give and use kind, specific feedback to check each panel against our criteria and its evidence.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Read two comments. “Your panel is boring.” “Your big idea is clear, but I wonder what ‘inherited’ means.” Which one helps a team improve?
What makes feedback helpful?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Museum makers, today we critique. A critique is a careful look at work to find what is strong and what can grow. Other people can spot problems we cannot see, because we already know what we meant to say.
Glow and Grow. Visit another team’s panel. Read it the way a visitor would. Write one Glow, something that meets a criterion well. Write one Grow, something that does not meet a criterion yet. Name the criterion each time.
Check the evidence. Ask two questions. Does each fact really support the big idea? Is there enough evidence, or does the team need more?
Worked example 1: Jada’s Glow and Grow. Jada reads Panel 2. “Glow: your wolf pack facts really show the group feeds the pups. Evidence criterion. Grow: ‘territory’ is not explained. Visitor-Friendly criterion.” She named a part and a criterion each time.
Worked example 2: Felix checks for enough evidence. Felix reads Panel 1. It shows only the monarch. The big idea says “all living things” follow the pattern. Felix writes: “Grow: one animal is not enough evidence for ‘all.’ Add a plant or a frog to your compare box.”
| Our Museum Guide Card | What it means |
|---|---|
| Criterion: Big Idea | The panel has one clear sentence that answers part of our driving question. |
| Criterion: Model | The panel has a labeled drawing, diagram, table or chart. |
| Criterion: Evidence | The panel gives at least two facts from our investigations or readings. |
| Criterion: Visitor-Friendly | Short sentences. Everyday words. Every science word is explained. A visitor can read the big idea in under 45 seconds. |
| Criterion: Accurate | The science matches our evidence. The panel is about plants and animals. |
| Constraint: Size | One poster-sized panel for each big idea. |
| Constraint: Supplies and time | Classroom art supplies only. We finish in class time. |
Rotate to two other teams’ panels. Answer these as you go.
Go back to your own panel and read your feedback.
List the Grows you got. For each one, name the criterion it is about.
Choose the one Grow you will fix first. Explain why it matters most for a visitor.
Feedback is a gift. Next time we revise and make version 2.
Exit ticket: What is one idea you saw on another team's panel that you want to borrow?
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 3, reading 6, instruction 6, two gallery rounds 9 minutes each 18, own-panel reflection 5, closure 2.
Materials: all five panel drafts posted, Glow and Grow sticky notes in two colors, Guide Card copies.
Setup: model one Glow and Grow on a sample panel first. Teams do not explain their panels during the rounds; a visitor would not have them there.
Misconceptions: feedback means saying what you like; one example proves a rule for all living things.
Supports: sticky notes with the frames “Glow: ___. Criterion: ___.” and “Grow: ___. Criterion: ___.” Stretch: rank a panel’s evidence from strongest to weakest.
Answer guide: the puppy evidence supports variation among siblings if the puppies share the same parents. Strong answers check that condition.
National Park Service, Harpers Ferry Center, Programmatic Accessibility Guidelines for Interpretive Media · U.S. government work, public domain
The National Park Service wants every visitor to enjoy its exhibits, including visitors with disabilities. So it wrote guidelines for making exhibits accessible, which means easy for everyone to use.
Here are some of the guidelines for the words. Use short, clear language and simple sentences. Use familiar words. Avoid jargon and long paragraphs. Give the meaning of hard words, and help visitors say them.
Share the main ideas at more than one level. Some visitors want only the main idea. Others want more detail.
Add easy-to-understand pictures and maps beside the words.
Here are some guidelines for how the words look. Text should be big enough to read. Words at eye level should be at least 24 point, and bigger if people read from farther away. Letters and background need strong contrast, so one is much darker than the other. Do not put red words on green, or green words on red. A busy picture behind words can make them hard to read.
Source: National Park Service, Harpers Ferry Center, Programmatic Accessibility Guidelines for Interpretive Media (nps.gov)