make a claim about how well a real kind of solution helps animals after a habitat changes, using evidence.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. A river has a wall built across it. Fish swim up the river each year to lay eggs. Draw what happens to the fish.
What could help fish get past a wall in a river?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Rescue Team, you are not the only ones solving this kind of problem. All over, people design solutions when a habitat changes.
A claim about merit. Merit means how good something is. A claim about merit says how well a solution solves the problem. It needs evidence. The evidence must be about the problem, and there must be enough of it.
Think in systems. A solution changes one part of a system. Then other parts change too. A fish ladder changes the river. Then more fish reach their egg-laying places. Then there may be more young fish.
Worked example 1: Zara’s claim. “The catch-and-carry system helps many young salmon get past the dams. Evidence: more than 850,000 young salmon traveled downstream after it was built.” Her evidence is about the fish, so it is related. Is it enough? Zara says she also wants to know how many adults come back now, to compare with the 99 in 1985.
Worked example 2: Eli checks his evidence. Eli wrote, “The fish ladder is good because it is pretty.” His teammate asked, “Does pretty help fish?” Eli changed his evidence to fish counts. Evidence must connect to the problem.
Needs change over time. A town may need more water or more power. A nature center may get more visitors. People’s needs and wants change, so plans must change too.
Read the case study and the career spotlight. Then check your thinking.
Connect this to our pond.
Write a claim about how well your Version 2 plan helps the frogs. Use one number from your data.
Your plan changes one part of the pond system. What other parts might change because of it?
Minnow Brook is a made-up stream. A small old dam was built across it long ago. Fish swim up Minnow Brook each spring to lay eggs. The dam blocks them. In this sample story, only 20 fish make it past each year.
Team 1 suggests a fish ladder beside the dam. The dam can stay, so the pond behind it stays too. It costs a medium amount.
Team 2 suggests taking the old dam out. It costs the most at first. The pond behind the dam would drain and become a stream again.
The town compares both ideas using data from similar streams. In this sample story, the ladder lets 300 fish pass each year. Removing the dam lets 500 fish pass.
Think about it: Which solution has more merit for the fish? Which has more merit for the animals that use the pond behind the dam? Use the numbers in your answer.
Real solutions are judged with evidence. Next lesson, we review the science of the whole unit.
Exit ticket: how might the nature center's needs change in the future? Give one example.
Pacing: warm-up 4, reading 7, mini lecture 6, case study 6, checks 10, writing and exit 7 minutes.
Misconceptions: “people only harm habitats” (people also design solutions); “one big number is enough evidence” (good evidence compares before and after). Minnow Brook and its numbers are invented.
Supports: offer the frame “I claim ___ because ___ shows ___.” Stretch: weigh the drained pond as a cost of removing the dam.
Answer guide: either Minnow Brook choice is fine if it uses fish numbers and names a cost or trade-off, such as pond animals losing the pond. System answers for our pond might name more water, more tadpoles growing up, more edge insects or more birds that eat frogs. Future-needs answers might name more visitors, a bigger trail or a larger budget.
NOAA Fisheries, Successful Fish Passage Efforts Across the Nation · U.S. government work, public domain
Some fish, like salmon, shad and sturgeon, need to reach fresh water in rivers. There they lay eggs, and their young grow. Some travel thousands of miles.
A dam is a wall built across a river. Dams can block the fish. They can also make the water warmer, which can help fish from other places that eat them.
People have tried many solutions. Some remove a dam. Some build a fish ladder, a set of small water steps that fish can swim and jump up. Eels get a sloping ramp with pegs that they can climb. When a dam is too tall for a ladder, workers catch fish and carry them past it.
Each blocked river needs its own plan.
People use numbers to see if a plan works. At one river with dams, only 99 adult salmon of one kind came back in 1985. Later, a catch-and-carry system was built. Since then, more than 850,000 young salmon of that kind have traveled downstream past the dams. Those dams still make electricity for people.
Source: NOAA Fisheries, Successful Fish Passage Efforts Across the Nation (fisheries.noaa.gov)