model how differences in color among animals of one kind can help some survive, and explain why a helpful trait gives an advantage.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Check the butterfly habitat. Then look at the picture of white sand dunes. Can you find the white lizard hiding on the sand?
On a sheet of newspaper, which paper moths will birds find first?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Camouflage. Camouflage is a color or pattern that helps an animal blend in with its surroundings. A moth that matches tree bark is hard for a bird to see.
Today’s model. Each team spreads a sheet of newspaper on the table. The teacher scatters 20 white paper moths and 20 newspaper-print paper moths on it. One student is the “bird.” The bird has 15 seconds to pick up moths one at a time. Then count the moths left of each kind. Switch birds and repeat three rounds.
| Round | White moths left | Newspaper moths left |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||
| 2 | ||
| 3 |
Worked example 1: reading results. Sam’s team had 6 white moths left and 15 newspaper moths left after one round. These are sample data. Sam wrote, “More newspaper moths survived. Their color helped them hide.”
Worked example 2: an advantage. Maya thought about what happens next. “The moths that survive can find mates and lay eggs. So moths that blend in get to have more young.” A trait that helps a living thing survive and have young is an advantage.
Same kind, different survival. All our paper moths were the same kind. The only difference was color. On a different background, like white paper, the white moths would hide better. Whether a trait helps depends on where the animal lives.
Use your team’s data table.
Write about your data.
Use your team's numbers. Which moths survived better? Explain why, and tell how surviving could help them have more young.
Differences among animals of one kind can help some survive, find mates and have young. Next time, we check whether our evidence about animal groups is strong enough.
Exit ticket: would a white moth have an advantage on dark tree bark? Explain.
Pacing: 5 min Do Now, 8 min reading, 6 min lecture, 14 min moth game (three rounds), 7 min practice and exit ticket.
Materials: per team one newspaper sheet, 20 white and 20 newspaper-print moths (precut with a moth template), a timer, data tables.
Boundary: 3-LS4-2 is about how variation gives an advantage in surviving, finding mates and reproducing. The reading’s page mentions genes; leave that out. Avoid saying animals “choose” or “try” to change color.
Likely misconceptions: “the moth changed its color to hide”; “camouflage always works everywhere.” The white-paper question addresses both.
Support / stretch: results frame: “___ moths survived better because ___.” Stretch: predict the moths after many rounds if survivors could have young that look like them.
Answer guide: newspaper moths usually survive better on newspaper; reasoning: harder for the bird to see, so more survive to mate and lay eggs. Lizard: blends with white sand, so predators spot it less. Exit ticket: no, a white moth stands out on dark bark.
National Park Service, White Sands National Park, White Animals at White Sands · U.S. government work, public domain
One national park has huge dunes of white sand. The National Park Service studies the animals that live there.
Some animals on the dunes are lighter in color than the same kinds of animals that live off the dunes. Scientists have found pale lizards, spiders, toads, mice and insects there. One lizard is called the bleached earless lizard. It is much lighter than a similar lizard that lives just outside the dunes.
Why be pale? Scientists think the light color is camouflage. That means it helps the animal blend in with the white sand. Then it is harder for a hungry predator to spot. The park says more tests are still needed to be sure.
The page explains how this could happen. Brothers and sisters can differ a little in color. The lighter young blend in better, so they are less likely to be eaten. More of them live to have young of their own.
Not every dune animal is pale. Most of the insects and mammals scientists collected were not unusual in color. So camouflage is one way to survive, but not the only one.
Source: National Park Service, White Sands National Park, White Animals at White Sands (nps.gov)