
calculate elastic potential energy from a spring constant or a force-stretch graph, trace energy into thermal energy at the particle scale, and argue from measurements that energy is conserved when a device seems to lose it.
Instruction
The argument. A rubber-band car rolls across the floor and stops. A pumped-storage plant returns only about three quarters of the energy it stores. A skeptic says: “Then energy is not really conserved; it gets used up.” Today you gather evidence and build the counter-argument: energy is conserved in every case, but some of it ends up where it is hard to use. To make that argument you need two more energy stores, elastic and thermal, and a way to see both at the particle scale.
Elastic potential energy. Stretch or compress a spring and it pushes back with a force proportional to the displacement, F = kx (Hooke’s law), where k is the spring constant in N/m. Worked example: a 200 g mass hung on a spring stretches it 4.9 cm, so k = mg/x = (0.200)(9.8)/0.049 = 40 N/m. The work you do stretching it is the area under the force-stretch graph, a triangle: PEelastic = ½kx2.
Worked example: a spring launcher. A launcher with k = 250 N/m is compressed 4.0 cm and fires a 50 g ball straight up. Stored energy: ½(250)(0.040)2 = 0.200 J. If all of it became gravitational potential energy, the ball would rise h = 0.200/((0.050)(9.8)) = 0.408 m. The measured rise is 0.34 m (illustrative numbers), so only (0.050)(9.8)(0.34) = 0.1666 J reached the top: 83%. The missing 0.0334 J did not vanish. It went into the vibrating spring, air drag, sound, and a slight warming of the spring and the ball.
Real materials are not ideal springs. A rubber band’s force-stretch graph curves (illustrative numbers):
| Stretch x (m) | 0.00 | 0.05 | 0.10 | 0.15 | 0.20 | 0.25 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Force F (N) | 0.0 | 1.6 | 2.6 | 3.3 | 4.0 | 4.9 |
The energy stored is still the area under the curve. Split it into trapezoids, each (width) × (average height): 0.05 × (0 + 1.6)/2 + 0.05 × (1.6 + 2.6)/2 + … = 0.6975 J. Treating the band as ideal, ½Fx = ½(4.9)(0.25) = 0.6125 J, would underestimate it by 12%. When this band launches an 80 g cart that leaves at 2.6 m/s, the cart has ½(0.080)(2.6)2 = 0.2704 J, only 39% of the stored energy. Rubber gets measurably warm when stretched and released quickly: the rest became thermal energy inside the band.
The particle view (9-12.PS3.A.2). At the scale you can see, energy is either motion (kinetic) or position in a field (gravitational, elastic, electric). At the particle scale the same two categories apply. Elastic energy is stored in the electric fields between molecules as bonds and chains are stretched. Thermal energy is the random kinetic energy of molecules jiggling plus the potential energy of their jostled bonds. When a 1,200 kg car brakes from 25 m/s, its 375,000 J of kinetic energy does not disappear: friction turns ordered motion of the whole car into disordered motion of the molecules in the brake pads and discs, which get hot. Energy that has spread into random molecular motion is still there, but it is hard to collect again. Unit 2 turns that idea into the second law of thermodynamics.
Building the argument. A strong argument names the system, accounts for every joule you can measure, identifies where the “missing” energy went with evidence (a warm band, sound, a slowing cart), and answers the counterclaim directly.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Lab: Rubber-band launcher: stored energy versus kinetic energy
Question. How much of the energy stored in a stretched rubber band becomes kinetic energy of a launched cart, and where does the rest go?
Materials
- Several identical rubber bands and a toy car or small cart
- A spring scale or digital luggage scale (0-10 N), or a plastic bag and a measuring cup to hang known amounts of water (250 mL of water has a mass of about 0.25 kg and weighs about 2.45 N)
- Meter stick, masking tape and a phone camera (for video timing)
- Two chairs or a heavy table leg to anchor the band
- Wear safety goggles whenever a band is stretched: a band can snap or slip and fly toward the face.
- Stretch bands only along the floor, never toward people, and do not stretch beyond 25 cm.
- Keep the launch lane clear and put a soft stop at the end.
Procedure
- Anchor the band between two chair legs at floor level. Pull its middle back with the spring scale in 5 cm steps to 25 cm, recording the force at each step (or hang known masses and measure stretch).
- Graph F against x and find the stored energy at 20 cm as the area under the curve, using trapezoids.
- Put the cart against the band, pull back 20 cm, and release. Film the cart crossing two tape marks 0.50 m apart just after launch and compute its speed from the frame count.
- Mass the cart. Compute its kinetic energy and the fraction of the stored energy it received. Repeat three times.
- Feel the band right after several quick stretches and releases, and note any warming.
Data
| Stretch x (m) | 0.00 | 0.05 | 0.10 | 0.15 | 0.20 | 0.25 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Force F (N) | 0.0 | 1.6 | 2.6 | 3.3 | 4.0 | 4.9 |
| Illustrative force-stretch data; record your own at the same stretches, plus three launch speeds. | ||||||
Analysis
- Claim-evidence-reasoning: was energy conserved in the launch? Cite your stored energy, the cart’s kinetic energy and the band’s warming.
- Compare your trapezoid area with ½Fx. Which is the better estimate for a rubber band, and why?
- Estimate the uncertainty in the cart’s kinetic energy from ±1 video frame, and decide whether the energy gap is larger than that uncertainty.
If you cannot do this lab in person: Use the illustrative force-stretch table and launch speed in the lesson, or PhET Masses and Springs (Energy screen) to see elastic, kinetic, gravitational and thermal energy bars as a mass oscillates with damping turned on.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
A spring with k = 250 N/m is compressed 4.0 cm. How much elastic energy does it store?
A 200 g mass stretches a spring 4.9 cm, so k = N/m. Stretched 10 cm, the spring stores J.
When a car brakes to a stop, its kinetic energy is destroyed by friction.
Record a 90-second argument (or write 200 words) answering the skeptic: “Energy is not conserved, because the rubber-band car stops.” Name your system, use your launch data (stored energy, kinetic energy, warming) as evidence, explain the particle-scale reasoning, and state what measurement would convince you the skeptic was right. Then reread it as the skeptic would and add one or two sentences answering the strongest objection you can find to your own argument. A written argument earns equal credit.
How confident are you that you can calculate elastic energy and argue from evidence, at the particle scale, that energy is conserved when it seems to be lost?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- Find the kinetic energy of a 0.5 kg object moving at 20 m/s.
Check your answer
Answer: 100.0 JKE = ½mv2. - Find the kinetic energy of a 0.15 kg object moving at 12 m/s.
Check your answer
Answer: 10.8 JKE = ½mv2. - A 500 g mass stretches a spring 8.0 cm. Find k.
Check your answer
Answer: 61.2 N/mk = mg/x. - The spring above is stretched 12 cm. How much elastic energy does it store?
Check your answer
Answer: 0.441 J½kx2. - A spring launcher (k = 400 N/m) is compressed 5.0 cm and fires a 40 g ball straight up. Ignoring losses, how high does it rise?
Check your answer
Answer: 1.28 m½kx2 = mgh. - The same launcher fires the ball horizontally on a frictionless track. What is its launch speed?
Check your answer
Answer: 5.00 m/s½kx2 = ½mv2.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- A rubber band’s force-stretch data are (0, 0), (0.05 m, 2.0 N), (0.10 m, 3.5 N), (0.15 m, 4.5 N). Use trapezoids to find the stored energy at 0.15 m.
Check your answer
Answer: 0.3875 JSum of (width)(average height) for three strips. - An 1,800 kg car brakes from 22 m/s to rest. Where does its kinetic energy go, and how much is there?
Check your answer
Answer: 435,600 J, mostly to thermal energy in the brakes½mv2; friction turns ordered motion into random molecular motion. - Respond to the claim “The launcher lost energy because the ball rose only 0.52 m instead of the predicted height.”
Check your answer
Answer: The energy was transferred, not lostPredicted 1.28 m; the missing energy went into spring vibration, air drag, sound and slight warming. Name the system and account for each transfer.
Challenge
Stretch problems. Expect to think before you write.
- A 60 kg skateboarder rolls off a 1.5 m high ramp at the bottom speed of 4.8 m/s. How much energy became thermal, and what average friction force acted over the 6.0 m ramp?
Check your answer
Answer: 191 J; 32 NThermal = mgh − ½mv2; force = thermal/distance.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- A 1800 kg object moving at 12 m/s collides and sticks to a 1000 kg object moving at 4.0 m/s (same line; positive is the first object’s direction). Find the total momentum and the velocity just after the collision.
Check your answer
Answer: total momentum 25,600 kg·m/s; final velocity 9.14 m/sMomentum is conserved: m1v1 + m2v2 = (m1 + m2)v. - An object is dropped from rest 10 m above the ground. Ignoring air resistance (g = 9.8 m/s2), how long does it fall and how fast is it moving at impact?
Check your answer
Answer: 1.43 s; 14.0 m/sh = ½gt2; v = gt.
Where the Energy Went: The Force-Stretch, Launch and Warming Record
SLS constructed teaching data set (illustrative, not laboratory measurements) following the Lesson 1.3 procedure: force at six stretches, three slow-motion launches of a 0.080 kg cart, a temperature check, and the spring measurements behind the worked examples · SLS original
Why this reading. The argument you must record needs evidence: a force-stretch graph, launch speeds, and some sign of warming. The lesson gives one force table and one launch speed with no trials behind it. Here is the full record of the lesson’s own procedure, run as written: the band’s force at six stretches, three launches filmed in slow motion, a temperature check, and the spring measurements behind the two worked examples. The numbers are SLS teaching data, constructed to behave like a real band and a real spring and labeled illustrative; they are not laboratory measurements from any named source. Every figure in the lesson can be recomputed from them.
Part A. The band
A single office rubber band (unstretched loop 9 cm) anchored between two chair legs on the floor, pulled at its middle with a 0–10 N spring scale in 5 cm steps. Each force is the steady reading after two seconds, read to 0.1 N.
| Stretch x (m) | 0.00 | 0.05 | 0.10 | 0.15 | 0.20 | 0.25 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Force F (N) | 0.0 | 1.6 | 2.6 | 3.3 | 4.0 | 4.9 |
Stored energy by trapezoids. Each strip is width × average height: 0.05(0 + 1.6)/2 = 0.040; 0.05(1.6 + 2.6)/2 = 0.105; 0.05(2.6 + 3.3)/2 = 0.1475; 0.05(3.3 + 4.0)/2 = 0.1825; 0.05(4.0 + 4.9)/2 = 0.2225. Total to 0.25 m: 0.6975 J. The ideal-spring shortcut ½Fx = ½(4.9)(0.25) = 0.6125 J is 12% low, because the real curve bulges above the straight line from the origin. To 0.20 m, the lab’s launch stretch, the area is 0.040 + 0.105 + 0.1475 + 0.1825 = 0.475 J.
Part B. Three launches
Cart mass 80.0 g (0.080 kg). Tape marks 0.50 m apart just past the release point. Filmed at 240 fps (a phone’s slow-motion setting), because at 30 fps the cart crosses 0.50 m in only about 6 frames and one frame would be a 17% error.
| Trial | Frames over 0.50 m (240 fps) | t (s) | v = 0.50/t (m/s) | ½mv2 (J) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 46 | 0.192 | 2.61 | 0.272 |
| 2 | 47 | 0.196 | 2.55 | 0.261 |
| 3 | 45 | 0.188 | 2.67 | 0.284 |
| Mean | 46.0 | 0.192 | 2.61 | 0.272 |
With a 0.25 m stretch (the lesson’s example) the same band launched the cart at 2.6 m/s: ½(0.080)(2.6)2 = 0.2704 J, 39% of the 0.6975 J stored. At the lab’s 0.20 m stretch the mean kinetic energy is 0.272 J out of 0.475 J stored: 57%. The band is more efficient at smaller stretch, which is itself evidence about where the energy goes.
Uncertainty from ±1 frame. 45 to 47 frames gives v from 2.55 to 2.67 m/s and kinetic energy from 0.261 to 0.284 J: about ±0.012 J, or ±4%. The gap between stored (0.475 J) and kinetic (0.272 J) energy is 0.203 J, seventeen times that uncertainty. Timing error cannot explain the missing energy.
Warming. An infrared kitchen thermometer read the band at 21.8 °C before the lab and 23.4 °C after twenty quick stretch-and-release cycles, a rise of 1.6 K, with the room at 21.6 °C. The band’s mass is about 1 g; taking a specific heat near 1,500 J/(kg·K) for rubber (an approximate value), that warming stores roughly (0.001)(1,500)(1.6) = 2.4 J across twenty cycles, or 0.12 J per cycle: the same order as the 0.2 J unaccounted for in each launch. The rest went to sound, air drag, and the band’s own vibration after release.
Part C. The spring behind the worked examples
| Hanging mass (kg) | Stretch x (m) | k = mg/x (N/m) |
|---|---|---|
| 0.050 | 0.012 | 40.8 |
| 0.100 | 0.025 | 39.2 |
| 0.150 | 0.037 | 39.7 |
| 0.200 | 0.049 | 40.0 |
The four values agree within 2%, which is what Hooke’s law predicts and what the rubber band does not do: k = 40 N/m. Stretched 10 cm it stores ½(40)(0.10)2 = 0.20 J.
The launcher (k = 250 N/m, compressed 4.0 cm, 50 g ball). Stored ½(250)(0.040)2 = 0.200 J. Measured rises against a wall scale: 0.33, 0.35, 0.34 m, mean 0.34 m, so mgh = (0.050)(9.8)(0.34) = 0.1666 J, or 83% of the stored energy. The 0.0334 J shortfall exceeds the ±0.005 J spread of the three rises.
Your turn
- Recompute the trapezoid area to 0.20 m and to 0.25 m. Then compute ½Fx at 0.20 m and state its percentage error.
- Write the energy account for one 0.20 m launch as an equation: stored = kinetic + thermal + other. Put a number on each term you can, and say which term you inferred rather than measured.
- The skeptic says the car “uses up” its energy when it stops. Using the coasting distance of a car (the lesson’s 4.1 m example) and its kinetic energy, compute the average resisting force and name the two places that energy ends up.
- State one measurement that would convince you the skeptic was right, and explain why the warming reading in Part B is evidence against it.