use evidence to explain how a helpful trait like cactus spines helps a plant survive, and plan what each gallery of our museum guide will explain.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Check the butterfly habitat one more time. Which stage are our painted ladies in now? Then look at a photo of a cactus covered in spines. Why might a plant need spines?
What do you think a cactus's spines do?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Helpful traits in plants. Animals are not the only living things with helpful traits. Spines on a cactus and thorns on a rose are traits that protect plants. A plant that is not eaten can keep growing, make flowers and make seeds.
Variation and advantage. Plants of one kind can vary. Some may have longer or thicker spines than others. If animals eat fewer of the plants with longer spines, those plants are more likely to survive and make seeds. That is an advantage, just like the hidden moths in 1.12.
Worked example 1: a spine explanation. Tariq wrote, “Claim: longer spines can help a cactus survive and have young. Evidence: spines protect cacti from hungry animals, and cholla spines help new plants start. Reasoning: a cactus that is not eaten can grow, make seeds and spread.”
Life cycle patterns, one more time. Every living thing we studied, the bean, butterfly, frog, flamingo, bison and wolf, follows the same pattern: birth, growth, reproduction and death. If a kind of living thing stopped having young, there would be fewer and fewer of them over time.
Worked example 2: a prediction from the pattern. Grace asked, “What if every cactus in one spot was eaten before it made seeds?” She reasoned, “No seeds means no new cactus plants. When the old ones die, that spot would have no cacti.”
Our guide plan. Each team now plans one gallery: Life Cycles, Traits From Parents, Traits and Surroundings, or Helpful Traits and Groups. Pick the best evidence from our logs, tables and graphs. In part 2, we build the guide.
Use the reading and our class evidence.
Plan your team’s gallery.
Write your gallery's big idea in one sentence. List two pieces of evidence from our unit you will show. Write one question a young visitor might ask, and your answer.
We can now explain both puzzles from 1.01, how living things grow, and why traits can help. In part 2, we turn our evidence into the museum guide.
Exit ticket: pick one living thing from this unit. Explain one trait it has and how that trait helps it survive or have young.
Pacing: 5 min Do Now, 8 min reading, 8 min lecture, 10 min practice, 9 min gallery planning and exit ticket.
Materials: cactus and rose photos, all team logs, tables and graphs from 1.03-1.13, a gallery planning sheet. Do not bring real cacti; spines are painful to remove.
Butterflies: if adults have emerged, follow the care sheet. Release only if local rules allow and the weather is warm; otherwise keep them fed in the habitat. Let students record the adult stage to finish the life cycle.
Likely misconceptions: “the cactus grew spines because it wanted to”; “a trait helps everywhere.” Tie back to the moth game: whether a trait helps depends on the environment.
Support / stretch: a gallery planning template with sentence starters. Stretch: link two galleries, such as how a frog’s spots (variation) might help it hide (helpful trait).
Answer guide: big idea sentences match the gallery; evidence comes from class data or readings; visitor answers are accurate and short. Exit ticket: e.g., a cactus’s spines protect it from animals so it can make seeds; newspaper moths hide from birds and live to lay eggs.
National Park Service, Saguaro National Park, Cacti and Desert Succulents · U.S. government work, public domain
One desert national park is full of cactus plants. The National Park Service explains how cacti survive there.
The biggest clue is the spines. Spines are leaves that have changed shape. They do several jobs.
First, spines protect the cactus from hungry or thirsty animals. Second, they give the cactus shade on hot summer days. They also help keep it warm on cold winter nights. Third, spines help stop the cactus from losing water to dry winds.
Spines can even help some cacti make new plants. A cholla cactus has sharp spines. When an animal brushes against it, the spines stick into the animal’s skin. A piece of the cactus breaks off and rides along. Later it falls off. If the soil is right, it can take root and grow.
Spines come in many sizes. Some are tiny and hairlike. Others are big hooks or spikes up to 3 inches long. They are not poisonous, but they hurt a lot to pull out.
Source: National Park Service, Saguaro National Park, Cacti and Desert Succulents (nps.gov)