use evidence to explain how the environment can change a living thing’s traits.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Remember our phenomenon. A plant in the shade grew taller but paler than its twin in the sun. What was different about their environments?
Two bean plants come from seeds of the same plant. One gets plenty of water. One gets very little. What will most likely happen?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Museum makers, Panel 4 adds a twist. Many traits are inherited. But the environment can change how those traits turn out. The environment is everything around a living thing: food, water, light, soil and space.
Animals and food. A flamingo inherits the ability to have colored feathers. But the pink color comes from pigment in its food. The food in its environment changes the trait.
Plants and water or light. A plant may inherit the ability to grow tall. If it gets too little water, it may grow shorter. A plant in deep shade may grow tall and thin, with pale leaves.
Worked example 1: Rosa’s bean data. This is sample data. Rosa grew two bean plants from the same parent plant. Plant A got water every two days. After three weeks it was 20 centimeters tall. Plant B got water once a week. It was 11 centimeters tall. Rosa wrote: “Less water caused a shorter plant.”
Worked example 2: Sam’s cause and effect. Sam draws two flamingos. One eats food with lots of pigment. One eats food with little pigment. He draws an arrow from food to feather color. His label says: “Cause: pigment in food. Effect: pinker feathers.”
Panel 4 plan. A two-column picture, “same parent, different environment.” A cause-and-effect arrow. Two facts as evidence.
Use the reading and Rosa’s sample data.
Write Panel 4.
Draw a “same parent, different environment” model for a plant or an animal. Label the cause and the effect.
Write two sentences for visitors. Use the flamingo or bean evidence to explain how the environment can change a trait.
Panel 4 shows that where a living thing grows matters. Next, Panel 5: differences that help some animals survive.
Exit ticket: Could a flamingo at a zoo stay pale? What would cause it?
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading 7, instruction 9, guided practice 10, drafting 8, closure 2.
Materials: Part 1 plant growth data if you have it, flamingo picture cards, Panel 4 poster.
Boundary: keep 3-LS3-2 examples to plants and animals (food, water, light, soil). Do not use children’s own height or weight as examples.
Misconceptions: traits are either inherited or from the environment, never both; the flamingo’s pink comes from the water.
Supports: frame “Because ___, the ___ became ___.” Stretch: explain why the zoo must feed flamingos special food to keep them pink.
Answer guide: a zoo flamingo could stay pale if its food had little pigment. Cause: food. Effect: paler feathers.
Smithsonian's National Zoo and Conservation Biology Institute, American Flamingo · Copyright Smithsonian Institution; no reuse license stated on the page. Retold here in our own words.
American flamingos are tall wading birds. Many people know them for their pink feathers. But flamingos are not pink when they hatch.
A flamingo chick hatches covered in soft white feathers called down. It takes several years, and several sets of new feathers, for a young flamingo to turn pink.
Where does the pink come from? It comes from food. Flamingos eat algae, small seeds and tiny water animals such as shrimp and fly larvae. A pigment in this food gives the feathers their pink color. A pigment is a natural coloring.
Flamingos are very social birds. Some flocks have thousands of birds. After young flamingos can walk and swim, they join a big group of young birds. An adult guards the group, while the parents still feed their own chick.
About 80,000 to 90,000 American flamingos live in the wild. Most of them breed in four large groups called colonies.
Source: Smithsonian's National Zoo and Conservation Biology Institute, American Flamingo (nationalzoo.si.edu)