build Version 1 of our pond rescue model within our limits and plan one test for each criterion and constraint.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Look at your two sketches and your shade data. Circle the plan you will build. Write one reason.
What is a prototype?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Rescue Team, it is building day. Choose your plan. Buy your supplies from the sample price list. Write down every cost.
Our design brief, in plain words. Our client is the staff of our community nature center. Their pond gets smaller every dry summer, and volunteers counted fewer frogs this year. They asked us for a plan to help the plants and animals that live there.
Criteria are what the plan must do. 1. Keep some water in the pond all summer. 2. Give frogs and other animals shelter at the edge. 3. Keep food sources, like insects and water plants.
Constraints are our limits. 1. A small budget: $200 (a sample amount). 2. Volunteers can work only on weekends. 3. No digging with big machines. 4. Anything near the water must be safe for children.
How we test it on a tabletop model. Our model has a nature center roof (a tilted plastic lid), a clear cup for the pond and a tray of soil around it. Rain test: the teacher pours a 200 mL “summer storm” on the roof. The plan must save at least 100 mL for the pond. Shade test: under a warm lamp for 10 minutes, the pond water must stay at least 2 degrees C cooler than an open cup. Edge check: plants or rocks around at least half of the pond edge, and water plants in the pond. Limits check: sample cost $200 or less, hand tools only, built in one class period (our stand-in for one volunteer weekend), a lid on the barrel and nothing sharp.
Why we test. The purpose of a test is to find failure points. A failure point is a place where the design stops working. Finding one is good news. Now you know what to fix.
Worked example 1: Sofia’s price list. Sofia’s team bought a barrel cup with a lid for $40, a foil gutter for $20, a straw hose for $10, six native plant cutouts at $10 each and four rocks at $5 each. That is 40 + 20 + 10 + 60 + 20 = $150. They are under the $200 budget.
Worked example 2: Ben’s test plan. Ben wrote one test for each goal. “Rain: pour 200 mL and measure what we save. Shade: 10 minutes under the lamp next to an open cup. Edge: check how much is covered. Limits: cost, tools, time, lid.” He also wrote what stays the same: the 200 mL, the lamp distance and the time.
| Goal | How we test it | What we record | Met when |
|---|---|---|---|
| Keep water (rain) | Teacher pours 200 mL on the roof | mL that reach the barrel and pond | 100 mL or more |
| Keep water (shade) | 10 minutes under the lamp, next to an open cup | Water temperature of both cups | 2 degrees C cooler or more |
| Shelter and food | Look around the edge and in the pond | How much edge is covered; water plants? | Half the edge or more; yes |
| Limits | Check the price list, tools, clock and safety | Cost, tools, time, lid, sharp parts | All yes |
Plan, buy and build. Then write your test plan.
Record your build.
Draw Version 1. Label the roof, gutter, barrel, pond and edge plants. Write your sample cost.
Predict one failure point your test may find. Why do you think so?
Version 1 is ready. Next time, it faces its tests.
Exit ticket: why do engineers test a prototype instead of just building the final design?
Materials: plastic lids for roofs, clear cups for ponds, small cups with lids for barrels, foil, straws, tape, soil trays, paper plant cutouts, pebbles, measuring cups. Sample price list: barrel with lid $40, gutter $20, hose $10, plant $10, rock $5, water plant cutout $5, tape $5, and a “digging machine” card at $500 that breaks two constraints.
Pacing: warm-up 3, reading 6, mini lecture 7, building 19, test plan and exit 5 minutes.
Misconceptions: the first build should be perfect; one test covers every goal; rain barrel water is clean drinking water (it is not).
Supports: provide a partly filled test plan and a receipt. Stretch: plan a second trial for each test.
Answer guide: test plans name an action, a measurement and what stays the same for each goal. Predicted failure points give a reason, such as “water may leak at the gutter seam.”
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Soak Up the Rain: Rain Barrels · U.S. government work, public domain
When rain falls on a roof, it runs off. A rain barrel catches that water and holds it. People can use it later on lawns, gardens or plants.
Rain barrels do a few good things. They save water. The water is free. They also cut down the amount of water that rushes off a property when it rains. That water is called runoff.
Many cities and towns sell rain barrels to people each year. Garden stores sell them too.
Some people use a much bigger container called a cistern. A cistern can hold a lot more water. It can sit above the ground or under it.
There is one thing to think about. As rain flows over a roof, it can pick up things we do not want. It can pick up germs from birds and other animals. It can pick up chemicals from roof materials. People think about this before they use barrel water on food plants.
Rain barrels are one way to soak up the rain where it falls.
Source: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Soak Up the Rain: Rain Barrels (epa.gov)