plan and set up a fair test to find out how light changes the traits of bean plants, and describe how surroundings can differ for one kind of plant.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Measure our bean seedlings from 1.03 and add the heights to the plant log. Remember the puzzle from 1.01: a shady plant grew taller but paler than its twin in the sun.
What will happen to a bean seedling kept in a dim corner for one week?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Surroundings. A living thing’s environment is everything around it: light, water, food, soil and temperature. Two plants of the same kind can grow up in different environments. The environment can change some of their traits.
A fair test. We want to know if light changes a bean plant’s height and leaf color. In a fair test, we change only one thing. Here that is light. Everything else stays the same: the same kind of seed, the same soil, the same cup and the same amount of water.
Our setup. Each team picks two seedlings that are about the same height. Cup A goes in a sunny window. Cup B goes in a shady spot, under a cardboard box with one side open. Both get 30 mL of water every other day. Every few days, measure height and match leaf color to a color strip.
Worked example 1: is it fair? Grace’s team wanted to give the sunny plant more water because it looked thirsty. Tariq said, “Then we changed two things. We would not know if light or water made the difference.” The team kept the water the same.
Worked example 2: practice with sample data. Rosa’s class did this test last year. After 10 days, the sunny plant was 12 cm tall and dark green. The shady plant was 18 cm tall, thin and pale yellow-green. These are sample data. Rosa wrote, “The shady plant was taller but paler. Light made the difference.”
Inherited and environment, together. Both seedlings inherited bean plant traits. But how tall they grow and how green they look can depend on their environment. We will check our own results in about two weeks.
Plan your fair test with your team.
Write your plan.
Write the plan in three parts: what we change, what we keep the same, and what we measure. Draw both cups in their places.
Our cups are in place. In about two weeks, our data will help us explain the plant twin puzzle. Next time, we turn to animals that live in groups.
Exit ticket: why is our plant test fair? Name one thing we keep the same.
Pacing: 5 min measuring, 8 min reading, 8 min lecture, 12 min planning and setup, 7 min plan writing and exit ticket.
Materials: two matched seedlings per team (from 1.03), one cardboard box per team with one side cut open, a 30 mL measuring cup, a green color strip (dark green to yellow-green), rulers, the plant log.
Humane care for plants: do not put the shade cup in total darkness for more than two weeks; after the test, move both plants to light and keep caring for them. Results are read in 1.11; if seedlings are slow, use the labeled sample data.
Likely misconceptions: “taller always means healthier”; “plants in the shade will not grow at all.” Do not resolve yet; let the data speak in 1.11.
Support / stretch: a plan template with three boxes. Stretch: add a third cup that gets the sun but only half the water. What is changed now?
Answer guide: change: light. Keep the same: seed kind, soil, cup, water, temperature. Measure: height in cm and leaf color. A strong prediction gives a reason, such as plants stretching toward light.
NASA, Growing Plants in Space · NASA content is generally not subject to U.S. copyright
Astronauts on the International Space Station grow plants. NASA wants astronauts to have fresh food on long trips. Plants also make the station a nicer place to live.
One plant garden on the station is called Veggie. It is about the size of a carry-on suitcase. It usually holds six plants.
Plants need light, water, air and nutrients. In Veggie, each plant grows in a small “pillow.” The pillow gives the roots water, nutrients and air. In space, water does not act the way it does on Earth. The pillows help keep roots from drowning.
Lights shine down on the plants. Plants use a lot of red and blue light. They reflect much of the green light. So the Veggie garden often glows a pinkish purple color.
On Earth, plants can tell up from down. In space, there is no gravity to help. So plants use light and other clues to decide which way to grow.
Astronauts have grown lettuce, cabbage, kale and zinnia flowers. Getting light and water just right is a big part of the job.
Source: NASA, Growing Plants in Space (nasa.gov)