show what I have learned in Unit 1 by reading a new survival passage closely and turning in my final anthology narrative.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Take a slow breath. You have read like a reader and written like a writer for weeks. Read the passage twice: once for the story, once with your pencil. Underline anything you might use as evidence.
How confident are you that you can I am ready to read closely and use evidence from the passage.
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
How this check works. Part A is a reading check on the passage. Part B is a short on-demand writing task. Part C is your final anthology narrative with your checklist, revision plan and revision log. Take your time and use evidence.
Reminders for Part A. When a question asks for evidence, quote exactly and use quotation marks. A theme is a full sentence about life. A summary leaves out opinions. For point of view, ask who is telling the story and whose thoughts the narrator shares.
Worked example 1: Imani quotes and explains. A practice question about “Fence Line” asks how Maya feels at post thirty-one. Imani writes, “Maya is scared but hides it to keep Nico going. She says ‘Twenty more,’ ‘though I had no idea if that was true,’ which shows she chooses calm words for her brother.” She copies the words exactly and explains them.
Worked example 2: Luis uses context clues. Luis does not know the word desolation in another story. He reads the sentence around it: no trees, no shrubs, no grasses. He decides it means an empty, lifeless place, and checks that the meaning fits.
Reminders for Parts B and C. Use our ten-item checklist. A strong scene hooks and orients the reader, uses dialogue and precise sensory words, unfolds in order with transitions and ends with a conclusion that follows.
| # | Writer’s checklist | Standard |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | My opening hooks the reader, sets the context and introduces the narrator and characters. | N |
| 2 | My story has a clear survival problem, and the character must use skill, courage or other people to face it. | M |
| 3 | Dialogue shows what characters think, want and fear. | O |
| 4 | I use precise words and at least four sensory details, and my survival facts are realistic. | O |
| 5 | I slow down the most dangerous moment and move quickly through the in-between parts. | O |
| 6 | Events unfold in a logical order, and varied transitions show shifts in time or place. | P |
| 7 | My conclusion follows from the events and shows what the character learned or how they changed. | P |
| 8 | My sentences vary in pattern and length, and my narrator’s voice stays consistent. | Q |
| 9 | Grammar, spelling, capitals and punctuation, including dialogue punctuation and verb tense, are correct. | R |
| 10 | I revised after feedback and kept a revision log with reasons. | T |
Constraints: 500 to 900 words. School-appropriate: danger and fear are fine, but no graphic injury. If your story is true and includes other people, change their names or ask their permission. Your title and your first name (or a pen name) will appear in the anthology.
Part A: Reading check. Work alone. Answer each question from the passage.
Parts B and C.
Part B (on-demand writing, about 15 minutes): Write the scene of the next morning, when the man wakes “chilled and sick” as the snow begins. Orient the reader, include at least two lines of correctly punctuated dialogue or spoken thoughts, use two sensory details and two transitions, slow down one important moment and end with a line that shows what keeps him going. Keep him true to the passage.
Part C: Submit your final anthology narrative with your checklist marked, your revision plan from 1.22 and your revision log. In two sentences, name the change from peer feedback that improved your story most.
Like the man in the barrens, you have kept going. Next, your story goes out to readers.
Exit ticket: which question on the check felt strongest for you, and which skill do you want to keep practicing?
Pacing: warm-up and two readings 10 minutes, brief reminders 3, Part A 17, Part B 10 (finish in the next lesson if needed). Collect Part C at the end.
Coverage: Part A covers CC.1.3.6.A (theme, q1; objective summary in the short response), B (quotation, q2 and short response), C (plot and the man’s response, q3 and q4), D (point of view and purpose, q7 and q8), F (personification and context clue, q5 and q6) and K (independent reading of a new passage). Part B and the final narrative (Part C) are scored with the rubric below for CC.1.4.6.M-R and T. Discussion records from 1.17, 1.22 and 1.23 and the audience discussion in 1.26 complete CC.1.5.6.A.
Content and edition notes: the passage is new to students; they read the story’s opening in 1.16 and will read its ending in 1.27. Later the story includes graphic hunger and a struggle with a sick wolf, which is not used. A cut […] ends the passage as the snow begins. Eluded is deliberately left out of the words to know and the glossary, so question 6 tests context clues. The 1913 Review of Reviews printing in the file reprints Macmillan’s 1906 copyright edition. The man’s crying is a natural response to despair; treat it respectfully if students react.
Supports: read the passage aloud for students with reading accommodations (Part A then measures comprehension, not decoding). Allow typed responses and extended time.
Scoring Part A (12 points): questions 1-8 are 1 point each. The short response is scored 0-4: 1 for a clear claim, 1 for each of two accurate quotations explained, 1 for an objective one-sentence summary.
Anthology narrative rubric (Part C; use rows 1, 2, 3 and 5 for Part B). Score each row 4 (exceeds), 3 (meets), 2 (approaching) or 1 (beginning).
| Row | 4 | 3 | 2 | 1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Opening (N) | A strong hook; context, narrator and characters are clear at once | Context and narrator are clear | Some of where, when or who is missing | The reader cannot tell where or who |
| 2. Survival story and techniques (M, O) | A clear survival problem shown through purposeful dialogue, four or more precise sensory details, realistic facts and a slowed-down key moment | A clear problem with some dialogue, sensory detail and pacing | The danger is told more than shown | No clear survival problem |
| 3. Sequence and conclusion (P) | Logical order, varied transitions for time and place, a conclusion that follows and shows change | Clear order, some transitions, a fitting conclusion | Order sometimes confusing; ending stops suddenly | Hard to follow; no conclusion |
| 4. Style and voice (Q) | Sentences vary on purpose; precise words; voice stays consistent | Some variety; voice mostly consistent | Most sentences sound alike; voice shifts | Choppy or run-on throughout |
| 5. Conventions (R) | Few or no errors; dialogue, pronouns and tense correct | Minor errors that do not get in the way | Frequent errors | Errors make it hard to read |
| 6. Revision (T) | Plan and log show real changes from feedback, with reasons, including a new approach | Log shows some changes | Few changes from the first draft | No plan or log |
A total of 18-24 meets the standard for the anthology. Below 18, confer and allow one more revision before publishing.
Answer key: 1 = C (index 2), 2 = B (1), 3 = A (0), 4 = D (3), 5 = A (0), 6 = B (1), 7 = C (2), 8 = D (3). Sample short response: “It takes the will to keep doing the next small thing, even after despair. After the fish escapes, he ‘cried loudly to the pitiless desolation,’ so he is not fearless. But then ‘He built a fire and warmed himself’ and made sure ‘his matches were dry,’ which shows he keeps caring for the tools that will keep him alive. Summary: a starving man alone in the north tries for half an hour to catch one small fish, loses it through a crack in the rocks, weeps, and then makes camp and sleeps.” Sample Part B: “By morning, the snow had come. The man woke with frost on his blanket and a raw ache in his ankle. ‘Get up,’ he told himself. ‘Bill is waiting.’ The flakes hissed as they hit his little fire, and one by one the flames went out. He held his breath, cupped his hands around the last coal, then let it go. Slowly, he strapped on his pack. The land of little sticks was somewhere ahead, and he meant to find it.”
Project Gutenberg, Love of Life and Other Stories by Jack London (Macmillan, copyright 1906), eBook #710, "Love of Life" · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
In 1.16 you read the opening of Jack London’s “Love of Life” (copyright 1906): Bill walks away from his partner, who has sprained his ankle in the empty Barren Grounds of northern Canada. The injured man goes on alone, telling himself that Bill will wait at their cache of supplies far to the south. His gun has no bullets, and he has not had enough to eat for a long time. He has a tin bucket, a few blankets and his matches, which he counts carefully.
This passage comes from the next day, after his first night alone. He has been eating muskeg berries and roots that do not fill him, and he is very hungry. You have not read this part before. Read it twice.
Words to know: vainly means without success; solitary means alone, only one; sediment is mud and bits that settle to the bottom of water; bale means to scoop water out; crevice is a narrow crack; clammy means cold and damp; profound means very deep.
He looked into every pool of water vainly, until, as the long twilight came on, he discovered a solitary fish, the size of a minnow, in such a pool. He plunged his arm in up to the shoulder, but it eluded him. He reached for it with both hands and stirred up the milky mud at the bottom. In his excitement he fell in, wetting himself to the waist. Then the water was too muddy to admit of his seeing the fish, and he was compelled to wait until the sediment had settled.
The pursuit was renewed, till the water was again muddied. But he could not wait. He unstrapped the tin bucket and began to bale the pool. He baled wildly at first, splashing himself and flinging the water so short a distance that it ran back into the pool. He worked more carefully, striving to be cool, though his heart was pounding against his chest and his hands were trembling. At the end of half an hour the pool was nearly dry. Not a cupful of water remained. And there was no fish. He found a hidden crevice among the stones through which it had escaped to the adjoining and larger pool–a pool which he could not empty in a night and a day. Had he known of the crevice, he could have closed it with a rock at the beginning and the fish would have been his.
Thus he thought, and crumpled up and sank down upon the wet earth. At first he cried softly to himself, then he cried loudly to the pitiless desolation that ringed him around; and for a long time after he was shaken by great dry sobs.
He built a fire and warmed himself by drinking quarts of hot water, and made camp on a rocky ledge in the same fashion he had the night before. The last thing he did was to see that his matches were dry and to wind his watch. The blankets were wet and clammy. His ankle pulsed with pain. But he knew only that he was hungry, and through his restless sleep he dreamed of feasts and banquets and of food served and spread in all imaginable ways.
He awoke chilled and sick. There was no sun. The gray of earth and sky had become deeper, more profound. A raw wind was blowing, and the first flurries of snow were whitening the hilltops. […]
Source: Project Gutenberg, Love of Life and Other Stories by Jack London (Macmillan, copyright 1906), eBook #710, "Love of Life" (gutenberg.pglaf.org)