separate facts from folklore about Penn’s treaty and give examples of cooperation between the Lenape and colonists.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. A famous painting shows William Penn meeting Lenape leaders under a big elm tree. Many people think it shows exactly what happened. Is a painting made 90 years later good evidence? Read and decide.
Benjamin West painted Penn's Treaty in 1771-1772. Penn arrived in 1682. About how many years later was the painting made?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Fact, folklore or fiction? A fact can be checked with evidence. Folklore is a story passed down that may have some truth in it. Fiction is made up. Historians sort the parts of a story so readers know what is proven.
Cooperation was real. Penn and Lenape leaders made agreements and signed land deeds in 1683. Lenape people and colonists traded goods. For years, Lenape leaders spoke of their friendship with Penn. These are examples of cooperation, which means working together.
So was conflict. After Penn died, his sons used the 1737 Walking Purchase to take a huge part of the Lenape homeland. Lenape leaders called it a fraud. A fair guide shows both the friendship and the broken trust.
Worked example 1: Kenji sorts the story. Kenji makes three columns. Fact: “In June 1683 Penn and Tamanend signed land deeds.” Folklore: “They met under the great elm in 1682.” Not proven: “The wampum belt was given to Penn at the treaty.” Each claim goes where the evidence puts it.
Worked example 2: Rosa writes a conclusion. Rosa writes: “Penn and the Lenape did make agreements and promise friendship. But no record proves the famous meeting under the elm. The painting came about 90 years later and was paid for by Penn’s son.” Her conclusion is backed by sources.
Ask who told the story and why. Thomas Penn paid for the painting. It made the Penn family look good. That does not make it false, but it is a reason to check it against other sources.
Sort the claims with your team.
Draft a “Fact or Folklore?” box for the guide.
Make a three-row chart: fact, folklore, not proven. Put one claim about Penn's treaty in each row and name your source.
Give one example of cooperation and one example of conflict between the Lenape and Penn's colony. Explain why a fair guide needs both.
A good guide tells readers what we know, what we think and what is only a story.
Exit ticket: what is one question you would still ask about Penn's treaty? What kind of source could answer it?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 9 minutes, mini lecture 9, career 2, guided practice 11, chart 6, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: that folklore is always false; that the painting is a photograph-like record; that cooperation erased conflict. Do not have students re-enact the treaty or wear costumes. Present the Lenape as a nation making agreements, and note the Lenape (Delaware) nations continue today.
Supports: color-coded claim cards (green fact, yellow folklore, gray not proven). Stretch: why might Lenape leaders in the 1700s have reminded colonists of Penn’s promises?
Answer guide: fact: 1683 deeds with Tamanend; folklore: 1682 meeting under the elm; not proven: wampum belt given at the treaty. Cooperation: trade, deeds, promises of friendship; conflict: the 1737 Walking Purchase. Career facts from bls.gov/ooh/life-physical-and-social-science/historians.htm.
Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia (Rutgers University-Camden), Treaty of Shackamaxon · Copyright Rutgers University; retold in our own words with a link to the source
A famous story says that soon after William Penn arrived in 1682, he met Lenape leaders at Shackamaxon, in today’s Fishtown neighborhood of Philadelphia. Under a great elm tree, they promised to be friends forever.
Historians have a problem. No written record from the meeting itself survives. Penn’s busy schedule in late 1682 is well recorded, so the 1682 date seems unlikely.
Some facts are clear. In June 1683, Penn and Lenape leaders, including Tamanend, signed deeds about land. Promises of friendship were likely made, maybe under the elm. Later Lenape leaders often spoke about their friendship with Penn.
The legend grew over time. Thomas Penn, William’s son, paid Benjamin West to paint the scene in 1771-1772. The painting shaped how people pictured it. A wampum belt showing two figures holding hands is said to have been given to Penn, but that is a claim, not proof. The elm fell in a storm in 1810.
Source: Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia (Rutgers University-Camden), Treaty of Shackamaxon (philadelphiaencyclopedia.org)