use fossil data and rock layers to write an explanation of how sea shells ended up high on a mountain.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look back at our Wonder Board question: How did sea shells get on top of a mountain? Read the first guesses we made in 2.01.
Which guess does our evidence support best now?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Rescue Team, time to solve our first mystery. Scientists explain with a claim, evidence and reasoning. The claim answers the question. The evidence is our data. The reasoning tells why the evidence supports the claim, using a science idea.
Our evidence so far. From 2.04 and 2.07: Hill A has sea shells, fish bones and other sea fossils at the top. From 2.06: the shells look like sea animals alive today. From 2.05 and today’s reading: layers form flat on the bottom of water and can be pushed up when mountains are built.
| Hill A layer (sample) | Fossils | Water or land? |
|---|---|---|
| 3 (top) | sea shells, fish bones | water (sea) |
| 2 | sea shells | water (sea) |
| 1 (bottom) | leaves, footprints | land |
Worked example 1: a strong claim. Noor wrote: “Claim: Hill A was once the bottom of a sea, and the land was later pushed up high.”
Worked example 2: evidence and reasoning. Caleb added: “Evidence: layers 2 and 3 have sea shells and fish bones. Reasoning: sea animals live in water, and layers form flat under water. Mountains can push layers up, so the sea floor became a hilltop.”
A bonus clue. Layer 1, at the bottom, has land fossils. It is the oldest. So this place was land first, then sea, and now high land again. Places can change more than once.
Use the Hill A sample table and the reading.
Write your own explanation.
Write a claim, two pieces of evidence and your reasoning to answer: How did sea shells end up high on Hill A? Use at least one fact from our fossil table.
Mystery one is solved: places change over very long times, and fossils are the evidence. Next time, we return to mystery two and decide what our rescue plan must do.
Exit ticket: how is the story of Hill A like the story of our nature center pond? How is it different?
Pacing: warm-up 4 min, reading 7, mini lecture 9, practice 9, written explanation 8, exit ticket 3.
Materials: the class fossil tables, the Hill A sample table, CER graphic organizer.
Misconceptions: “The sea level was as high as the mountain.” Steer toward the land moving up, which is what the reading shows. Some students think uplift is fast; stress “very, very long time.”
Boundary: no named periods, no numbers of years, no fossil names.
Answer guide: claim: Hill A was a sea floor that was later pushed up. Evidence: sea shells and fish bones in its upper layers; shells resemble living sea animals. Reasoning: sea animals live in water; layers form under water and mountain building can raise and tilt them. Exit ticket: alike, both places change; different, Hill A changed over a very long time, the pond is changing in a few years.
U.S. Geological Survey, Fossils, Rocks, and Time: Rocks and Layers · USGS-authored information, U.S. public domain
Let’s reread the Rocks and Layers page as mystery solvers. Watch for the steps in the story.
Step 1. Gravel, sand and mud settle to the bottom of rivers, lakes and oceans. They can bury animals and plants on the lake or sea bottom.
Step 2. More bits pile on top over a long time. The bottom of the pile turns into rock. Animal skeletons and plant pieces can become fossils.
Step 3. The layers start out flat, piled one on top of another. Each layer is older than the layers above it.
Step 4. Many layers are not flat anymore. They were moved by later events. Often they were tilted while mountains were being built. The page shows workers collecting fossil shells from nearly upright layers in a mountain range.
So rock that formed on a sea floor, with shells inside, can end up as part of a mountain. It just takes a very, very long time.
Source: U.S. Geological Survey, Fossils, Rocks, and Time: Rocks and Layers (pubs.usgs.gov)