decide if evidence is enough to support a claim, and use evidence to explain how needs and habitat features cause different survival outcomes.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. A volunteer visited the nature center pond once, on a cold, rainy morning. She saw zero frogs. She said, “There are no frogs here.”
Is one cold, rainy visit enough evidence to say there are no frogs?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Rescue Team, is it enough? A claim needs evidence that matches it. It also needs enough evidence. One observation can fool us. Many observations at different times make us more sure.
Ask three questions. Does the evidence match the claim? Is there enough of it, from more than one time or place? Is there evidence that disagrees?
| Visit (sample) | Frogs counted | Weather |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 0 | cold, rainy morning |
| 2 | 6 | warm evening |
| 3 | 4 | warm evening |
| 4 | 5 | warm afternoon |
Worked example 1: more evidence changes the claim. With only visit 1, Ruby might say there are no frogs. With all four visits, she wrote: “Frogs do live at the pond. On warm days we counted 4 to 6. Visit 1 was cold, and frogs may hide.”
Worked example 2: cause and effect. Ahmed explained why cattails survive well at the pond edge but not on the dry hill nearby. “Cattails need wet soil. The pond edge has wet soil. The hill is dry. So the habitat feature, wet soil, causes cattails to grow well in one place and not the other.”
Need plus feature equals outcome. When we explain survival, we name the organism’s need, the habitat feature, and the result.
Use the sample visit table, Ahmed’s example and the reading.
Write a full explanation.
Explain why frogs survive well at the nature center pond when it is full. Name the frog's need, the habitat feature, and the outcome. Then write one more piece of evidence you would want to collect to be more sure.
Strong claims need matching evidence, and enough of it. Next time, we solve the mystery of the shells on the mountain.
Exit ticket: what is one question you would ask before you believe a claim about animals in a habitat?
Pacing: warm-up 4 min, reading 8, mini lecture 9, practice 10, explanation 6, exit ticket 3.
Materials: the sample visit table on chart paper, the claims from 2.09 and 2.10.
Misconceptions: “More evidence always means a bigger number.” More evidence means more observations, not more frogs.
Assessment: this lesson checks 3b again (does evidence match?) alongside the new 3c and 4a ids.
Answer guide: need: water and moist places for skin and eggs; feature: a full pond with plants at the edge; outcome: frogs survive well. Good extra evidence: counts on more days, counts of eggs or tadpoles, or counts in a dry summer.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Why Are Wetlands Important? · U.S. government work (EPA), public domain
Wetlands are some of the busiest places for life on Earth. Tiny living things, plants, insects, frogs and other amphibians, reptiles, birds, fish and mammals all live in wetlands.
The EPA calls wetlands “biological supermarkets.” Dead plants break into tiny bits. Small insects, shellfish and little fish eat those bits. Bigger animals eat the small ones.
Some organisms live only in wetlands. Wood ducks, muskrats and cattails are examples. Other animals, like otters, raccoons and deer, visit wetlands for food, water or shelter. Many birds feed and build nests there.
More than one third of the endangered and threatened species in the United States live only in wetlands. Endangered means a kind of living thing is in danger of becoming extinct.
Wetlands also act like sponges. They soak up rain and floodwater and let it go slowly.
Source: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Why Are Wetlands Important? (epa.gov)