measure a trait in a group of bean seeds, organize the data in a graph, and describe how traits vary among members of one kind.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Add a caterpillar log entry. Are all the caterpillars in our room the same length today? Then look at a pile of 20 dry lima beans. Do they look exactly alike?
If we measure 20 lima beans, what will we find?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Variation. Variation means the differences among members of one kind of living thing. Two lima beans from the same bag are both lima beans. But one may be a little longer, wider or paler than the other.
Today’s investigation. Each team measures the length of 20 lima beans to the nearest centimeter. Lay each bean flat on the ruler. Measure from end to end. The Recorder makes a tally for each length.
Make a line plot. Draw a number line from 1 to 4 centimeters. Put one X above the number for each bean. The tallest stack of X’s shows the most common length.
Worked example 1: reading a line plot. Ivy’s team found 3 beans at 2 cm, 13 beans at 3 cm, and 4 beans at 4 cm. She wrote, “Most of our beans are 3 cm long. A few are shorter or longer.” These are sample data. Your team’s numbers will be your own.
Worked example 2: why variation matters. Marcus wondered if differences could ever help. He thought about moths. If some moths are a little darker, they might be harder to spot on dark tree bark. A small difference in a trait can matter for survival. We will test an idea like this later.
Other variations. You can find variation everywhere in nature: leaf length on one tree, spot patterns on ladybugs, the length of our caterpillars on the same day. Our museum guide can show visitors how to look for it.
Use your team’s line plot. Point to the data as you answer.
Explain your data.
Look at your line plot. What is the most common bean length? What is the shortest and the longest? Write two sentences about how beans of one kind vary.
Members of one kind vary in their traits. Next time, we set up a test to see if surroundings like sun and shade can change a plant’s traits.
Exit ticket: name one trait that varies in beans and one trait that varies in monarchs. Use evidence from today.
Pacing: 5 min Do Now, 8 min reading, 7 min lecture, 13 min measuring and line plot, 7 min practice and exit ticket.
Materials: 20 dry lima beans per team, centimeter rulers, tally sheets, line plot paper.
Allergy note: dry beans are legumes; gloves are fine. Collect and count beans at the end so none are left on the floor.
Likely misconceptions: “a smaller bean is a different kind”; “variation means something is wrong.” Stress that variation is normal. Marcus’s moth idea previews 1.12; do not explain it fully yet.
Support / stretch: students measure 10 beans instead of 20. Stretch: combine all teams’ data into one class line plot. Does the most common length change?
Answer guide: most lima beans will be 2-3 cm; answers should name the mode and the range from their own plot. Exit ticket: beans vary in length; monarchs vary in size, egg number or life span.
USDA Forest Service, Celebrating Wildflowers: Monarch Butterfly Biology · U.S. government work, public domain
Let’s look again at the Forest Service page about monarch butterflies. This time, look for ways monarchs differ from each other.
First, size. A larva starts out less than 1 centimeter long. It can grow to about 5 centimeters. So two larvae of different ages can be very different in size.
Second, eggs. A female monarch lays about 100 to 300 eggs in her life. That is a wide range. Some females lay many more eggs than others.
Third, how long they live. Monarchs can have up to four generations each summer. A generation is one set of parents or one set of young. Adults born in summer live about 2 to 5 weeks. But the last generation of the year is different. Those monarchs fly far south to a warm place for the winter. They can live as long as 9 months!
All of these butterflies are monarchs. They have the same four life stages and the same orange wings. But they are not all the same in every way.
Source: USDA Forest Service, Celebrating Wildflowers: Monarch Butterfly Biology (fs.usda.gov)