
design, build and refine a device that converts one form of energy into another within constraints, measure its efficiency across iterations, and justify my design choices with data and trade-offs.
Instruction
The design challenge (9-12.PS3.A.3). Design, build and refine a device that converts one form of energy into another within given constraints, and measure how well it does it. Choose one:
- Option A: a falling-mass lifter. A mass falling a measured height turns a spool that winds up a string and lifts a lighter load. Gravitational energy of one mass becomes gravitational energy of another.
- Option B: a rubber-band car. Elastic energy in a wound or stretched band becomes kinetic energy of the car.
- Option C: a rubber-band launcher. A stretched band launches a small ball or a folded-paper projectile straight up: elastic energy becomes gravitational energy. Input is the area under the band’s force-stretch graph (Lesson 1.3); output is mgh at the top of the flight, read against a wall you have marked. No timing is needed, so this is the easiest option to measure accurately at home.
Worked example, Option A (illustrative numbers). A 1.00 kg mass falls 0.80 m: input energy mgh = (1.00)(9.8)(0.80) = 7.84 J. It lifts a 0.50 kg load 1.00 m: useful output (0.50)(9.8)(1.00) = 4.90 J. Efficiency = 4.90/7.84 = 62.5%. The rest went to friction in the axle, the kinetic energy of the falling mass when it lands, and the stretch of the string.
Worked example, Option B (illustrative numbers). The band stores 1.8 J (measured from its force-stretch graph, as in Lesson 1.3). The 0.25 kg car leaves at 2.4 m/s: ½(0.25)(2.4)2 = 0.72 J, an efficiency of 40%. It then coasts 4.1 m to a stop, so the average resisting force was 0.72 J/4.1 m = 0.176 N. After the team replaced a rubbing axle with a straw bearing and added a larger drive wheel, the car left at 2.9 m/s: 1.051 J, or 58%. That is iteration with evidence: change one thing, measure, compare.
Criteria and constraints. Criteria might include efficiency, distance traveled or load lifted, repeatability across three trials, and cost. Constraints might include a mass limit, a maximum size, only recycled or everyday household materials, and a build-time limit. Rank the criteria: if efficiency matters most, a heavier but smoother axle may be worth it.
Break the device into parts. Every energy converter has a source (the falling mass, the band), a transfer path (spool, axle, wheels) and an output (the lifted load, the moving car). Draw an energy-flow diagram with arrows for the useful path and for each loss. Test and improve the part with the biggest loss first.
Measuring well. Measure input energy directly (height and mass, or the area under the band’s F-x graph). Measure output energy with the methods from Lesson 1.2 (video timing for speed, a meter stick for lifted height). Run three trials of every version and report the mean and spread. Two versions are only different if their difference is bigger than the spread.
Trade-offs. A wider drive wheel may raise speed but add mass. A stronger band stores more energy but may snap. State the trade-offs you accepted and why, using your ranked criteria.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
A 1.00 kg mass falls 0.80 m and lifts a 0.50 kg load 1.00 m. What is the efficiency?
If version 2 of a car averages 44% efficiency and version 1 averaged 40%, but each version’s three trials spread over ±6%, the data show version 2 is better.
Stage 1 plan: choose your option, list ranked criteria and constraints, sketch the device with an energy-flow diagram, and explain how you will measure input and output energy.
How confident are you that you can design, build and refine an energy converter and justify it with measured efficiency and trade-offs?
Unit 1 checkpoint
Do this before you start the task. It covers the whole unit and tells you what to review first.
A force does no work on a moving object when the force is
A 2.0 kg ball moving at 6.0 m/s has J of kinetic energy.
Lifting 50 kg through 3.0 m stores J of gravitational potential energy.
Doubling an object’s speed doubles its kinetic energy.
A plant stores 85 units of every 100 pumped and returns 84% of what is stored. The round-trip efficiency is about
A spring with k = 200 N/m compressed 0.10 m stores J.
When a sliding box stops because of friction, its kinetic energy becomes thermal energy in the box and floor.
At the particle scale, elastic potential energy in a stretched rubber band is stored
A 70 kg person climbing 3.0 m in 6.0 s develops W.
MW and MWh measure the same quantity.
In the energy-converter task, what makes version 2 demonstrably better than version 1?
A falling 2.0 kg mass drops 1.0 m and lifts a 1.0 kg load 1.2 m. The efficiency is %.
Design Report: An Energy Converter
Task: Design, build and refine a device that converts one form of energy into another within the task constraints listed in this lesson’s reading (Option A falling-mass lifter, Option B rubber-band car or Option C rubber-band launcher; all three are described in the lesson and earn equal credit). Measure the input and useful output energy for at least three versions, with three trials each, and compute the efficiency of each version with its spread. Your report must include ranked criteria and constraints, a labeled sketch and an energy-flow diagram showing the useful path and every loss, an iteration log (what you changed, why and what happened), a graph or table comparing versions, a particle-level explanation of where the lost energy went, and a trade-off discussion. Wear safety goggles whenever bands are stretched or masses are dropped, keep falling masses over a soft landing, and have a parent or guardian check any device of your own design before you test it.
Choose where your measurements come from. All three earn full credit and are the same difficulty.
Route 1 — build and measure. Your own device, at least three versions, three trials each.
Route 2 — the illustrative data set in this lesson. No materials needed. A falling-mass lifter was run three times per version; on every run a 1.00 kg mass fell 0.80 m, so the input energy was mgh = (1.00)(9.8)(0.80) = 7.84 J, and the useful output was a 0.50 kg load lifted the height shown. These are constructed teaching numbers, not real measurements.
| Version | What changed | Load lifted, trials 1-3 (cm) | Output energy, trials 1-3 (J) | Mean output (J) | Efficiency |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | As first built: wooden axle turning in a hole punched in cardboard | 88.0, 92.9, 90.0 | 4.31, 4.55, 4.41 | 4.42 | 56.4% |
| 2 | Drinking-straw bearings added at both ends of the axle | 100.0, 103.1, 99.0 | 4.90, 5.05, 4.85 | 4.93 | 62.9% |
| 3 | Spool diameter doubled, string rewound in a single layer | 111.0, 114.3, 108.2 | 5.44, 5.60, 5.30 | 5.45 | 69.5% |
Treat these as your three versions. Recompute every output energy and efficiency yourself (output = 0.50 × 9.8 × height in meters), work out each version’s spread as a percentage of 7.84 J, and use the true-or-false check in this lesson to decide whether each change really improved the device. Then write the iteration log from the ‘what changed’ column, explain at the particle level where the missing energy went, and recommend a design with its trade-offs.
Route 3 — PhET Energy Skate Park as the converter. The PhET simulation is at phet.colorado.edu/sims/html/energy-skate-park/latest/energy-skate-park_all.html. On the Intro screen, turn on the bar graph and speedometer. Your device is the track: it converts gravitational energy into kinetic energy. Release the skater from 4.0 m at three friction settings you record, and each time take the speed at the bottom three times. Input is mgh (the sim gives the skater’s mass); useful output is ½mv2. Report the three efficiencies with their spreads, treat lowering friction as your refinement, and answer every part of the task from those numbers. Say clearly which real losses the sim models and which it does not. Cite the sim and the date you used it.
Submission workflow
- Stage 1 — Plan. Option, ranked criteria and constraints, sketch, energy-flow diagram and measurement plan.
- Stage 2 — Reviewed draft. After two tested versions, recompute every input and output energy a second time from your raw data (or have a parent, guardian or other reader recompute them with you), and challenge one of your own design decisions with the data; submit the review notes and your revision plan.
- Stage 3 — Revised final. Report with at least three versions, efficiencies with spreads, the particle-level explanation of losses and the trade-off discussion.
- Stage 4 — Demonstration and defense. Show video of your final device (or, for Routes 2 and 3, your data and graphs) and record a five-minute defense of your design that answers two questions about your data: which change made the largest difference, and how you know it was larger than the spread.
How it is scored
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Design and refinement (9-12.PS3.A.3) | Builds a working converter and improves it through at least three evidence-based iterations. |
| Energy measurement (9-12.PS3.A.1, SEP.3) | Input and output energies correctly measured and calculated, with trials and spreads. |
| Trade-offs (9-12.ETS1.B.1) | Ranked criteria and constraints guide decisions; trade-offs named and justified. |
| Energy explanation (CCC.5) | Energy-flow diagram and particle-level account of where the losses went. |
| Data communication (RST.11-12.3, MP.4) | Clear tables or graphs comparing versions, with units and uncertainty. |
| Defense (SEP.6) | Explains the design and answers questions with reasoning from data. |
Three Devices, Three Versions Each: Iteration Logs for the Energy-Converter Task
SLS constructed teaching data set (illustrative, not laboratory measurements): iteration logs with three trials per version for a falling-mass lifter, a rubber-band car and a rubber-band launcher, built to the Lesson 1.5 worked examples; constraints adapted for at-home work · SLS original
Why this reading. The task’s Route 2 gives a data set for one of the three devices, the falling-mass lifter. A student who chooses the rubber-band car or the launcher and has no materials had nothing to work from, and the true-or-false check about spreads needs the trial-level numbers behind every version. Here are complete iteration logs for all three options, each with three versions and three trials, built to the lesson’s worked examples so that every figure in the lesson can be recomputed. These are SLS teaching numbers, labeled illustrative; they are not measurements from any named laboratory. Use whichever option you chose, and use the constraints below as your task constraints.
Constraints and criteria used for these logs
| Item | Figure | Kind |
|---|---|---|
| Total device mass | at most 400 g, not counting the falling mass or the launched ball | constraint |
| Footprint | fits inside a 40 cm × 40 cm square | constraint |
| Materials | household or recycled only; one rubber band per device; no glue guns | constraint |
| Build time | about two hours of building per version | constraint |
| Efficiency | useful output ÷ input, mean of three trials; higher is better | criterion, weight 3 |
| Repeatability | spread of three trials, as a percentage of the input; smaller is better | criterion, weight 2 |
| Output | load lifted, distance coasted or height reached; larger is better | criterion, weight 1 |
Option A. Falling-mass lifter
Input every run: a 1.00 kg mass falling 0.80 m, mgh = (1.00)(9.8)(0.80) = 7.84 J. Output: a 0.50 kg load lifted the recorded height, (0.50)(9.8)(h).
| Version | What changed | Load lifted, trials 1-3 (cm) | Output (J) | Mean (J) | Efficiency | Spread (± J, ± points) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | wooden axle in a punched cardboard hole | 88.0, 92.9, 90.0 | 4.31, 4.55, 4.41 | 4.42 | 56.4% | 0.12 J, 1.5 points |
| 2 | drinking-straw bearings at both ends | 100.0, 103.1, 99.0 | 4.90, 5.05, 4.85 | 4.93 | 62.9% | 0.10 J, 1.3 points |
| 3 | spool diameter doubled, string in one layer | 111.0, 114.3, 108.2 | 5.44, 5.60, 5.30 | 5.45 | 69.5% | 0.15 J, 1.9 points |
The spread is (highest − lowest)/2 for the three trials, then divided by 7.84 J to give points of efficiency. Version 2 beat version 1 by 6.5 points and version 3 beat version 2 by 6.6, both several times the spread, so both changes are real improvements. The lesson’s worked example (a 0.50 kg load lifted 1.00 m, 62.5%) is version 2’s first trial.
Option B. Rubber-band car
Input every run: the band’s stored energy from its force-stretch graph at the launch stretch, 1.8 J (measured once, as in Lesson 1.3). Car mass 0.25 kg. Speed from slow-motion video across 0.50 m marks. Coasting distance measured to where the car stopped.
| Version | What changed | Launch speed, trials 1-3 (m/s) | ½mv2 (J) | Mean (J) | Efficiency | Spread (points) | Coast (m) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | as first built: axle rubbing in cardboard | 2.36, 2.44, 2.40 | 0.696, 0.744, 0.720 | 0.720 | 40.0% | 1.3 | 4.1 |
| 2 | straw bearing on the drive axle, larger drive wheel | 2.85, 2.93, 2.92 | 1.015, 1.073, 1.066 | 1.051 | 58.4% | 1.6 | 5.9 |
| 3 | band anchored to a stiffer chassis so less energy went into flexing it | 3.05, 3.14, 3.11 | 1.163, 1.232, 1.209 | 1.201 | 66.7% | 1.9 | 6.8 |
Version 1 reproduces the lesson: 0.72 J, 40%, and an average resisting force while coasting of 0.72 J ÷ 4.1 m = 0.176 N. Version 2 is the lesson’s 2.9 m/s and 1.051 J (58%). Each step is well outside the spread.
Option C. Rubber-band launcher
Input every run: the Lesson 1.3 band pulled to 0.20 m, area under its force-stretch graph 0.475 J. Output: a 0.050 kg ball’s rise h read against a wall scale, mgh = (0.050)(9.8)(h).
| Version | What changed | Rise, trials 1-3 (m) | mgh (J) | Mean (J) | Efficiency | Spread (points) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | band across a cardboard frame, ball on a paper cup | 0.50, 0.54, 0.52 | 0.245, 0.265, 0.255 | 0.255 | 53.6% | 2.1 |
| 2 | cup replaced by a light paper pocket (less mass thrown with the ball) | 0.61, 0.58, 0.60 | 0.299, 0.284, 0.294 | 0.292 | 61.6% | 1.5 |
| 3 | frame braced so it no longer flexed on release | 0.67, 0.70, 0.68 | 0.328, 0.343, 0.333 | 0.335 | 70.5% | 1.5 |
Where the lost energy went, at the particle scale
In every device the input minus the useful output ended up mostly as thermal energy: rubbing surfaces (axle in hole, string on spool, band on frame) turn ordered motion into faster random motion of the molecules in both surfaces, which warm. Some went into sound, which is ordered air motion that also ends as thermal energy, and into the kinetic energy of parts that had to move but were not the output: the landing falling mass, a flexing frame, a spinning spool. Each version above removed one such path and the efficiency rose by an amount the trials can distinguish.
Your turn
- For your option, recompute every output energy, mean, efficiency and spread from the trial columns; the tables round to two or three figures and you should carry one more.
- Apply the true-or-false test from the lesson to each pair of consecutive versions: is the difference in efficiency larger than both versions’ spreads? Show the comparison as numbers.
- Score the three versions of your option in a decision matrix with the weights above (efficiency 3, repeatability 2, output 1) and state which version you would submit and what it gave up.
- Name the loss path each change closed, and one path that remains open in version 3 with a fourth change that would close it.