analyze our bean plant data and use evidence to explain how a change in the environment caused a change in a plant’s traits.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Bring Cup A (sun) and Cup B (shade) to your table. Measure both plants in centimeters. Match each plant’s leaves to the color strip. Record the numbers in your plant log.
Look at your two cups. Which statement fits most teams' plants?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
From data to explanation. Scientists do not stop at numbers. They use data as evidence for an explanation. Today you will explain what light did to our bean plants.
Make a class bar graph. Each team adds two bars: the height of Cup A and the height of Cup B. Color each bar to match the leaf color. Look for a pattern across all teams, not just your own.
Why would a shade plant grow taller? Plants need light to make their food. A plant in dim light stretches up, using its energy to grow toward light. Its stem gets long and thin. Its leaves stay pale because they cannot make as much green color without enough light.
Worked example 1: a claim with evidence. Aisha wrote, “Claim: less light made our bean plant taller and paler. Evidence: Cup B was 17 cm and pale. Cup A was 11 cm and dark green. Reasoning: we changed only light, so light caused the difference.” These are sample data from one team.
Worked example 2: when data are messy. Ben’s team found both plants about the same height. They noticed the shade box had slipped, and Cup B got sun in the afternoon. Ben wrote, “Our test was not fair, so we will use the class graph as evidence.” Good scientists say when something went wrong.
Inherited plus environment. Both plants inherited the traits of bean plants. The environment, how much light they got, changed how tall and how green they grew. That solves our plant twin puzzle.
Use the class bar graph.
Write your explanation.
Write a claim, evidence and reasoning about our sun and shade test. Use your own team's numbers or the class graph. End with one sentence for our museum guide.
Our data showed that the environment can change a plant’s traits. Next time, we play a camouflage game to see how some traits help animals survive.
Exit ticket: explain the plant twin puzzle from 1.01 in two sentences. Use the words inherited and environment.
Pacing: 6 min measuring, 8 min reading, 7 min lecture, 12 min graph and practice, 7 min explanation and exit ticket.
Materials: Cups A and B (10-14 days after 1.08), rulers, color strips, a large class bar graph, crayons in greens and yellow-green.
Plant care: after today, move all shade plants into the light and keep watering. Students can watch the pale leaves green up over a few days. If seedlings did not grow, use the sample data in Worked example 1 and say it is sample data.
Likely misconceptions: “the taller plant is healthier”; “the shade plant is a different kind of bean.” Point to the seeds coming from the same bag.
Support / stretch: a CER frame with boxes. Stretch: what other environment change could alter a bean plant’s traits? (Less water, poorer soil.)
Answer guide: claim: less light made the plant taller and paler. Evidence: heights and colors from data. Reasoning: only light changed. Exit ticket: both plants inherited bean traits, but the environment (light) changed their height and color.
NASA, Growing Plants in Space · NASA content is generally not subject to U.S. copyright
Let’s go back to NASA’s page about growing plants in space. This time, look at what happens when the environment is not right.
Plants need light, water, air and nutrients. They need them in balance. Too much or too little can cause problems.
Astronauts once grew zinnia flowers in the Veggie garden. The zinnias got too much water. The air did not move around them very well. A fungus started to grow, and some of the plants died. The astronauts took care of the rest, and those plants got healthy again.
NASA also chooses light carefully. Lights above the plants give the kinds of light plants grow best in. Plants use a lot of red and blue light.
On the station, plants also use light to help them know which way to grow.
All of the zinnias were the same kind of plant. But how they grew depended on their water and air. The environment made a big difference.
Source: NASA, Growing Plants in Space (nasa.gov)