test our final plan against every goal and make a claim, with enough evidence, about how well it helps the pond’s frogs and plants.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Look at your Version 2 data. Which goal are you most sure about? Which are you least sure about?
One trial is always enough evidence for a strong claim.
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Rescue Team, this is the final test. You will test your best version. Then you will make a claim.
Our goals, one more time. Keep water: save at least 100 mL of the 200 mL storm, and stay at least 2 degrees cooler in the shade test. Shelter and food: plants or rocks around half the edge, and water plants. Limits: $200 or less, hand tools only, one class period, a lid and nothing sharp.
A strong claim has three parts. The claim says how well the plan helps. The evidence is data about the goals. The reasoning explains how the plan changes the pond system and helps the frogs.
Worked example 1: Ruby’s claim. “Our plan helps the pond well. In three rain trials we saved 130, 120 and 140 mL. That is 390 mL out of 600. Our shade kept the water 3 degrees cooler. It met every other goal too. Reasoning: saved rain and shade keep more water in the pond, and the reading shows ponds with water all year keep more amphibians.”
Worked example 2: Theo asks, is it enough? Theo’s team ran one rain trial. He said, “One trial is not enough. Also, a cup is not a pond, and ten minutes is not a summer. To be sure, the nature center should measure the real pond and count frogs before and after.” Honest scientists say what their evidence can and cannot show.
| Goal | Trial 1 | Trial 2 | Trial 3 | Met? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rain test (mL saved) | ||||
| Shade test (degrees cooler) | ||||
| Edge and water plants | ||||
| Limits |
Run three rain trials and one shade test. Fill in the table.
Judge your evidence.
Is your evidence enough? What more evidence would make your claim stronger?
What can our tabletop model NOT tell us about the real pond and real frogs?
Your claim is ready. Next time you present your rescue plan to an audience.
Exit ticket: how does your plan change the pond system? Name two parts that change.
Pacing: warm-up 3, reading 6, mini lecture 6, trials 15, writing and exit 10 minutes.
Misconceptions: a claim must say the plan is perfect; the model proves what the real pond will do. The reading’s region is real but unnamed here; its drought is the same kind of single change as our dry summers.
Supports: provide a claim-evidence-reasoning frame. Stretch: find the range of the three rain trials.
Answer guide: claims state how well the plan helps; evidence uses trial numbers for every goal; reasoning links saved water and shade to a pond that lasts, more tadpoles growing up and more shelter at the edge. Strong answers name model limits and ask for real pond depth and frog counts before and after.
U.S. Geological Survey, Resilience of native amphibian communities following catastrophic drought · USGS-authored information, U.S. public domain
Let’s reread the drought study and look at the evidence.
How much data? The scientists did not look just once. They used ten years of data. That was more than 2,000 surveys of 233 ponds and seven kinds of amphibians. Lots of data makes a claim stronger.
What changed? In the worst drought year, more than half of the ponds dried up. Almost every kind of amphibian laid fewer eggs during the drought.
A surprise. Some fish and frogs that did not belong in the area disappeared from many ponds during the drought. They did not come back afterward.
What helped? Ponds that held water all year kept more native amphibians during the dry years. Ponds that dried up kept fewer. After the drought, the native amphibians came back quickly.
The scientists say it helps to have different kinds of water places, including some that stay wet all year.
Source: U.S. Geological Survey, Resilience of native amphibian communities following catastrophic drought (usgs.gov)