explain how water, ice and moving plates shaped Pennsylvania’s land, compare two places, and revise atlas pages against our criteria.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Look at a picture of the Delaware Water Gap, where a river cuts right through a mountain ridge. How do you think a river could cut through solid rock?
About how deep is the Delaware Water Gap?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Earth’s surface is always changing, mostly slowly. Three big forces shaped Pennsylvania’s land: moving plates, water and ice.
Moving plates build mountains. Earth’s outer layer is broken into giant pieces called plates. Very long ago, plates pushed together along eastern North America. That squeezing folded and cracked rock and built the Appalachian Mountains.
Water wears land down. Rivers carry away tiny bits of rock every day. Over millions of years, that adds up to deep valleys and gaps. The Allegheny, Monongahela and Ohio rivers carved the valleys around Pittsburgh in this way.
Ice scrapes and leaves things behind. Glaciers covered northern Pennsylvania during the Ice Age. They scraped the land and left rock and sand when they melted.
Worked example 1: Priya compares two places. Priya compares the Delaware Water Gap with the Forks of the Ohio. “Both were shaped by rivers. The Gap is a narrow cut through a tall ridge. The Forks is a flat point where wide rivers meet. The Gap is a deep notch; the Forks is a meeting place.”
Worked example 2: Caleb revises his caption. Caleb’s draft says, “The river made the gap.” His feedback says it is not complete. He revises: “Over millions of years, streams wore away a weak spot in Kittatinny Mountain. This erosion carved the Delaware Water Gap, about 1,200 feet deep. Source: National Park Service.”
Revision studio today. Use your glow and grow notes from 1.22. Check every page against the criteria. Fix one thing at a time.
| Criterion | What it means |
|---|---|
| Accurate | Every fact traces to a named source. |
| Fair | We name specific nations, such as the Lenape, Susquehannock, Shawnee and Seneca. We never show the land as empty. We show Native nations as living peoples today. |
| Clear | Every map has a title, a key, a compass rose and a scale. Captions use short sentences a family member can read. |
| Complete | Each page shows a place, its land and water, its people and one change. |
| Constraints | One main map per page. A caption of 80 words or fewer. A source list on every page. No images of human remains or sacred objects. No costumes or role-play. |
Check your understanding, then revise.
Revision studio: improve your atlas page.
Choose your most important grow from the critique. Make the change. Write the old sentence and the new sentence.
Check your page against all four criteria. For each one, write yes or not yet, and what you did to fix any not yet.
Rivers revise the land slowly. We revise our work the same way: one careful change at a time.
Exit ticket: which revision improved your page most? Which criterion did it help?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 7 minutes, mini lecture 7, practice 9, revision studio 15, closure 2.
Likely misconceptions: that the river cut the Gap quickly; that glaciers dug the Gap (the park says erosion at a weak zone carved it, and meltwater carved the waterfalls); that mountains never change. The plate explanation is established science; the park page describes the mountain building and folding.
Supports: provide a revision checklist and sentence frames for comparison. Conference with students flagged on the 1.23 exit ticket. Stretch: explain how erosion could keep changing the Gap in the future.
Answer guide: comparisons should name a shared process (river erosion) and a difference in shape or size. Revisions should show a clear change linked to a criterion, such as adding a source, naming a nation or adding a key.
National Park Service, NPS Geodiversity Atlas: Delaware Water Gap National Recreation Area · U.S. government work, public domain
The Delaware Water Gap is a notch in Kittatinny Mountain, on the border of Pennsylvania and New Jersey. It is about 1 mile wide and 1,200 feet deep.
The rocks here started as mud, sand, gravel and lime that settled in water. Over time they hardened into rock. They are about 359 to 450 million years old.
Over hundreds of millions of years, mountain building squeezed the rock. It bent into folds and cracked along breaks called faults. One spot in the ridge became weaker than the rest.
Water wore away that weak spot more than any other place. Streams kept cutting deeper and deeper until they carved the Gap. Wearing away rock like this is called erosion.
Ice changed the land too. Between about 2 million and 20,000 years ago, huge sheets of ice called glaciers spread over the area several times. They scraped hills and left piles of rock and sand. When the ice melted, rushing water carved waterfalls. Waterfalls slowly move upstream as water wears away the rock.
Source: National Park Service, NPS Geodiversity Atlas: Delaware Water Gap National Recreation Area (nps.gov)