define scarcity, explain how incentives like cheap land changed choices, and weigh the costs and benefits of a farm decision, without treating people as goods.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Your class has 30 students but only 10 markers. What problem do you have? What choices could the class make?
In early Pennsylvania, what was harder to get: land or workers?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Scarcity. Scarcity means there is not enough of something for everyone who wants it. Every family and community faces scarcity, so they must make choices. In early Pennsylvania, workers and time were scarce. Later, as more people came, good land became scarcer and farms got smaller.
Incentives. A positive incentive is a reward that makes people want to do something. A negative incentive is a penalty that makes people want to avoid something. Cheap land was a positive incentive that drew settlers. High demand for flour was an incentive to grow wheat. A fine for breaking a rule is a negative incentive.
Worked example 1: costs and benefits. Here is sample data, made up for practice. The Brenner family must choose: plant more wheat, or spend the time building a springhouse. Wheat: benefit, flour to sell; cost, no springhouse this year. Springhouse: benefit, food keeps longer; cost, less flour to sell. Grace weighs it and writes, “I would plant wheat because flour was in high demand.”
Worked example 2: an incentive. Andre writes, “Because flour sold for a lot, farmers had an incentive to grow more wheat. That is a positive incentive.”
A hard truth. Scarcity of workers led some colonists to enslave people. That was not a fair trade or a free choice for the enslaved. Enslaved people got no pay and no say. Economics can explain why enslavers wanted labor, but it never makes slavery right.
Our guide. In our Market Guide we will explain goods and choices. We will never show people as goods.
Use the reading and the sample data. Sample numbers are for practice only.
Make a choices page for our guide.
Make a costs-and-benefits chart for this sample choice: a farm family can buy a second plow or save money for a new barn. List one cost and one benefit of each.
Write a sentence explaining how cheap land changed the choices of families in Europe.
Scarcity and incentives shaped colonial choices. Next we compare viewpoints on slavery in the colony.
Exit ticket: give one example of scarcity in our school or community, and one choice people make because of it.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 10, mini lesson 10, guided practice 10, chart 5.
Do not run a market game, auction or trading simulation. The Brenner family and the plow-or-barn choice are invented sample examples about tools and buildings only. Never place people in a cost-benefit chart.
Accuracy: the page gives 1,989,000 barrels of flour and 599,000 bushels of wheat per year exported 1768-1772 by the colonies, much from southeastern Pennsylvania, Delaware and New Jersey; we round to about 2 million barrels. The 19 percent figure is for eastern Chester County in the 1770s.
Likely misconceptions: that scarcity means having none; that incentives are always money.
Answer guide: slavery question: enslaved people were forced, unpaid and had no say; a trade is fair only when all sides agree freely. Exit examples: limited computers, recess time, library books.
Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia, “Plantations” · Copyright 2015 Rutgers University; retold in our own words
In early colonial times, land around Philadelphia was cheap. The hard part was finding people to do the work. One settler, Rowland Ellis, got 700 acres in the 1680s. Ten years later, he farmed only about 15 of them.
Farms were run by families. A farm often had a house, a springhouse, a smokehouse, barns and a kitchen garden. Many farmers also had a second trade, such as blacksmithing.
Wheat grew well in the region’s weather. It needed only about 25 days of work a year. By 1750 it was one of the most wanted crops in the world. Each year from 1768 to 1772, the colonies shipped out about 2 million barrels of flour.
Moving grain was slow. Oxen needed three days to haul grain 25 miles over dirt roads.
Some farm owners used indentured servants. Some held people in slavery. Slaveholding grew from 1750 to 1780, when flour sales were highest. In the 1770s, about 19 percent of households in eastern Chester County held enslaved people.
Over time, farms got smaller. The average farm was about 600 acres in 1700 and about 135 acres by 1765.
Source: Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia, “Plantations” (philadelphiaencyclopedia.org)