compare what three organisms need to live and make a claim about which survive well, less well, or not at all in a habitat.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Picture a fish, a cactus and a frog, all moved into a wet, muddy pond.
Which one would have the hardest time in the pond?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Rescue Team, one habitat, three results. When we put organisms in a habitat, some survive well: they live, grow and have young. Some survive less well: a few live, but they struggle. Some do not survive at all.
Why? It depends on a match. Does the habitat have what the organism needs? The better the match, the better it survives.
| Organism (sample) | Needs | Count at start | Count after one year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pond snail | water all the time, water plants to eat | 20 | 45 |
| Toad | water for eggs, but damp land to live on | 20 | 12 |
| Cactus | dry, sandy soil, lots of sun | 20 | 0 |
This is sample data from an imaginary pond that is wet all year.
Worked example 1: survives well. Ana read the table. The snails went from 20 to 45. She wrote: “Claim: pond snails survive well here. They need water all the time, and this pond always has water.”
Worked example 2: survives less well. Eli saw the toads drop from 20 to 12. He wrote: “Toads survive less well. The pond gives water for eggs, but there is not much damp land around it.”
Your turn. Use the cactus row to write a claim about the third result.
Use the sample table from the always-wet pond.
Compare all three organisms.
Write three claims, one for each organism in the table. Use the words survives well, survives less well or does not survive, and give one reason from its needs.
The same habitat helps some organisms and not others. Next time, we look at the traits that help animals survive in a tough habitat.
Exit ticket: if the pond dried up every summer, which organism in our table might struggle most? Why?
Pacing: warm-up 3 min, reading 8, mini lecture 9, practice 10, three claims 7, exit ticket 3.
Materials: the sample table on chart paper; optional organism picture cards.
Note on the reading: the page says “specialist” and “generalist” species; the summary uses “picky” and “flexible” as kid-friendly words for those ideas. You may introduce the real words as a stretch.
Misconceptions: “The cactus died because it was weak.” Push for the match between needs and habitat features.
Boundary: the exit ticket previews habitat change; keep it to a quick prediction, since 3-LS4-4 is developed in part 2.
Answer guide: the pond snail, because it needs water all the time; accept the toad with a reason about its eggs.
National Park Service, Food, Water, Shelter, and Space (lesson plan) · National Park Service content, U.S. government work, public domain
Every living thing needs food, water, shelter and space. The place where it gets these things is its habitat. You can think of a habitat as a home.
Some organisms can live only in a very special habitat. They might need a certain temperature. They might need one kind of soil, or one kind of food. We can call them picky organisms. The page says they are very easily harmed when their environment changes.
Other organisms can live in many kinds of habitats. People are one example. We can call them flexible organisms. A change in the environment is less likely to harm them.
On some islands, many plants and animals came to need very special habitats. When those habitats are disturbed, the plants and animals can be in danger. Some could even become extinct.
That is why people should learn about the habitats of other living things and treat them with respect.
Source: National Park Service, Food, Water, Shelter, and Space (lesson plan) (nps.gov)