explain how a difference in a trait can help some members of a kind of animal or plant survive and have young.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Play “spot the moth.” Your teacher shows a picture of dark tree bark with paper moths on it, some light and some dark. Which moths did you find first?
On dark tree bark, which moths are hardest for a bird to see?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Museum makers, Panel 5 is about helpful differences. Members of one kind of living thing are not all the same. Some moths are lighter and some are darker. Some rose bushes have longer thorns. These differences can matter.
A helpful trait is an advantage. An advantage is something that gives one living thing a better chance than others. A moth that blends in with bark is less likely to be eaten. It is more likely to live long enough to have young.
Why it matters. Animals that survive can find mates and have young. Plants that survive can make seeds. So a helpful trait can help a living thing survive, find a mate and reproduce.
Worked example 1: Hana’s moth count. This is sample data. Hana’s class placed 10 light and 10 dark paper moths on dark bark paper. A “bird” picked moths for 30 seconds. It found 8 light moths and 2 dark moths. Hana wrote: “Dark moths were harder to find. On dark bark, being dark is an advantage.”
Worked example 2: Theo’s thorns. Theo writes about a plant where some bushes have longer thorns than others. “Deer eat fewer leaves from bushes with longer thorns. Those bushes keep more leaves, so they can grow and make more seeds.” He explains the cause and the effect.
Panel 5 plan. A picture of two individuals of one kind, with one difference. An arrow from trait to survival to young. Two facts as evidence.
Use the reading and Hana’s sample data.
Write Panel 5.
Draw two individuals of one kind, like a light moth and a dark moth. Label the difference and show which one has the advantage, and where.
Write for visitors: how does the helpful trait lead to more young? Use the words survive and reproduce.
All five panels have first drafts! Next time, another team will critique our panels against the criteria.
Exit ticket: On white snow, would a light or dark moth have the advantage? Explain.
How confident are you that you can I can tell which version of a trait gives an advantage in a place.
Pacing (40 min): Do Now with moth hunt 7, reading 6, instruction 8, guided practice 10, drafting 7, closure 2.
Materials: dark bark-pattern paper, 10 light and 10 dark paper moths per group, timer, Panel 5 poster.
Boundary: 3-LS4-2 is about differences among individuals of the same species and their advantage in surviving, finding mates and reproducing. Do not introduce genes or how new species form.
Misconceptions: animals choose or try to change color to survive (the ptarmigan’s seasonal change is a trait it has; differences among individuals are already there); a trait is helpful everywhere (a dark moth is easy to see on snow).
Supports: frame “___ helps it survive because ___. Then it can ___.” Stretch: predict the moth count on light bark.
Answer guide: on white snow, a light moth blends in and has the advantage. Strong explanations link trait, survival and having young.
National Park Service, Rocky Mountain National Park, Animal Camouflage · U.S. government work, public domain
Many animals have colors that help them blend in with what is around them. This is called camouflage. Animals use it in different ways.
Camouflage can help an animal hide from predators, the animals that hunt it. The ptarmigan is a bird that lives high in the mountains. In summer, its feathers match the colors of the rocks. In winter, it turns snowy white. It can also stay very still for a long time. This helps it hide from hawks, eagles, coyotes and foxes.
Predators use camouflage too. It helps them sneak close to their food. A coyote that chases a rabbit for a long way can use up more energy than the rabbit gives it. Getting close without being seen can mean the difference between eating and going hungry.
Some small hunters, like spiders, use camouflage both ways. They hide from the animals that hunt them. They are also hard for their own food to see.
Camouflage saves energy. It helps animals stay safe or find food. Both help them survive.
Source: National Park Service, Rocky Mountain National Park, Animal Camouflage (nps.gov)