revise a panel using checkpoint feedback, or extend our guide with a new panel about how soil changes a plant’s flower color.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Look at two pictures of the same kind of bush. One has blue flowers. One has pink flowers. List three things that could cause the difference.
Bigleaf hydrangea bushes of the same kind are planted in two different soils. What might happen?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Museum makers, today you choose your path. Path A: revise. Use your checkpoint feedback to fix one panel. Path B: extend. Build a new panel about hydrangeas for our guide.
Path A: revise. Look at the standard where your checkpoint showed you need practice. Find that panel. Add one fact, a clearer label or a better connection sentence. Read it aloud again in under 45 seconds.
Path B: extend. Our guide has animal evidence for Panel 4, the flamingo. A plant example makes the guide stronger. The hydrangea shows that the same kind of plant can have different flower colors in different soils.
Worked example 1: Wren’s revision. Wren’s checkpoint showed she mixed up inherited traits and environment traits. She adds a two-column chart to Panel 4: “Comes from parents” and “Changed by environment.” She puts “has flowers” in the first column and “blue or pink, from soil” in the second.
Worked example 2: Kai’s hydrangea panel. Kai’s big idea: “The same kind of plant can grow different flower colors in different soil.” His model shows two bushes side by side, one in acidic soil with blue flowers, one in other soil with pink flowers. His arrow says, “Cause: soil. Effect: flower color.”
Same criteria. Either path uses our Guide Card: Big Idea, Model, Evidence, Visitor-Friendly and Accurate.
Use the reading for either path.
Work on your chosen path.
Path A: name the panel you revised, what you changed and which criterion it now meets better.
Path B: write a big idea, draw a labeled model and give two facts from the reading for a new hydrangea panel.
Our museum guide is complete, museum makers. You showed how living things grow, and why members of one kind are alike and different. In Unit 2, we will find out what happens when habitats change.
Reflection: What is the most important thing you learned in Unit 1? Which panel taught it best?
How confident are you that you can I can improve my work using feedback and evidence.
Flex lesson: revise or extend. Assign Path A to students who scored low on one standard in 1.26. Others may choose either path.
Pacing: Do Now 4, reading 6, instruction 6, path work 18, closure 6.
Materials: panels, checkpoint feedback, poster paper, markers; optional pictures of blue and pink bigleaf hydrangeas.
Accuracy notes: the color change applies to bigleaf hydrangeas, not every hydrangea. Keep pH simple: low means acidic. Students do not need to explain the chemistry beyond “aluminum in the flowers makes them blue.” The reading’s source is copyrighted, so students retell it and do not copy it.
Misconceptions: blue and pink hydrangeas are different kinds of plants; the flower chooses its color.
Supports: Path B organizer with the big idea frame “The same kind of plant can ___ in different ___.” Stretch: compare the hydrangea and flamingo examples in one sentence.
Answer guide: strong Path B panels state the soil as cause and flower color as effect, with the two pH ranges as evidence.
Clemson Cooperative Extension, Home and Garden Information Center, Hydrangea Care (HGIC 1067) · Copyright Clemson University; summarized in our own words for education
Hydrangeas are bushes with big clusters of flowers. One kind is called the bigleaf hydrangea. Its flowers can be blue or pink.
What decides the color? The soil. Gardeners measure soil with a number called pH. A low pH means the soil is acidic. A higher pH means it is not.
In acidic soil, with a pH of 5.0 to 5.5, bigleaf hydrangea flowers are blue. In soil with a pH of 6.0 or more, the flowers are pink.
The pH does not change the color by itself. It changes how much of a material called aluminum the plant can get from the soil. Whether aluminum is in the flowers decides if they are blue or pink.
Bigleaf hydrangeas also need the right light. They grow best in partial shade, with morning sun and afternoon shade. Hot, open spots are not good for them.
Source: Clemson Cooperative Extension, Home and Garden Information Center, Hydrangea Care (HGIC 1067) (hgic.clemson.edu)