describe the limits on our rescue plan, such as cost, materials and time, and write a design brief that defines the problem.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. You want to throw a class party. You have $20, one hour and the classroom only.
What do we call the $20, the one hour and the classroom?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Rescue Team, every plan has limits. Constraints are the limits on a design. Common ones are cost (how much money), materials (what we can use) and time (how long we have). Safety is a limit too.
Our client’s limits. The nature center staff told us: a small budget, sample amount $200; volunteers can work only on weekends; no digging with big machines; and anything near the water must be safe for children.
Worked example 1: is it within the limits? Sofia suggested a new concrete pond. The team checked: it needs big machines and costs far more than $200. It breaks two constraints. They crossed it out.
Worked example 2: a plan that fits. Marcus suggested rain barrels that collect water from the nature center roof, plus native plants at the edge for shade and shelter. The team checked: low cost, volunteers can do it on weekends, no big machines. It fits the constraints.
Our design brief. A design brief puts it all on one page: the client, the problem, the criteria and the constraints. It does not choose the solution yet. In part 2, teams will design, test and improve their rescue plans.
| Design brief part | Our class answer |
|---|---|
| Client | |
| Problem | |
| Criteria (musts) | |
| Constraints (limits) |
Use Sofia’s and Marcus’s examples and the reading.
Fill in your own copy of the design brief table.
Write our design brief: the client, the problem in one sharp sentence, three criteria and three constraints.
Our design brief is ready. In part 2, teams will dream up rescue plans, test them against the brief and make them better.
Exit ticket: pick one constraint. How might it change the kind of rescue plan we design?
Pacing: warm-up 3 min, reading 7, mini lecture 9, practice 9, design brief 9, exit ticket 3.
Materials: the criteria chart from 2.13, a design brief template, and the client’s constraints on chart paper. The $200 budget is a sample; adjust it to fit your real partner if you have one.
Misconceptions: students mix criteria and constraints. Criteria say what the plan must do; constraints say what limits it.
Assessment: the design brief checks 1a (problem from a need), 2a (focused on now), 3a (criteria) and 3b (constraints) together.
Answer guide: client, the nature center staff; problem, the pond shrinks in dry summers and pond animals need water and shelter; criteria, keep some water all summer, shelter at the edge, food for animals; constraints, $200, weekend volunteers, no big machines, safe for children. Exit ticket example: the small budget means we choose cheap materials like rain barrels and plants.
NOAA Fisheries, Habitat Conservation: How We Restore · U.S. government work (NOAA), public domain
Let’s reread the NOAA page and look for limits that people face.
Habitats are being lost fast. The page says coastal areas in much of our country lose about 80,000 acres of coastal wetlands each year. That is about seven football fields every hour. Building, draining, erosion, sinking land and rising seas all play a part.
Restoration costs money. It also makes jobs. One study found about 15 jobs for every $1 million spent on restoration projects.
Restoration takes time. The page warns that damaged habitat might take decades to recover, if it recovers at all. A decade is ten years.
So protecting is smart. The page says preventing harm is a wise investment. Some problems can be made smaller, or even avoided, by protecting habitats before they are damaged.
Source: NOAA Fisheries, Habitat Conservation: How We Restore (fisheries.noaa.gov)