explain why the Liberty Bell and the State House are important historic sites, and make a claim about who gained and who lost as colonial Pennsylvania grew.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. The Liberty Bell says, “Proclaim Liberty Throughout All the Land Unto All the Inhabitants thereof.” Inhabitants means the people who live in a place. In colonial Pennsylvania, did all inhabitants have liberty?
Who first called it the Liberty Bell?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
A historic site. A historic site is a place kept because important things happened there. The Pennsylvania State House was built starting in 1732 for the colony’s government. The Assembly that the Charter of Privileges set up met there. Later, the Declaration of Independence was signed there. Today it is Independence Hall.
Continuity and change. Some things stayed the same over time: freedom of worship and an elected assembly. Some things changed: the colony grew from a few thousand settlers to a busy farm and iron region, and Philadelphia became a big port. Lenape land shrank. Slavery grew, then slowly began to end after 1780.
Gained and lost. Many settlers gained land, jobs and freedom of worship. The Penn family and merchants gained wealth. The Lenape lost much of their homeland. Enslaved Africans were denied freedom and pay. Our guide must show all of this.
Worked example 1: a historic site claim. Yusuf writes, “The Liberty Bell is important because its words about liberty for all inhabitants inspired people who worked to end slavery.”
Worked example 2: a gained-and-lost claim. Clara writes: Claim: colonial growth helped settlers but hurt the Lenape. Evidence: cheap land drew settlers, and the Walking Purchase took Lenape land. Reasoning: the land settlers gained was the land the Lenape lost.
Ready to build. In Part 2 we will draft, check and share our Colonial Pennsylvania Market Guide. Today we answer our driving question with a first claim.
Use today’s reading and your notes from the whole unit.
Plan your piece of the Market Guide.
Choose one topic for your guide page: government, the Lenape, many peoples, slavery and resistance, iron, farms and flour, or routes and wagons. List three facts and their sources.
Write a caption for a picture of the Liberty Bell for our guide. Explain why it is a historic object and who its words did not yet include in colonial times.
We finished our investigation. Next part, we build the guide.
Exit ticket: what is one thing that stayed the same and one thing that changed in Pennsylvania from 1682 to the 1760s?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 10, guided practice 12, planning 5.
Accuracy: State House construction began in 1732, and the Assembly met there from 1735 (NPS timeline, lesson 2.08); NPS says it housed all three branches of the colonial government. The NPS page says Norris “may” have chosen the words for the charter’s 50th anniversary; keep that hedge. The Declaration is named only; it is taught in later courses.
Likely misconceptions: that the bell cracked on July 4, 1776; that the bell was always called the Liberty Bell.
Supports: a gained-and-lost T-chart with each group from the unit. Stretch: compare “all the inhabitants” with who could vote under the 1701 charter.
Answer guide: gained: settlers (land, worship), the Penn family and merchants (wealth), workers who found jobs. Lost: the Lenape (homeland), enslaved Africans (freedom, pay, family). Same: freedom of worship, elected assembly. Changed: population, trade, Lenape land, slavery’s growth.
National Park Service, Independence National Historical Park, “The Liberty Bell” · U.S. government work, public domain
In 1751 Isaac Norris, the leader of Pennsylvania’s Assembly, ordered a bell from a foundry in London. It cracked the first time it was rung. In 1753 two Philadelphia metalworkers, John Pass and John Stow, melted it down and made it again.
The bell has words from the Bible: “Proclaim Liberty Throughout All the Land Unto All the Inhabitants thereof.” Norris may have chosen them to mark the 50th birthday of William Penn’s 1701 Charter of Privileges.
The bell hung in the tower of the Pennsylvania State House. Today we call that building Independence Hall.
Years later, people working to end slavery, called abolitionists, were inspired by the bell’s words. A newspaper against slavery first called it the “Liberty Bell” in 1835.
A crack grew in the 1840s. Workers tried to fix it, but a second crack formed. The bell has not rung freely since. Today it is a symbol of freedom that people from around the world come to see.
“Proclaim Liberty Throughout All the Land Unto All the Inhabitants thereof”
— inscription on the Liberty Bell, as given by the National Park Service
Source: National Park Service, Independence National Historical Park, “The Liberty Bell” (nps.gov)