compare how a biography from Arlington National Cemetery and Henson’s own memoir present his life and achievement, and write an objective summary of the biography.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Write one sentence about yourself that only you could write. Then write one sentence about yourself that a stranger with a fact sheet could write. What is the difference?
When did Henson receive major national honors for the North Pole journey?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Memoir and biography. A memoir (2.09) is written by the person who lived it, in the first person, close to the events. A biography is written by someone else, in the third person, often long after. A memoir gives feelings and small moments. A biography gives the whole life and its meaning from a distance.
Worked example 1: what each includes. Nadia notes that the biography includes facts Henson’s polar chapter does not: born “in Charles County, Maryland in 1866,” cabin boy at 12, and honors in 1937 and 1944. Henson’s chapter included the cold, the rescue and his feelings. She writes: The biography shows his whole life; the memoir shows what one day felt like.
Worked example 2: how each presents the achievement. Ravi notices the biography says Henson “received relatively little immediate recognition” and calls later honors “long-overdue.” Those words judge history. Henson’s memoir, written in 1912, could not know how he would be remembered. Ravi writes: The biographer can show the unfairness Henson faced because she or he looks back on his whole life.
Reading a claim carefully. The biography says the party “became the first human beings to set foot on the North Pole” and adds “According to Henson, he was the first of the group to reach the North Pole.” Notice the phrase According to Henson: the writer tells us whose claim it is.
Objective summary of a biography. Retell the life in order, in your own words, without your opinions. You may report the writer’s judgment (The page says his honors were long overdue) but do not add your own.
Monuments quote too. The inscription quotes Henson’s memoir. In 2.14 we will read his own ending of the book and see how the monument used it.
Use the biography and your 2.09 notes. Mark B (biography only), M (memoir only) or Both.
Compare, then summarize.
Venn diagram: Memoir (Henson, 2.09) / Biography (Arlington) / Both. Write at least three items in each part, including who wrote it, when, and point of view.
Write an objective summary of the biography in 4-5 sentences, in time order. Checklist: (1) the central idea first, (2) birth, sea career, expeditions and recognition, (3) your own words, (4) no opinions of your own.
A memoir and a biography gave us two views of one life. Next we read NOAA’s numbers about ocean depth and plan our data graphic.
Exit ticket: write two timeline entries about Henson's life (year plus event) for our exhibit, using the biography.
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading 8, mini lesson 8, guided practice 11, Venn and summary 9.
Text notes: the cut skips the paragraphs on Henson’s 1955 death, his 1988 reburial at Arlington with his wife, Lucy Ross Henson, and the design of his monument; share them for the timeline if useful (they are on the same page). The biography states the North Pole claim as fact; remind students of 2.10’s debate and of the page’s own phrase “According to Henson.” Henson’s title word Negro appears in the inscription paragraph; it was the respectful term in 1912.
Discussion note: the gap in recognition reflects racism in the early 1900s. Name it plainly and keep the focus on Henson’s skill and on the evidence of who received credit and when.
Likely misconceptions: that a biography has no point of view; that a memoir must be less accurate; that “valet” was Henson’s only role (he accompanied Peary on seven Arctic expeditions).
Supports: a timeline strip with 1866, 1878 (age 12), 1888, 1891-1909, 1912, 1937, 1944. Stretch: why might Arlington choose to end with a quotation from Henson himself?
Answer guide: both present the 1909 journey; the memoir tells it from inside, in the first person, with fear and rescue, while the biography sums it up in one sentence and adds how he was remembered. Sample summary: Matthew Henson, born in Maryland in 1866, became an explorer who went with Robert Peary on seven Arctic expeditions and reached the North Pole area with him and four Inuit assistants in 1909. He went to sea at 12 and learned to read, write and navigate. After the expedition he wrote a book and gave lectures but received little recognition compared with Peary. Late in life he was admitted to the Explorers Club and given a medal by Congress.
Arlington National Cemetery (U.S. Army), Notable Graves: Explorers, Matthew Henson · U.S. government work, public domain
About the text. Arlington National Cemetery, near Washington, D.C., is run by the U.S. Army. Its website has short biographies of notable people buried there. Henson was reburied at Arlington in 1988, beside Peary. A biography is a true account of a person’s life written by someone else, in the third person (he, his).
What to notice. The page covers Henson’s whole life in a few paragraphs: childhood, work at sea, the expeditions and his late recognition. Notice words that show the writer’s view, such as long-overdue. The last paragraph quotes the inscription on his monument, which comes from his memoir.
Words to know. Sharecroppers were farmers who worked someone else’s land for a share of the crop. A valet is a personal assistant. Subsequently means afterward. Obscurity means being unknown. Prestigious means highly respected. An inscription is writing carved on a monument.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the big idea and once with a pencil.
On April 6, 1909, U.S. citizens Matthew Alexander Henson and Robert Edwin Peary, and four Inuit assistants, became the first human beings to set foot on the North Pole. Henson and Peary had been attempting to reach the Pole for the past 18 years. According to Henson, he was the first of the group to reach the North Pole.
Matthew Henson was born in Charles County, Maryland in 1866. His parents were sharecroppers, like many African Americans in the post-Civil War years. Both died during Henson’s childhood. At the age of 12, he went to work as a cabin boy on a merchant ship, having been fascinated by stories of the sea. Aboard the ship for six years, he learned how to read, write and navigate. Later, while working as a clerk in a Washington, D.C. hat shop, he met Commander Robert E. Peary, who was planning a surveying expedition to Nicaragua. Upon learning of Henson’s sailing and navigation experience, Peary hired him as a valet. On the 1888 Nicaragua expedition, Henson impressed Peary, and subsequently accompanied him on seven Arctic expeditions between 1891 and 1909.
In 1912, Henson published an account of his experiences, “A Negro Explorer at the North Pole,” and he gave lectures throughout the country. Compared to Peary, however, he received relatively little immediate recognition for his part in the 1909 expedition to the North Pole. He spent the remainder of his career in obscurity, working as a clerk at the U.S. Customs House in New York City. Late in his life, Henson received some long-overdue honors: the prestigious Explorers Club finally admitted him as a member in 1937, Congress awarded him the Peary Polar Expedition Medal in 1944, and Presidents Harry S. Truman and Dwight D. Eisenhower welcomed him to the White House.
[…]
On the opposite side, an inscription quotes Henson’s book, “A Negro Explorer at the North Pole”: “The lure of the Arctic is tugging at my heart. To me the trail is calling! The old trail. The trail that is always new.”
Source: Arlington National Cemetery (U.S. Army), Notable Graves: Explorers, Matthew Henson (arlingtoncemetery.mil)