explain the main ideas of Penn’s 1682 Frame of Government and what Penn meant when he compared governments to clocks.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Think about a wind-up clock. It does not move by itself. Someone has to wind it. What might a clock have to do with a government?
What do you think Penn meant by comparing a government to a clock?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
A plan on paper. Penn did not want one ruler to decide everything. He wrote a plan that shared power between a governor and leaders chosen by freemen. Historians call this a representative government: people choose others to speak and vote for them.
The clock idea. Penn wrote that governments go from the motion people give them. He meant that good laws need good people. If leaders are honest, even a simple plan can work. If leaders are not, the best plan can fail.
Who had a voice? This plan gave more people a voice than most governments of that time. But it was not for everyone. Only freemen with land or who paid taxes could vote. Women, servants and enslaved people were left out, and so were the Lenape.
Worked example 1: explaining a quotation. Mei reads the clock line. She writes, “Penn means a government does not run by itself. The people in it have to work to make it good.” She put Penn’s idea into her own words.
Worked example 2: finding a main idea in a document. Jamal looks at the parts of the plan: elected Council, elected Assembly, secret ballot. He writes, “A main idea is that freemen choose their own leaders.” He used three details to support one main idea.
A document is a primary source. The Frame of Government was written in 1682 by the person who made it. That makes it a primary source. Our guide can quote it to show readers what Penn hoped for.
Read the plan’s main parts with your team. Use the reading for each answer.
Make a document card for our Market Guide’s opening page.
Write the clock quotation. Then explain it in your own words and give one example from our school or town of people making a group work well.
Write two main ideas of the Frame of Government. Give one detail from the reading for each.
We read Penn’s first plan. Next time we will see the plan he wrote in 1701, which lasted much longer.
Exit ticket: is a government with elected leaders more like a clock that runs itself, or one that people wind? Explain.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 10, mini lesson 10, guided practice 10, document card 5.
Accuracy: the Avalon text says “men”; the PA standard 5.1.6.M paraphrases it as “people.” Both are fine to discuss. The Frame is dated April 25, 1682, and the laws were agreed May 5, 1682. Article XXXIV required officeholders and voters to profess faith in Jesus Christ, so freedom of worship was wide for its time but not complete.
Likely misconceptions: that everyone could vote; that the Assembly wrote the laws at first (in 1682 the Council proposed and the Assembly accepted or rejected).
Supports: act out a wind-up toy that stops when no one winds it (not a historical role-play). Stretch: compare the 1682 plan with our student council.
Answer guide: left out: women, servants, enslaved people, the Lenape, poorer men without land. Strong answers say the plan was free for some but not all.
The Avalon Project, Yale Law School, Frame of Government of Pennsylvania (May 5, 1682) · Document text is public domain (1682); Avalon Project transcription
In 1682 William Penn wrote a plan for how Pennsylvania would be governed. It is called the Frame of Government. A frame is the shape that holds something together.
In the opening part, Penn shared his big ideas. He said a government is free for the people when the laws rule and the people help make those laws. He also compared governments to clocks. A clock moves only when someone winds it. In the same way, a government works only as well as the people who run it.
The plan had a governor and two groups of leaders. Freemen, men who owned or farmed a certain amount of land or paid taxes, would elect them. The Provincial Council had 72 members. It wrote ideas for laws. The General Assembly was a larger group, elected every year, that voted yes or no on those laws. Voting was done by secret ballot.
The laws with the plan promised that people who believed in God and lived peacefully would not be punished for how they worshiped. The plan could be changed only if the governor and most of the elected leaders agreed. Not everyone could vote. Women, servants and enslaved people could not.
“Governments, like clocks, go from the motion men give them;”
— William Penn, preface to the Frame of Government, 1682
Source: The Avalon Project, Yale Law School, Frame of Government of Pennsylvania (May 5, 1682) (avalon.law.yale.edu)