judge whether our evidence shows that living in a group helps animals survive, and explain how losing the group could make survival harder.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look back at your Many Eyes data from 1.09. A classmate says, “Our game proves that all animals are safer in groups.” Do you agree?
Is one classroom game enough to prove something about all animals?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Is the evidence enough? A good scientist asks two questions about evidence. Does it really show what I claim? Do I have enough of it? One game or one animal is a start, not the finish.
Our evidence so far. (1) Many Eyes game: bigger groups spotted the fox faster. (2) Elephants: the herd bunches around calves when danger comes. (3) Wolves: packs hunt large animals together and defend their territory. Today we add (4) honey bees: in winter, they crowd together in a ball to stay warm, so the colony survives the cold.
Worked example 1: does it match the claim? Noah’s claim was “Groups help animals get food.” He used the elephant evidence. His partner pointed out that the elephant evidence is about safety, not food. Noah switched to the wolf evidence, which shows packs hunting large animals. Now his evidence matches his claim.
Worked example 2: is there enough? Amara claimed, “Living in groups helps animals get food, stay safe and handle changes.” She had evidence for food (wolves), safety (elephants, Many Eyes) and changes (bees). She wrote, “I have at least one example for each part. More examples would make it stronger.”
Losing the group. What if an animal loses its group? A wolf alone cannot easily hunt an elk. An elephant calf without a herd has no one to warn it or crowd around it. A single bee cannot stay warm in winter. Losing the group can make survival harder.
Groups are not perfect. Members of a group must share food. Big groups need more food. Scientists weigh both sides.
Judge the evidence with your team.
Write an argument.
Claim: living in a group helps animals survive. Give two pieces of evidence from two different animals. Then explain how losing the group could make survival harder for one of them. Finish: is your evidence enough? Why or why not?
Our argument about groups now uses evidence from a model and from real animals. Next time, we put everything together for our museum guide.
Exit ticket: what is one more piece of evidence that would make our group argument stronger?
Pacing: 5 min Do Now, 8 min reading, 8 min lecture, 12 min evidence sort and practice, 7 min argument and exit ticket.
Materials: 1.09 data tables, evidence cards (Many Eyes, elephants, wolves, honey bees), a claim-evidence chart.
Background: honey bees cluster in a tight ball in winter and shiver their flight muscles to make heat; the cluster keeps the colony alive. Use this as teacher-given evidence.
Likely misconceptions: “animals live in groups because they like each other”; “one example proves a rule.” Praise students who say they need more evidence.
Support / stretch: argument frame with three boxes. Stretch: name a cost of living in a group and decide if the benefits are bigger.
Answer guide: two matched pieces of evidence (wolves and food; elephants and safety; bees and cold). Losing the group: a lone wolf struggles to hunt elk; a calf has no protection. A strong answer says the evidence is a good start but more animals would make it stronger.
National Park Service, Yellowstone National Park, Wolf Ecology · U.S. government work, public domain
Let’s go back to the park’s page about wolves. This time we look for evidence about life in a pack.
Wolves are very social animals. They live in packs, and each wolf has a role. Packs in the park are often about 10 to 12 wolves. One pack once had 37 wolves!
A pack helps wolves get food. Working together, wolves can hunt large animals that most other predators cannot kill. In winter, most of their food is elk. They also hunt bison, and deer in summer.
A pack also defends its home area, called a territory. Packs warn other packs to stay away. They howl, and they leave scent marks. When packs fight, larger packs often beat smaller ones.
The pack raises pups together, too. It stays near the den for weeks while the pups are small.
So for wolves, the pack helps with food, safety and raising young.
Source: National Park Service, Yellowstone National Park, Wolf Ecology (home.nps.gov)