describe the nature center pond before and after dry summers, explain the problem for frogs, and restate our design criteria and constraints.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Picture a puddle on a hot summer day. What happens to it by the afternoon? Now picture a whole pond in a long, dry summer. Tell a partner.
Frogs lay eggs in water. What happens if a pond dries up before the tadpoles grow up?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Habitat Rescue Team, welcome to Build. In Make Sense you wrote our design brief. Now you will design, test and improve a plan for the nature center pond.
Our design brief, in plain words. Our client is the staff of our community nature center. Their pond gets smaller every dry summer, and volunteers counted fewer frogs this year. They asked us for a plan to help the plants and animals that live there.
Criteria are what the plan must do. 1. Keep some water in the pond all summer. 2. Give frogs and other animals shelter at the edge. 3. Keep food sources, like insects and water plants.
Constraints are our limits. 1. A small budget: $200 (a sample amount). 2. Volunteers can work only on weekends. 3. No digging with big machines. 4. Anything near the water must be safe for children.
Before the change. In a wet year the pond is full. Cattails and water plants grow at the edge. Frogs hide in the plants, catch insects and lay eggs in the water.
The change. Dry summers shrink the pond. Mud shows where water used to be. The edge plants dry out. Volunteers counted fewer frogs this year.
Worked example 1: Priya’s change chain. Priya wrote: “Before: a full pond with plants at the edge. Change: dry summers. Problem: the pond shrinks, so tadpoles and edge plants lose water. Effect: fewer frogs.”
Worked example 2: Marcus checks the brief. Marcus asked, “Does a new concrete pond fit?” No: it needs big machines and costs far more than $200. “Do rain barrels and edge plants fit?” Yes: they are cheap and volunteers can set them up on a weekend.
How we test it on a tabletop model. Our model has a nature center roof (a tilted plastic lid), a clear cup for the pond and a tray of soil around it. Rain test: the teacher pours a 200 mL “summer storm” on the roof. The plan must save at least 100 mL for the pond. Shade test: under a warm lamp for 10 minutes, the pond water must stay at least 2 degrees C cooler than an open cup. Edge check: plants or rocks around at least half of the pond edge, and water plants in the pond. Limits check: sample cost $200 or less, hand tools only, built in one class period (our stand-in for one volunteer weekend), a lid on the barrel and nothing sharp.
| Before (a wet year) | After (a dry summer) | |
|---|---|---|
| The pond | ||
| The edge plants | ||
| The frogs |
Fill in the before-and-after table with your team. Use the reading.
Write the problem in your own words.
Finish these sentences. Before, the pond ___. Now dry summers cause this problem: ___. If nothing changes, ___.
Write our three criteria and our four constraints in your own words.
You named the problem and the goals, Rescue Team. Next you will dream up two different ways to solve it.
Exit ticket: what is the difference between a criterion and a constraint? Give one of each from our plan.
Pacing: warm-up 4, reading 8, mini lecture 9, table and checks 12, writing and exit 7 minutes.
Misconceptions: “the frogs can just move to a new pond” (there may be none nearby); “we can make it rain” (we cannot change the weather, but we can save and keep water). Keep to this one change: dry summers. Do not frame it as climate change.
Supports: post the design brief from 2.14 with picture icons. Offer the frame “Before ___. Change ___. Problem ___.” Stretch: ask what other pond animals the change might affect.
Answer guide: strong answers name dry summers as the change, connect it to tadpoles needing water, and predict fewer frogs. Criteria answers say what the plan does; constraint answers name cost, weekend time, no big machines or child safety.
U.S. Geological Survey, Resilience of native amphibian communities following catastrophic drought · USGS-authored information, U.S. public domain
Amphibians are animals like frogs, toads and newts. Many lay their eggs in ponds.
Scientists watched the amphibians in one region for ten years. They checked 233 ponds and did more than 2,000 surveys. A survey is a careful look and count.
During those years there was a very bad drought. A drought is a long time with much less rain than usual. Before the drought, fewer than 20 out of 100 ponds dried up in a year. In the worst drought year, 51 out of 100 ponds dried up.
Almost every kind of amphibian laid fewer eggs during the drought. Some kinds were found in more than one quarter fewer ponds.
There was good news too. After the drought, the native amphibians came back quickly. Ponds that held water all year kept more native amphibians during the dry years than ponds that dried up.
So water that lasts all year helps amphibians get through dry times.
Source: U.S. Geological Survey, Resilience of native amphibian communities following catastrophic drought (usgs.gov)