compare fossils to living plants and animals, organize whether each has a similar living relative, and explain that some fossils come from extinct living things.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Your teacher holds up a fossil shell cast and a real shell from a beach today. Look closely at both.
How are the fossil shell and today's shell alike?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Rescue Team, let’s compare then and now. When we find a fossil, we can ask: does anything alive today look like it? Where does that living thing live?
Some have living look-alikes. Many fossil shells look like shells of sea animals alive today. Many fossil leaves look like ferns that still grow in damp, shady forests.
Some are extinct. Other fossils come from living things that are gone. Dinosaurs and mammoths are famous examples. No dinosaur like the giant ones in museums and no mammoth walks the Earth today.
| Fossil (sample) | Similar living thing today? | Where it lives now |
|---|---|---|
| Spiral shell | Yes, a sea snail | Ocean |
| Fern leaf | Yes, a fern | Damp, shady forest |
| Giant three-toed footprint | No, extinct | None |
Worked example 1: a living look-alike. Zoe compared a fossil fern to a fern from the school garden. Both had leaves split into many small parts. She wrote: “Similar. Ferns today grow in damp, shady places.”
Worked example 2: no match. Diego studied a giant footprint card. No animal alive today makes a print that big with three toes. He wrote: “No living match. This animal is probably extinct.”
Why it matters. If a fossil matches a living thing, we can ask where that living thing lives today. That gives a clue about where the fossil once lived. We use this clue next time.
Use the sample table and the reading.
Use your team’s fossil cards from 2.04.
Add two columns to your fossil table: Similar living thing? and Where it lives now. Fill them in for at least three cards.
Some fossils have living look-alikes, and some come from extinct living things. Next time, we use these clues to picture places long ago.
Exit ticket: name one way a fossil fern and a fern today are alike and one way the fossil is different.
Pacing: warm-up 4 min, reading 8, mini lecture 8, compare stations 10, practice 7, exit ticket 3.
Materials: one fossil shell cast and one modern shell, a fern or fern photo, the fossil cards and tables from 2.04.
Misconceptions: “People and dinosaurs lived at the same time.” The reading’s deeper-layers pattern helps: people fossils stop long before the older layers. Another is “a look-alike is the same kind.” Keep the language at “similar.”
Boundary: no species identification and no named time periods; dinosaurs and mammoths are named only as well-known extinct groups. Do not teach evolution mechanisms here.
Answer guide: alike: leaves split into many small parts; different: the fossil is stone, or it may be bigger or shaped a bit differently.
U.S. Geological Survey, Fossils, Rocks, and Time: Fossil Succession · USGS-authored information, U.S. public domain
The U.S. Geological Survey shares three big ideas about fossils.
First, fossils are the remains of things that were once alive.
Second, most fossils come from living things that are extinct. Extinct means that kind of living thing is not alive anywhere on Earth anymore.
Third, older rocks hold different kinds of fossils than younger rocks. That is because life on Earth has changed over time.
Imagine starting at today and digging into older and older layers. At some point, you stop finding fossils of people. Go deeper, and you stop finding flowering plants. Deeper still, there are no birds. Deeper again, there are no fish, and then no shells at all.
Scientists use this pattern too. When they find the same kinds of fossils in rocks from different places, they know those rocks are about the same age.
Source: U.S. Geological Survey, Fossils, Rocks, and Time: Fossil Succession (pubs.usgs.gov)