compare how two sources show different points of view about the Susquehannock, and decide what each can and cannot tell us.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Two people describe the same soccer game. One was a visitor who watched for ten minutes. The other studied the whole season’s records. How might their stories differ?
Which source would tell you more about how the Susquehannock lived from day to day?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Point of view. A source’s point of view is the position its maker sees from. Where were they? What did they want? What could they know?
| Source A: John Smith | Source B: National Park Service | |
|---|---|---|
| Who? | English explorer | U.S. government agency |
| When? | visited 1608; book 1624 | written in our time |
| Why? | to map land, find riches and claim land for England | to teach visitors about a park and its history |
| Based on | a few days of meetings | archaeology and many historical records |
Worked example 1: what each source shows. Rosa writes, “Smith shows the first meeting with the English and how impressed he was. The Park Service shows the Susquehannock’s towns, trade and hard years over a long time.”
Worked example 2: a puzzle in the evidence. Kenji reads the page closely. One part says the people fell to about 900. Another says the 1676 town was home to about 3,000. He writes, “These numbers do not fit together. Maybe people from other places joined the town, or one number is wrong. I need another source.” Good historians notice when evidence does not fit.
Whose voice is missing? Both sources were made by outsiders. Smith wrote that the Susquehannock seemed like giants to the English, and the Park Service warns that his book may be embellished. The Society for Pennsylvania Archaeology says the Susquehannock are not a separate nation today, but their history lives on in neighboring nations’ histories.
Use the reading, the table and your notes from 1.02.
Write a source-comparison paragraph for our atlas.
Write a paragraph comparing Source A and Source B. Tell who made each one, what each shows and what each leaves out. End with which source you would use for an atlas page about Susquehannock towns, and why.
We compared two views and found a puzzle. Next we map many nations across Pennsylvania’s regions.
Exit ticket: what would you ask the Park Service about the two population numbers?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 10, mini lesson 10, practice 10, writing 5.
Accuracy: the population figures on the NPS page do not agree (3,000 falling to 900 before 1676, and “some 3,000” in the 1676–1680 town). Present it as a real puzzle; do not resolve it with invented facts. Smith’s description of the Susquehannock as giants comes from his own published writing (1612 and 1624); NPS cautions that his later book may be embellished. It is not a quotation from the NPS page.
Likely misconceptions: that the government source must be complete; that the Susquehannock “disappeared” with no connections to living nations.
Supports: the comparison table as a writing frame. Stretch: the public-domain quotation in the challenge box.
Answer guide: Smith: first-hand, short visit, English goals, may be embellished. NPS: long view from archaeology and records, but written by outsiders. Strong answers name the missing Susquehannock voice and the number puzzle.
National Park Service, Captain John Smith Chesapeake National Historic Trail, Native Lands Park · U.S. government work, public domain
The Susquehannock spoke an Iroquoian language. They came to the lower Susquehanna River valley around 1550, perhaps from farther north. “Susquehannock” is a name from a different Native language. The people’s own name for themselves was never written down.
They built towns with protective walls along the river and on its islands. They grew powerful through trade with other Native nations, and later with the French and the English.
Then came hard years. In the twenty years before 1676, new diseases and wars with rival nations, such as the Seneca, hurt them badly. The page says their number fell from about 3,000 to about 900.
Around 1676, the Susquehannock gathered in one town on a high spot above the river, now Native Lands Park in Wrightsville, York County. A log wall surrounded more than a dozen longhouses, each about 90 feet long and home to about 50 family members. Fields around the town gave food. The town lasted from 1676 to 1680.
“Occupied from 1676 to 1680, the town was home to some 3,000 people.” (National Park Service, Native Lands Park)
Source: National Park Service, Captain John Smith Chesapeake National Historic Trail, Native Lands Park (nps.gov)