from the river up the canyon. We knew we would have to make a number of back-breaking relay trips to establish our first cache. Quickly, we began dividing our supplies, making about sixty-five to seventy-pound packs for each. Then we started. The trail immediately crooked up, narrow and slippery. As we climbed, we threw our weight toward the inside of the trail, hugging the precipitous walls. The fact that we must make several trips over this trail for the rest of our supplies was hard to bear.” – Stampeder Ed Lung, 1897.
Source: National Park Service, Klondike Gold Rush National Historical Park, Ton of Goods (nps.gov)