show what I have learned about Penn’s colony, its economy and the people who gained or lost.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Take a slow breath. You have worked like a historian for weeks. Read the passage first. It is a primary source you will use on the checkpoint.
How confident are you that you can I am ready to use evidence from the reading and from our unit.
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
This checkpoint is your chance to show your thinking. It covers Penn’s ideas, the land, work and money, roads and rivers, and the people who gained or lost. Read each question fully. Use the reading and what you remember.
For written answers, use claim, evidence, reasoning. State your answer. Give a fact or detail. Explain how the fact supports your answer.
Worked example 1: Tessa answers a document question. Question: what does the Charter of Privileges tell us about early Pennsylvania? Tessa writes: “It shows the colony valued freedom of worship. The charter says no one could be punished for faith in God, and Penn said that part must never change. This tells us religious freedom was central.”
Worked example 2: Sam answers a fairness question. Question: who was left out of the charter’s rights? Sam writes: “Only freemen could vote, so women and enslaved people could not. This shows the colony’s freedom had limits.” He answers with a reason, not just a fact.
Be careful with hard history. Our unit includes slavery and the loss of Lenape land. A strong answer can hold two truths: the colony had new ideas about freedom, and many people did not share in them.
Part A. Answer on your own.
Part B. Answer each question in 2 to 4 sentences with evidence.
1. Write one historical question about colonial Pennsylvania that evidence can answer. Then explain why the Charter of Privileges matters and what the Pennsylvania Constitution does for people today.
2. Explain what William Penn meant by “Governments, like clocks, go from the motion men give them.” Is a famous saying like this a primary or secondary source?
3. Explain how roads, rivers and wagons changed trade, and what the Conestoga wagon shows about life long ago. Why did towns grow in some places? Name one important Pennsylvania historic site and tell why.
4. Give one example of cooperation and one example of conflict in early Pennsylvania. Use Penn's treaty, the Walking Purchase or the Whiskey Rebellion. Name one cause and one result.
5. Explain how slavery and resistance to it shaped Pennsylvania, and why the 1780 law mattered. Use people-first words.
6. Describe how people earned a living near natural resources and how ways of working changed. Then explain one incentive, one cost and benefit, and how scarcity affected a choice.
7. Describe the culture of one group in Pennsylvania, how it shows up on the land, and how the beliefs of Native peoples or Quakers shaped the colony. Then sort one claim as fact or folklore, and one statement as fact or opinion.
Look back through your answers. Add evidence wherever you can.
Which answer best shows your growth as a historian? Why?
How confident are you that you can I can explain how Penn's colony grew and who gained or lost.
Pacing: reading 7 minutes, directions and examples 4, Part A 10, Part B 17, closure 2. Allow extended time; Part B may be split across two sittings or answered orally.
Evidence map: Part A: charter rights 8.2.6.B:1a and 5.1.6.D:1a; secondary source 8.1.6.D:2a; Hopewell 7.3.6.D:2a and 6.2.3-5.E:1a; regions 8.3.6.C:2a; rent 17.2.3-5.A:1a; 1780 law 8.2.6.D:3a; clocks 5.1.6.M:2a, scarcity 6.1.3-5.C:1a. Part B: Q1 8.1.6.D:1a, 8.2.6.B:1a, 5.1.6.D:1a, 5.1.6.D:2a; Q2 5.1.6.M:1a, 5.1.6.M:2a, 8.1.6.D:2a; Q3 8.2.6.C:2a, 6.2.3-5.E:2a, 8.2.6.B:2a, 7.3.6.C:1a, 8.2.6.B:3a; Q4 8.2.6.D:1a, 8.2.6.D:2a, 8.3.6.D:1a, 8.1.6.C:2a; Q5 8.3.6.D:2a, 8.2.6.D:3a; Q6 7.3.6.D:1a, 7.3.6.D:2a, 6.2.3-5.E:1a, 8.2.6.C:1a, 6.1.3-5.H:1a, 6.1.3-5.H:2a, 6.1.3-5.F:1a, 6.1.3-5.C:1a, 8.3.6.C:1a; Q7 7.3.6.B:1a, 7.3.6.B:2a, 8.2.6.C:3a, 8.1.6.D:3a, 8.1.6.C:1a.
Supports: read aloud, allow oral or scribed responses, provide sentence frames and the Guide Map. Tell students the content includes slavery and the loss of Lenape land.
Answer guide (3 points each): 3 = correct, specific evidence and clear reasoning; 2 = correct with limited evidence; 1 = partly correct or unsupported. Q2: people make government work; the saying is a primary source when read in Penn’s own writing. Q4: cooperation, 1683 deeds and trade; conflict, the Walking Purchase (Lenape called it fraud) or the Whiskey Rebellion (cash tax as cause, army and collapse as result). Q5: enslaved people resisted by escaping, as Ona Judge and Hercules did; the law was the nation’s first gradual abolition law but freed no one that day. Q6: incentives such as cheap land or Franklin’s pay. Q7: Pennsylvania German stone houses and Ephrata; Quaker peace and freedom of worship; fact vs. folklore with the elm story.
Yale Law School, The Avalon Project, Charter of Privileges Granted by William Penn (October 28, 1701) · Primary source text in the public domain; retold in our own words
On October 28, 1701, William Penn gave the people of Pennsylvania a new plan of government. It is called the Charter of Privileges. A privilege is a special right.
The first part was about religion. Anyone who believed in one God and lived peacefully could not be hurt or punished for their faith. No one could be forced to go to a church or pay for one against their will. Christians could serve in the government.
The second part set up an Assembly. Freemen would elect it every year, with four members from each county. It would meet in Philadelphia and make laws.
Another part said that people accused of crimes would have the same right to witnesses and a lawyer as the people accusing them.
Penn said the first part, about freedom of worship, must never be changed. This charter guided Pennsylvania until the Revolution. In 1751, 50 years after it was written, the Assembly ordered the bell we now call the Liberty Bell.
“THAT all Criminals shall have the same Privileges of Witnesses and Council as their Prosecutors.” (Charter of Privileges, 1701)
Source: Yale Law School, The Avalon Project, Charter of Privileges Granted by William Penn (October 28, 1701) (avalon.law.yale.edu)