sort traits into inherited traits and traits changed by the environment, and use evidence to explain the kitten and flamingo puzzles.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Check the butterfly habitat and the bean cups. Then think back to 1.02. A flamingo chick is gray. Its parents are pink.
Where does a flamingo's pink color come from?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Two causes of traits. Some traits are inherited: they come from parents, like a wolf’s pointed ears or a kitten’s fur color. Some traits are changed by the environment: things around the living thing, like food, water and light. Many traits depend on both.
Solving the kitten puzzle. The four kittens inherited cat traits from their parents. That is why they are alike. As siblings, they can inherit different versions of a trait, like fur color. That is why they are different. Both patterns are evidence that traits are inherited.
Solving the flamingo puzzle. Flamingo chicks inherit flamingo traits from their parents, like long legs. But pink color needs the right food. The environment adds to the trait.
Worked example 1: sorting traits. Hana sorted these cards. Inherited: a bean seed grows into a bean plant; a wolf pup’s coat color. Environment: a dog’s short hair from a haircut; a plant’s pale leaves from little light. Both: a flamingo’s pink feathers; a plant’s height.
Worked example 2: a clear explanation. Yusuf wrote, “The kittens are siblings. They are alike because they inherited cat traits. They are different because siblings can inherit different fur colors.” He used evidence words and made a claim.
Learned behaviors count too. A dog that learned to sit did not inherit that trick. Training, a scar or a haircut all come from what happened in an animal’s life, not from its parents.
Sort and explain with your team.
Explain one of our puzzles.
Explain the kitten puzzle or the flamingo puzzle. Write a claim, give two pieces of evidence, and use the word inherited or environment.
Some traits come from parents, some from the environment, and many from both. Next time, our bean plant data will test the plant twin puzzle.
Exit ticket: name one inherited trait and one environment trait of any animal. Tell how you know.
Pacing: 5 min Do Now, 8 min reading, 8 min lecture, 12 min sorting and practice, 7 min explanation and exit ticket.
Materials: trait sort cards (inherited / environment / both / learned), the 1.06 tables, flamingo photos.
Boundary: no genes or prediction of offspring. “Siblings can inherit different versions of a trait” is as far as grade 3 goes. Keep all traits to plants and animals, never students or their families.
Likely misconceptions: “an animal can pass on a scar or trick to its young”; “flamingos are born pink.” The reading corrects the second.
Support / stretch: claim frame: “The ___ are alike because ___. They differ because ___.” Stretch: what might happen to a zoo flamingo that got food without the pigments? (The reading does not say; students predict that the feathers would not turn as pink, and label it a prediction.)
Answer guide: kitten claim: they are siblings that inherited cat traits but different fur colors; evidence: whiskers, tails and ears match; colors differ. Flamingo: inherited flamingo body; pink from pigments in food. Exit ticket: e.g., inherited ear shape; environment: a scar or pale leaves.
Smithsonian's National Zoo and Conservation Biology Institute, Why Are Flamingos Pink? And Other Flamingo Facts · Copyright Smithsonian Institution; no reuse license stated on the page. Retold here in our own words.
Remember the gray flamingo chicks? Let’s go back to the National Zoo page to solve their mystery.
Flamingos are not pink when they hatch. The chicks have white-gray, fluffy feathers. It takes several years for a flamingo to get its pink color.
So where does the pink come from? It comes from food! Flamingos eat tiny living things called algae. They also eat small animals called brine shrimp. These foods hold colorful pigments. A pigment is a material that gives something its color.
As a flamingo eats algae and shrimp, its body uses the pigments. The pigments end up in its feathers and turn them pink.
Here is a fun link. The same kind of pigments give carrots and tomatoes their colors.
So a flamingo’s pink feathers depend on what it eats. The food in its environment helps make the trait.
Source: Smithsonian's National Zoo and Conservation Biology Institute, Why Are Flamingos Pink? And Other Flamingo Facts (nationalzoo.si.edu)