turn numbers from a source into a data graphic with a title, labels and a source line, and write a caption that tells visitors what to notice.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Read this sentence: “The ship drifted 1186 miles, but the nearest food and shelter were 346 miles away.” Now sketch two bars, one for each number, on scrap paper. Which version, the sentence or the sketch, shows the difference faster?
For which job is a bar graph usually better than a paragraph?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
When words are not enough. Some information is easier to see than to read. Informative writers add graphics (tables, bar graphs, maps, timelines, diagrams, photos) when they help readers understand. The standard says “when useful”: a graphic must earn its space.
Integrating words and numbers. Shackleton’s diary gives six distances in a few sentences: more than 570 miles of drift, 573 miles from the starting point, 1186 miles of total observed drift, more than 1500 miles probably covered, 346 miles to Paulet Island and 180 miles to the nearest barrier. Read quickly, they blur together. A graphic lets visitors compare them, and the words explain what they mean: the ice had carried the men a very long way, yet safety was still hundreds of miles off.
Rules for a data graphic. (1) A title that says what the graphic shows. (2) Labels and units (miles, days, meters). (3) A source line. (4) One graphic, one idea. (5) Numbers copied exactly; if you round, say so.
Sample data graphic (made for our class from the diary).
| The Endurance’s Long Drift, October 27, 1915 (miles) | |
|---|---|
| Total observed drift | 1186 ████████████ |
| Straight-line distance from where the ship was trapped | 573 ██████ |
| Distance to food and shelter at Paulet Island | 346 ████ |
| Distance to the nearest barrier (no food there) | 180 ██ |
Source: Ernest Shackleton, South (1919), diary for October 27, 1915. Each block is about 100 miles.
Captions. A caption sits under a picture or graphic. It tells what the visitor is looking at, points out what to notice and gives a credit line.
Worked example 1: Aiden builds the graphic. Aiden first includes all six numbers, then sees that “more than 570” and “573” say almost the same thing and that “more than 1500” is only Shackleton’s estimate. He keeps four exact numbers with one idea: how far the ice carried them compared with how far safety was.
Worked example 2: Sofia writes the caption. Sofia’s caption: “The ice carried the Endurance more than a thousand miles, yet its crew was still 346 miles from food and shelter. Source: Shackleton, South (1919).” She tells visitors what to notice and gives the source.
Use Shackleton’s diary under “The text” and the sample graphic.
Plan your own data graphic.
Find three or four real numbers in a source about your object (distances, depths, dates, temperatures or counts). List each number with its unit and source. Choose a graphic type (bar graph, table, timeline or labeled diagram) and explain why it fits.
Sketch your graphic and write its title, labels, source line and a caption of 15 to 40 words that tells visitors what to notice.
A good graphic lets a seven-year-old see in two seconds what took Shackleton a paragraph to say.
Exit ticket: what is the one thing a visitor should notice in your graphic? Write it as the first sentence of your caption.
Pacing: warm-up 4 minutes, reading 8, mini lecture with the sample graphic 9, guided practice 12, graphic planning 6, closure 1.
Source notes: the passage is copied from Gutenberg #5199, Chapter IV, including the book’s acute-accent minute marks (69° 5´) and the en dash in “–8.5°.” The first cut skips the opening of the diary entry, which Part 1 read in 2.06; the second cut skips Shackleton’s note that he had bought the hut’s stores in London for the Argentine government. The figure of 28 people in the summary is the Weddell Sea party listed elsewhere in the book; students do not need it for any answer. The bar blocks in the sample graphic are rounded to the nearest 100 miles, as its source line says.
Discussion note: the diary describes danger and loss. All members of the Weddell Sea party survived the expedition; tell students who worry, and save the full survival story for independent reading.
Likely misconceptions: that more numbers make a better graphic (one idea per graphic); that “573” and “1186” contradict each other (one is a straight line, one follows every observed turn); that a caption just repeats the title.
Supports: provide graph paper and a bar-graph frame with the title and source line printed. Pair students who share an object. Stretch: add the estimated 1500 miles to the graphic in a way that shows it is an estimate (dashed bar or a note).
Answer guide: sample integration: “The graphic shows that the ice carried the Endurance 1186 miles, yet the men were still far from help. Shackleton wrote that they were ‘346 miles from Paulet Island, the nearest point where there is any possibility of finding food and shelter,’ so the long drift had not brought them close to safety.”
Project Gutenberg, South: The Story of Shackleton’s Last Expedition 1914–1917 by Sir Ernest Shackleton (1919; New York: Macmillan, 1920), eBook #5199 · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
In Part 1 (2.06) you read how the moving ice crushed the Endurance and the start of Shackleton’s diary for October 27, 1915, the day the crew left the ship. The ship had been trapped in the frozen Weddell Sea, near Antarctica, since early 1915. For months the ice carried it along, a slow movement called drift.
Today you read the position report for that day and then the part of the diary that comes next. Notice how many numbers Shackleton records: days in the ice, miles of drift and miles to the nearest possible shelter. Ask yourself what those numbers meant for the 28 people on the ice.
Words to know: lat. and long. mean latitude and longitude, the numbers that mark a place on a map; Fahr. means degrees Fahrenheit; beset means trapped by ice; mortally hurt means hurt so badly it will die; floes are large sheets of floating ice; barrier here means a great wall and shelf of ice along the coast; sustaining means keeping alive.
The position was lat. 69° 5´ S., long. 51° 30´ W. The temperature was –8.5° Fahr., a gentle southerly breeze was blowing and the sun shone in a clear sky.
[…] She is crushed and abandoned after drifting more than 570 miles in a north-westerly direction during the 281 days since she became locked in the ice. The distance from the point where she became beset to the place where she now rests mortally hurt in the grip of the floes is 573 miles, but the total drift through all observed positions has been 1186 miles, and probably we actually covered more than 1500 miles. We are now 346 miles from Paulet Island, the nearest point where there is any possibility of finding food and shelter. A small hut built there by the Swedish expedition in 1902 is filled with stores left by the Argentine relief ship. […] The distance to the nearest barrier west of us is about 180 miles, but a party going there would still be about 360 miles from Paulet Island and there would be no means of sustaining life on the barrier. We could not take from here food enough for the whole journey; the weight would be too great.
Source: Project Gutenberg, South: The Story of Shackleton’s Last Expedition 1914–1917 by Sir Ernest Shackleton (1919; New York: Macmillan, 1920), eBook #5199 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)