list the features our rescue plan must have and keep the problem focused on what the nature center needs right now.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Imagine you are building a bird feeder. Name one thing it MUST do to count as a good bird feeder.
Which is a must for a bird feeder?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Rescue Team, what counts as success? Before engineers design, they list criteria. Criteria are the features a solution must have to solve the problem. If a plan misses a criterion, it does not solve the problem.
Keep it about now. Our client needs help with the pond today. A plan to dig for fossils on Hill A would be fun, but it does not help the pond. Good engineers keep the problem focused on what people need right now.
Use what we learned. In 2.08 to 2.11 we learned that pond animals need water, food, shelter and space, and that frogs need water for their eggs. Those needs become our criteria.
Worked example 1: turning a need into a criterion. Iris knew frogs lay eggs in water. She wrote: “Criterion: the plan must keep some water in the pond all summer.”
Worked example 2: in or out? Theo suggested, “The plan should include a fossil museum.” The team asked, “Does it help pond animals now?” No. They left it out. Then Theo offered, “The plan must give frogs places to hide at the edge.” That one stayed.
Our class list. Together, we will choose three to five criteria for the Habitat Change Rescue Plan.
Use Iris’s and Theo’s examples and the reading.
Draft our criteria.
Write three criteria for the rescue plan. For each one, name the organism need it comes from.
Now we know what our plan must do. Next time, we add the limits and write our design brief.
Exit ticket: why should our criteria come from what pond organisms need?
Pacing: warm-up 3 min, reading 8, mini lecture 8, practice 9, criteria drafting and class vote 9, exit ticket 3.
Materials: the habitat needs notes from 2.08 to 2.11, chart paper titled “Our Criteria.”
Misconceptions: students mix criteria (musts) with wishes (extras). Use the bird feeder test: does it solve the problem without it?
Supports: frame: “The plan must ___ because ___ need ___.”
Answer guide: likely criteria: keep some water in the pond all summer; give frogs and other animals shelter at the edge; keep food sources, like insects and water plants; be safe for visitors. Exit ticket: the plan is for the pond organisms, so their needs tell us what success looks like.
NOAA Fisheries, Habitat Conservation: How We Restore · U.S. government work (NOAA), public domain
Habitats can be harmed. Oil and chemical spills can damage them. Building can destroy them. Dams can block rivers. When that happens, fish cannot live there anymore. That often means less food for other animals and fewer fish for people to catch.
Restoration means bringing a damaged habitat back. People can clean up after an oil spill. They can remove a dam so fish can swim back up a river.
NOAA’s restoration projects work on things like opening rivers so fish can travel, reconnecting coastal wetlands, restoring shallow corals and rebuilding oyster reefs.
Restoration helps people too. Healthy coastal habitats give clean water, support fish and wildlife, and protect towns from storms. They also support boating and fishing.
NOAA’s restoration experts do not work alone. They work with communities and partners to plan projects where they are needed most.
Source: NOAA Fisheries, Habitat Conservation: How We Restore (fisheries.noaa.gov)