
use Coulomb’s law with vector addition to predict the force between charges and compare electric and gravitational forces
Instruction
The phenomenon. On a cold January day in a heated Missouri house, you walk across a carpet, reach for a doorknob and feel a snap; in July the same walk does nothing. In Atchison County, in Missouri’s northwest corner, 342 wind turbines (U.S. Geological Survey count) turn the motion of air into electricity for the grid. The two scenes share one idea: electric charges push and pull on each other, and moving charges and magnets are linked. This unit builds the model that explains both, starting with the force between charges.
Charge. Matter is made of protons (charge +e), electrons (charge −e) and neutrons (no charge), where e = 1.602 × 10−19 C. Charge is conserved: rubbing a balloon on hair does not create charge, it moves electrons from one object to the other. Charge is also quantized: every object carries a whole number of electron charges. A balloon with −50 nC of charge carries 3.12 × 1011 extra electrons. Dry air matters because humid air leaves a thin film of water on surfaces that lets charge leak away, so on a dry winter day charge builds up on you instead of draining off. Missouri winter air is dry indoors for a reason you can calculate: NOAA’s 1991-2020 climate normals give St. Louis a January average of 32.6°F with a dew point of 23.1°F, and when the furnace warms that air to 70°F without adding water, its relative humidity falls to about 17%.
Three ways to charge. By friction, two different materials touch and electrons move to the one that holds them more tightly. By conduction, a charged object touches a neutral conductor and shares its charge. By induction, a charged object is brought near a conductor without touching; the conductor’s mobile electrons shift, and if the far side is grounded and then disconnected, the conductor keeps a charge opposite to the charged object. Insulators cannot share charge freely, but their molecules polarize, which is why a charged balloon picks up neutral bits of paper.
Coulomb’s law. The size of the force between two point charges is
F = k|q1q2| / r2, k = 8.99 × 109 N·m2/C2
Like charges repel and unlike charges attract; the force acts along the line joining them. It is an inverse-square law: double the distance and the force falls to one quarter.
Worked example 1 (illustrative charges). Two rubbed balloons each carry −50 nC and their centers are 0.10 m apart. F = (8.99 × 109)(50 × 10−9)2 / (0.10)2 = 2.25 × 10−3 N, a repulsion. A 3.0 g balloon weighs (0.0030)(9.8) = 0.0294 N, so the electric push is about 8% of its weight: enough to see the balloons swing apart.
Worked example 2: electric versus gravitational. In a hydrogen atom the electron and proton are about 5.29 × 10−11 m apart. The electric attraction is ke2/r2 = 8.24 × 10−8 N. The gravitational attraction is Gmemp/r2 = 3.63 × 10−47 N. The ratio is about 2.3 × 1039. Both are inverse-square laws, so the ratio does not depend on distance. Gravity dominates planets only because large objects are almost exactly neutral, while mass has no negative version to cancel it.
Worked example 3: adding forces as vectors. Forces from several charges add as vectors, not as plain numbers. A +1.0 μC charge sits at the origin. Charge A (+2.0 μC) is 0.30 m above it and charge B (−3.0 μC) is 0.40 m to its right.
FA = (8.99 × 109)(1.0 × 10−6)(2.0 × 10−6)/(0.30)2 = 0.200 N, pointing straight down (A repels). FB = (8.99 × 109)(1.0 × 10−6)(3.0 × 10−6)/(0.40)2 = 0.169 N, pointing right (B attracts). The components are perpendicular, so Fnet = √(0.1692 + 0.2002) = 0.261 N at tan−1(0.200/0.169) = 49.8° below the +x direction.
Common misconceptions. (1) “The bigger charge pushes harder on the smaller one.” No: by Newton’s third law the two forces are equal in size and opposite in direction. (2) “Use the sign of the charges in F = kq1q2/r2 to get the direction.” Use magnitudes for the size and decide direction from like/unlike, then draw it. (3) “Neutral objects feel no electric force.” A neutral object can be attracted after it polarizes. (4) Forgetting to square r, or leaving microcoulombs and centimeters unconverted.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Lab: Sticky-Tape Charges
Question. How many kinds of charge does peeled tape carry, and how do charged and neutral objects interact?
Materials
- Roll of matte (frosted) clear tape
- A clean tabletop or desk edge
- Small bits of paper and a plastic comb or balloon (latex-free)
- Marker to label tape tabs
- Use latex-free balloons, or skip the balloon, for anyone with a latex allergy.
- Keep charged tape and combs away from phones, laptops and other electronics.
Procedure
- Press a 12 cm strip of tape on the table and fold a small tab at one end; label it B (bottom).
- Press a second strip on top of the first and label its tab T (top).
- Peel T off B quickly, then peel B off the table; hang both from the table edge without letting them touch anything.
- Make a second T/B pair the same way.
- Bring each pair of strips toward each other (T to T, B to B, T to B) and record attract, repel or no effect, and roughly how close they were when you first saw motion.
- Bring T, then B, near bits of paper and near your finger, and record what happens.
Data
| Pair brought together | Attract / repel / none | Distance when motion first seen (cm) |
|---|---|---|
| T and T | ||
| B and B | ||
| T and B | ||
| T and paper bits | ||
| B and paper bits | ||
| T and finger |
Analysis
- Claim-evidence-reasoning: how many kinds of charge does your evidence support, and which observations show it?
- Both T and B attract paper. Explain with polarization why a neutral object is attracted by either kind of charge.
- Why does the effect weaken as the strips get farther apart, and what would humid air do to your results?
If you cannot do this lab in person: Open the PhET Balloons and Static Electricity simulation, rub the balloon on the sweater, and record what happens when the balloon approaches the wall and the second balloon; answer the same analysis questions.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Two T strips of tape are peeled the same way and hung near each other. What will they do?
Two charges attract with 0.36 N. The distance between them is tripled. What is the new force?
In hydrogen the electric force is about 2.3 × 1039 times the gravitational force. The ratio (changes / does not change) if the distance doubles, because both forces depend on 1/r.
A +4 μC charge exerts a larger force on a nearby +1 μC charge than the +1 μC charge exerts on it.
How confident are you that you can use Coulomb’s law with vector addition and compare electric and gravitational forces?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- Find the force between a +3.0 μC charge and a +5.0 μC charge 0.25 m apart. Is it attractive or repulsive?
Check your answer
Answer: 2.16 N, repulsiveF = (8.99 × 109)(3.0 × 10−6)(5.0 × 10−6)/(0.25)2 = 2.16 N; like charges repel. - An object has 2.0 × 1012 more electrons than protons. What is its charge?
Check your answer
Answer: −3.20 × 10−7 C (about −320 nC)q = −ne = −(2.0 × 1012)(1.602 × 10−19 C) = −3.20 × 10−7 C. - Two charges exert 0.80 N on each other. What is the force if the distance between them is tripled?
Check your answer
Answer: 0.0889 NThe force goes as 1/r2, so tripling r divides it by 9: 0.80/9. - Both charges in a pair are doubled and the distance between them is also doubled. By what factor does the force change?
Check your answer
Answer: It stays the same (factor 1).The product q1q2 grows by 2 × 2 = 4, and r2 grows by 4, so F is unchanged. - How many electrons must be removed from a neutral metal sphere to give it a charge of +1.0 nC?
Check your answer
Answer: 6.24 × 109 electronsn = q/e = (1.0 × 10−9)/(1.602 × 10−19) = 6.24 × 109. - Two −4.0 nC charges are 3.0 cm apart. Find the force and say whether it is attractive or repulsive.
Check your answer
Answer: 1.60 × 10−4 N, repulsiveConvert: 3.0 cm = 0.030 m. F = (8.99 × 109)(4.0 × 10−9)2/(0.030)2 = 1.60 × 10−4 N.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- A +2.0 μC charge is at x = 0 and a −4.0 μC charge is at x = 0.20 m. A +1.0 μC charge is placed at x = 0.10 m. Find the net force on it.
Check your answer
Answer: 5.39 N in the +x directionFrom the +2.0 μC charge: 1.80 N, pushed toward +x (repulsion). From the −4.0 μC charge: 3.60 N, pulled toward +x (attraction). Both point the same way, so they add: 5.39 N toward +x. - A −1.5 μC charge is at the origin. A +4.0 μC charge is at (0.50 m, 0) and another +4.0 μC charge is at (0, 0.50 m). Find the size and direction of the net force on the −1.5 μC charge.
Check your answer
Answer: 0.305 N, directed at 45° between the +x and +y axesEach attraction is (8.99 × 109)(1.5 × 10−6)(4.0 × 10−6)/(0.50)2 = 0.216 N, one along +x and one along +y. Net = √2 × 0.216 = 0.305 N at 45°. - Two protons in a nucleus are about 2.0 × 10−15 m apart. Find the electric force between them, and explain what this tells you about the nucleus.
Check your answer
Answer: About 57.7 N of repulsion; another, stronger attractive force (the strong nuclear force) must hold the nucleus together.F = ke2/r2 = (8.99 × 109)(1.602 × 10−19)2/(2.0 × 10−15)2 = 57.7 N, a large force on particles this small. Gravity between them is far too weak to balance it. - Two 1.0 kg spheres 1.0 m apart each carry +1.0 μC. Compare the electric repulsion with the gravitational attraction.
Check your answer
Answer: Electric 8.99 × 10−3 N; gravitational 6.67 × 10−11 N; the electric force is about 1.3 × 108 times larger.Fe = (8.99 × 109)(1.0 × 10−6)2/1.02 = 8.99 × 10−3 N. Fg = (6.674 × 10−11)(1.0)(1.0)/1.02 = 6.67 × 10−11 N. Ratio = 1.3 × 108. A tiny imbalance of charge (about 6 × 1012 electrons) outweighs gravity between everyday objects.
Challenge
Stretch problems. Expect to think before you write.
- A +1.0 μC charge is at x = 0 and a +4.0 μC charge is at x = 0.30 m. Where between them can a third charge sit with zero net electric force on it?
Check your answer
Answer: x = 0.100 mSet k(1.0)/x2 = k(4.0)/(0.30 − x)2. Taking square roots, (0.30 − x) = 2x, so x = 0.10 m. The point is closer to the smaller charge, and the answer does not depend on the third charge’s size or sign. - Two identical 2.0 g balloons hang from the same point on 0.50 m threads. After both are rubbed with the same charge, each thread makes 10° with the vertical. Find the charge on each balloon (treat them as point charges).
Check your answer
Answer: About 108 nC (1.08 × 10−7 C) eachSeparation r = 2(0.50)sin 10° = 0.174 m. For balance, Fe = mg tan 10° = (0.0020)(9.8)(0.1763) = 3.46 × 10−3 N. Then q = r√(F/k) = 0.174 × √(3.46 × 10−3/8.99 × 109) = 1.08 × 10−7 C.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- What net force gives a 8 kg object an acceleration of 3 m/s2?
Check your answer
Answer: 24.00 NFnet = ma. - What net force gives a 60 kg object an acceleration of 1.5 m/s2?
Check your answer
Answer: 90.00 NFnet = ma. - Use Newton’s law of gravitation to find the force between Earth (5.972 × 1024 kg) and the Moon (7.35 × 1022 kg), 3.844 × 108 m apart. Then say what would happen to the force if the distance were halved.
Check your answer
Answer: 1.98 × 1020 N; halving the distance would make it 4 times larger.F = GMm/r2 = (6.674 × 10−11)(5.972 × 1024)(7.35 × 1022)/(3.844 × 108)2 = 1.98 × 1020 N. Gravity is also inverse-square.
Missouri Winter Sparks: NOAA’s Dew Points, the CODATA Constants, and a Recorded Tape Lab
NOAA NCEI, U.S. Climate Normals 1991-2020, hourly normals (HLY-TEMP-NORMAL, HLY-DEWP-NORMAL) for St. Louis Lambert International Airport (USW00013994) and Kansas City International Airport (USW00003947), monthly means of the hourly values; NIST CODATA 2022 recommended values (e, epsilon0, G, electron and proton masses, Bohr radius); SLS humidity calculations (Magnus approximation) and constructed tape observations (illustrative); retrieved Nov. 5, 2026 · Public domain (works of the United States government), with SLS original calculations and illustrative tape record
Why this reading. The lesson opens on a dry Missouri winter day and a doorknob spark, then asks you to compare electric and gravitational forces with figures it does not source. Here is NOAA’s own climate record of how much water vapor Missouri air carries in January and in July, and the calculation that turns it into the dry indoor air of a heated house; the CODATA 2022 constants that make Worked Example 2 a calculation rather than a quotation; and a recorded sticky-tape observation set so that a student without tape can still do the claim-evidence-reasoning. The tape record is SLS teaching data, labeled illustrative; the climate figures and the constants are not.
1. Missouri winter air, according to NOAA
NOAA’s National Centers for Environmental Information publish 1991-2020 hourly climate normals for the airport weather stations at St. Louis and Kansas City: the expected temperature and dew point for every hour of the year. The dew point is the temperature at which the air’s water vapor would start to condense; it measures how much water the air actually holds, whatever its temperature. Averaging the hourly normals over each month gives:
| Station | Month | Mean temperature (°F) | Mean dew point (°F) | Relative humidity outdoors | Relative humidity if warmed (or cooled) to 70°F with no water added |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| St. Louis Lambert Airport | January | 32.6 | 23.1 | 68% | 17% |
| Kansas City International Airport | January | 29.4 | 20.4 | 69% | 15% |
| St. Louis Lambert Airport | July | 80.5 | 66.8 | 63% | 90% |
| Kansas City International Airport | July | 78.4 | 67.4 | 69% | 91% |
The two relative-humidity columns are computed, not measured, with the Magnus approximation for the saturation vapor pressure of water, es(T) = 6.112 exp[17.62T/(243.12 + T)] hPa with T in °C, and RH = es(dew point)/es(air temperature). St. Louis in January: the dew point of 23.1°F (−4.9°C) means a vapor pressure of 4.24 hPa. Outdoors at 32.6°F that is 68% of saturation, which feels damp. Heat the same air to 70°F (21.1°C), where saturation is 25.0 hPa, and the relative humidity falls to 17%: the furnace adds energy but no water. The July air holds 22.4 hPa of vapor, 5.3 times as much; cooled to 70°F it would be close to saturation, which is why an air conditioner drips water as it runs.
The physics link to the spark: water molecules are polar, and at high relative humidity they leave a thin conducting film on skin, carpet fibers and metal that lets separated charge drain away almost as fast as you make it. At 15-20% relative humidity the film is gone. The charge you pick up from the carpet stays on you, your voltage climbs with every step, and the doorknob gets it all at once. Kansas City’s January air is drier still (dew point 20.4°F, about 15% when heated to 70°F), so the effect is the same across the state.
2. The constants behind Worked Example 2 (CODATA 2022, NIST)
| Constant | CODATA 2022 value |
|---|---|
| Elementary charge e | 1.602 176 634 × 10−19 C (exact) |
| Coulomb constant k = 1/(4πε0) | 8.987 551 786 × 109 N·m2/C2 (the lesson rounds to 8.99 × 109) |
| Newtonian constant of gravitation G | 6.674 30(15) × 10−11 m3/(kg·s2) |
| Electron mass me | 9.109 383 7139(28) × 10−31 kg |
| Proton mass mp | 1.672 621 925 95(52) × 10−27 kg |
| Bohr radius a0 | 5.291 772 105 44(82) × 10−11 m |
Electric attraction in hydrogen: ke2/a02 = (8.988 × 109)(1.602 × 10−19)2/(5.292 × 10−11)2 = 8.24 × 10−8 N. Gravitational: Gmemp/a02 = (6.674 × 10−11)(9.109 × 10−31)(1.673 × 10−27)/(5.292 × 10−11)2 = 3.63 × 10−47 N. Ratio 2.27 × 1039, the lesson’s 2.3 × 1039. Both forces carry the same 1/r2, so the ratio is the same at any separation; it is set by the constants alone.
Balloons: two at −50 nC, 0.10 m apart, repel with (8.99 × 109)(5.0 × 10−8)2/(0.10)2 = 2.25 × 10−3 N; a 3.0 g balloon weighs 0.0294 N, so the push is 7.6% of the weight. A charge of 50 nC is 50 × 10−9/1.602 × 10−19 = 3.12 × 1011 electrons.
3. Recorded sticky-tape observations (illustrative)
Two T/B pairs of 12 cm matte tape, peeled as the procedure directs, on a day with indoor relative humidity 28%. “Distance” is the separation at which motion was first seen, read against a ruler on the table edge; it is coarse, about ±1 cm.
| Pair brought together | Attract / repel / none | Distance when motion first seen (cm) |
|---|---|---|
| T and T | repel | 4 |
| B and B | repel | 4 |
| T and B | attract | 6 |
| T and paper bits | attract (bits jump to tape) | 2 |
| B and paper bits | attract (bits jump to tape) | 2 |
| T and finger | attract (tape swings toward finger) | 3 |
| B and finger | attract | 3 |
| T and a fresh, unpeeled strip on the table | none | — |
| T and T, repeated after breathing on both strips | repel, weakly | 1 |
Read the record the way the analysis asks. Like strips repel and unlike strips attract, and there are only two kinds of behavior, so the evidence supports two kinds of charge and no third. Paper and a finger are neutral, yet both kinds of tape attract them: a charged strip pulls the opposite charges in the neutral object slightly closer and pushes like charges slightly away (polarization), and since the closer charges feel the stronger inverse-square force, the net effect is always attraction. The unpeeled strip did nothing because it had not been separated from anything. Breathing on the strips (raising the humidity of the air around them) cut the repulsion distance from 4 cm to about 1 cm within seconds: the moisture film let charge leak off, which is the Missouri winter story run backward, July in a single breath. The distance falls with charge because F = kq1q2/r2: at a quarter of the force, the distance at which the strip first moves is about half.
Your turn
- Recompute the hydrogen ratio with the CODATA figures, carrying three significant figures, and state why doubling the separation leaves it unchanged.
- Two charges attract with 0.36 N; the distance triples. Show the new force is 0.04 N, and then compute the force if the distance is instead halved.
- Write the claim-evidence-reasoning for the number of kinds of charge using at least three rows of the tape record, and say which row is the control.
- Using the NOAA table, explain why the same walk across the same carpet produces a spark in a heated St. Louis house in January and none in July. Then compute the relative humidity of the Kansas City January air heated to 68°F instead of 70°F, and say whether turning the thermostat down would help much.
Sources: NOAA NCEI, U.S. Climate Normals 1991-2020 (hourly normals, St. Louis USW00013994 and Kansas City USW00003947), via the NCEI Access Data Service (ncei.noaa.gov); NIST CODATA 2022, elementary charge (physics.nist.gov); NIST CODATA 2022, vacuum electric permittivity (physics.nist.gov); NIST CODATA 2022, Newtonian constant of gravitation (physics.nist.gov); NIST CODATA 2022, electron mass (physics.nist.gov); NIST CODATA 2022, proton mass (physics.nist.gov); NIST CODATA 2022, Bohr radius (physics.nist.gov)