finish my revision plan, then edit my narrative for grade 6 conventions, including dialogue punctuation, pronouns and verb tense.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Find the three errors: “Don’t kill me” cried Chuchundra. Him and Rikki-tikki listened, then a snake scratches on the bricks.
Which version fixes all three errors?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Revise first, edit second. Revising changes what you say and how (big moves from your revision plan). Editing fixes conventions so readers are never distracted. Finish your plan first. Then edit, one skill at a time.
Dialogue rules from Kipling. (1) Quotation marks go around the exact words: “Told you what?” (2) A question mark or exclamation point stays inside the closing mark: “Rikki-tikki, don’t kill me!” (3) When a statement is followed by a tag, use a comma inside the marks: “Don’t kill me,” said Chuchundra. (4) When the tag interrupts one sentence, use commas on both sides and keep the second part lowercase: “That’s Nag or Nagaina,” he said to himself, “and he is crawling…” (5) A dash shows a speaker breaking off: “My cousin Chua, the rat, told me–” (6) Start a new paragraph for each new speaker.
Pronoun case. Use subject pronouns (I, he, she, we, they) as subjects and object pronouns (me, him, her, us, them) after verbs and prepositions. “Nico and I walked” but “the ranger helped Nico and me.” Also fix vague pronouns: if “he” could mean two characters, use a name.
Verb tense. Pick past or present and stay there. Kipling’s narrator stays in past tense (said, sat, listened), while the characters speak in their own present inside the quotation marks.
Worked example 1: Elena edits dialogue. Draft: Stay here said Mom we need to wait for the ranger. Edit: “Stay here,” said Mom. “We need to wait for the ranger.” She added marks, a comma inside, a period after the tag and a capital for the new sentence.
Worked example 2: Kofi fixes a run-on and a tense shift. Draft: The river was rising fast I grab my brother’s hand. Edit: “The river was rising fast, so I grabbed my brother’s hand.” He joined the two sentences with a comma and so and kept the past tense.
Commas for extra information. Set off extra information with commas or dashes: “My cousin Chua, the rat, told me.” Kipling uses dashes for an interruption: “a noise as faint as that of a wasp walking on a window-pane–the dry scratch of a snake’s scales.”
Edit each sentence. Use Kipling’s punctuation as your model.
Revise, then edit your own narrative.
Finish the three changes in your revision plan. In your revision log, write the before and after for the biggest change and why it helps your reader.
Edit in four passes, one skill each: (1) dialogue punctuation, (2) pronouns, (3) verb tense, (4) spelling and run-ons. Read your draft aloud for pass 4. List one error you fixed in each pass.
Clean conventions are a gift to your reader: nothing gets between them and your story.
Exit ticket: which convention do you get wrong most often? What will you check for every time you write?
Pacing: warm-up 4 minutes, reading 5, mini lecture 9, guided practice 10, revision and editing passes 11, closure 1. This is the flex revision lesson; extend with a second editing day if drafts need it.
Content and edition notes: Part 1 read the story’s opening, the meeting at the nest and the ending; this scene comes between them and was not read there. The setting is colonial India and the family is British; say so plainly. Chuchundra calls himself “a very poor man” though he is a muskrat, a playful touch worth pointing out. The book file prints dashes as two hyphens (–), copied as printed. The summary’s quoted description of Chuchundra comes from the paragraph just before the passage.
Likely misconceptions: that “Me and him” is fine as a subject; that a comma can join two complete sentences; that every quote needs a period inside before the tag.
Supports: provide a dialogue-punctuation card and a pronoun chart. Let students edit with a ruler under each line. Stretch: find the sentence with commas around extra information (“My cousin Chua, the rat”) and imitate it.
Answer guide: Do Now errors: missing comma inside the closing mark, “Him” for “He,” tense shift (scratches). Edited passage: “Where is the fire?” asked Nico. Maya and I looked at the spruce tree. The snow fell on it, and it was gone. (Accept “falls … it’s gone” in present tense if consistent; the key fixes are the capital, the question mark inside the marks, “Maya and I,” the run-on and “it’s” or “it was.”)
Project Gutenberg, The Jungle Book by Rudyard Kipling (1894), eBook #236, "Rikki-Tikki-Tavi" · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
In Part 1 you met Rikki-tikki, the young mongoose in Rudyard Kipling’s “Rikki-Tikki-Tavi” from The Jungle Book (1894), and the cobras Nag and Nagaina. This scene happens on the night after Rikki-tikki first fights a snake. While the family’s boy, Teddy, sleeps, Rikki-tikki walks around the house and meets Chuchundra, a muskrat. Kipling calls him “a broken-hearted little beast” who whimpers all night and never dares to run into the middle of the room. Chuchundra knows something important, but he is too scared to say it.
Today you are reading like an editor. Look at where every quotation mark, comma, question mark and exclamation point goes, and notice when a new paragraph begins. This edition uses two hyphens (–) for a dash.
Words to know: scornfully means in a way that shows you look down on someone; sorrowfully means sadly; H’sh means hush; spirit here means courage; sluice is a channel or drain for water; brick-work means bricks laid in a wall.
“Don’t kill me,” said Chuchundra, almost weeping. “Rikki-tikki, don’t kill me!”
“Do you think a snake-killer kills muskrats?” said Rikki-tikki scornfully.
“Those who kill snakes get killed by snakes,” said Chuchundra, more sorrowfully than ever. “And how am I to be sure that Nag won’t mistake me for you some dark night?”
“There’s not the least danger,” said Rikki-tikki. “But Nag is in the garden, and I know you don’t go there.”
“My cousin Chua, the rat, told me–” said Chuchundra, and then he stopped.
“Told you what?”
“H’sh! Nag is everywhere, Rikki-tikki. You should have talked to Chua in the garden.”
“I didn’t–so you must tell me. Quick, Chuchundra, or I’ll bite you!”
Chuchundra sat down and cried till the tears rolled off his whiskers. “I am a very poor man,” he sobbed. “I never had spirit enough to run out into the middle of the room. H’sh! I mustn’t tell you anything. Can’t you hear, Rikki-tikki?”
Rikki-tikki listened. The house was as still as still, but he thought he could just catch the faintest scratch-scratch in the world–a noise as faint as that of a wasp walking on a window-pane–the dry scratch of a snake’s scales on brick-work.
“That’s Nag or Nagaina,” he said to himself, “and he is crawling into the bath-room sluice. You’re right, Chuchundra; I should have talked to Chua.”
Source: Project Gutenberg, The Jungle Book by Rudyard Kipling (1894), eBook #236, "Rikki-Tikki-Tavi" (gutenberg.pglaf.org)