collect data on how a group spots danger, and describe animals that live in groups of different sizes and how the group helps them survive.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Check the caterpillars and the bean cups. Then look at three photo cards: a herd of elephants, a school of fish and a hive of honey bees. What do they have in common?
A fox sneaks toward some rabbits. Who will spot it first?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Groups of many sizes. Many animals live in groups. Some groups are small, like an elephant family herd. Some are huge, like a school of thousands of fish or a honey bee hive. Some, like a wolf pack, are in between.
Why live in a group? Scientists find three big ways groups can help. Groups can get food, like wolves hunting large animals together. Groups can stay safe, like elephants bunching around their calves. Groups can handle changes, like honey bees crowding together to stay warm in winter.
Today’s model: the Many Eyes game. Students sit in groups of 1, 3 or 6, facing different directions. The teacher slowly moves a toy fox from the door. When anyone in the group spots it, the whole group raises hands. The Recorder writes how many seconds it took. Each group size gets three tries.
| Group size | Try 1 (seconds) | Try 2 | Try 3 | Fastest |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||
| 3 | ||||
| 6 |
Worked example 1: reading the data. Eli’s class found that the single student took 9 seconds to spot the fox. The group of 6 took 3 seconds. These are sample data. Eli wrote, “The bigger group spotted the fox faster.”
Worked example 2: a model is not the real thing. Chloe said, “We are students, not rabbits.” She is right. A model helps us test an idea, but we still need evidence from real animals, like the elephants in our reading.
For our guide. The Helpful Traits and Groups gallery will show real animal groups and how each group helps its members.
Use your class data and the reading.
Use your data to make a claim.
Write a claim about group size and spotting danger. Use numbers from your class table as evidence. Then name one real animal group from today and how its group helps it.
Many animals live in groups of different sizes, and groups can help them get food, stay safe and handle changes. Later we will ask if our evidence is strong enough.
Exit ticket: how does living in a herd help an elephant calf survive?
Pacing: 5 min Do Now, 8 min reading, 7 min lecture, 13 min Many Eyes game and table, 7 min practice and claim.
Materials: a toy fox or a fox picture on a stick, a stopwatch, photo cards (elephant herd, fish school, bee colony, wolf pack), data tables.
Running the game: start the fox from a different spot each try and move it at the same slow speed. Students face outward. The single student faces one way only. Results usually show bigger groups spot the fox sooner, but use whatever the class gets.
Likely misconceptions: “animals live in groups because they are friends”; “bigger groups are always better.” Note that groups also share food; 1.13 asks whether evidence is enough.
Support / stretch: claim frame: “Groups of ___ spotted the fox in ___ seconds, but one student took ___ seconds, so ___.” Stretch: name one problem a big group might have.
Answer guide: claim: bigger groups spotted danger faster, with class numbers. Exit ticket: older elephants call out danger, the herd bunches around calves, and the herd helps raise them.
Smithsonian's National Zoo and Conservation Biology Institute, Asian Elephant · Copyright Smithsonian Institution; no reuse license stated on the page. Retold here in our own words.
The Smithsonian’s National Zoo cares for Asian elephants. Its page explains how they live.
Asian elephants live in small groups called herds. A herd is a family. It is made of related females, their young daughters and young males. Males leave the herd when they are between 8 and 13 years old. Females stay with their family their whole lives.
The herd works together to raise the young. Usually a mother has one calf. A calf weighs about 150 to 350 pounds at birth! It can stand and drink its mother’s milk soon after it is born. By 6 months old, it starts to eat plants.
The herd also keeps calves safe. Tigers can attack young elephants. When older elephants see danger, they make loud warning calls. Then the rest of the herd bunches together for protection.
Herds move to find places with enough plants and water. A grown elephant eats about 165 to 330 pounds of food in a day. It drinks about 50 gallons of water.
Source: Smithsonian's National Zoo and Conservation Biology Institute, Asian Elephant (nationalzoo.si.edu)