describe how a group’s culture shows up on the land and revise a guide page so it is accurate, fair, clear and complete.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. People call some Pennsylvanians the “Pennsylvania Dutch.” But most did not come from the Netherlands. Where did the name come from? Read to find out.
The name Pennsylvania Dutch comes from which word?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Culture leaves marks on the land. Culture is a group’s way of life: its language, customs, religion, food and ways of building. When people move, they bring culture with them. You can see it in a region’s buildings, place names and churches.
Pennsylvania German culture. German-speaking settlers kept their language, their churches and their building styles. Stone houses with central chimneys, German room names and religious communities like Ephrata made southeastern Pennsylvania look and sound different from other regions.
Beliefs shaped the colony. Penn’s promise of freedom of worship drew many faiths: Quakers, German Pietists, Mennonites and others. Lenape beliefs and ways continued too, even as their homeland shrank. Many beliefs side by side is part of Pennsylvania’s story.
Worked example 1: Liam describes culture in a place. Liam writes: “In the Pennsylvania German region, people spoke German, built stone houses around a central chimney and formed religious communities like the Ephrata Cloister.” He names a language, a custom and a religion.
Worked example 2: Maya revises with criteria. Maya’s draft says, “Lots of people came for stuff.” She checks the criteria. Clear? Not really. Accurate? No source. Her revision: “German-speaking settlers came in the early 1700s, partly for freedom of worship (PHMC).” Now it is clear, accurate and sourced.
Revision studio steps. First, reread your feedback from the gallery critique. Second, fix one accuracy problem and one fairness problem. Third, cut your main text to 100 words or fewer. Fourth, check that no person is listed as a good and that any made-up number is labelled sample.
Use this table as your checklist.
| Criterion | What it means |
|---|---|
| Accurate | Every claim traces to a named source. |
| Fair | We show more than one viewpoint. We name specific nations, like the Lenape. We show enslaved people as people who had families, skills and ways of resisting. |
| Clear | A neighbor can read it without help. |
| Complete | It tells who, where, when, what changed, and who gained or lost. |
| Constraints | One page per team. Main text of 100 words or fewer. People are never listed as goods or given prices. No costumes or role-play. Any made-up number is labelled sample. |
Warm up your revising eye.
Revise your page.
Make your two most important changes from the gallery critique. Write what you changed and which criterion it helps.
Describe the languages, customs and religions of one group in colonial Pennsylvania, and explain how its culture shows up on the land.
Good writers and good historians both revise.
Exit ticket: is your page ready? Rate it on each criterion from 1 to 3 and name one last fix.
Pacing: warm-up and reading 8 minutes, mini lecture 7, guided practice 8, revision 14, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: that “Pennsylvania Dutch” means from Holland; that all Pennsylvania Germans were Amish; that culture is only food and clothing. This reading is an archived 2015 PHMC page; it does not discuss bank barns, so avoid adding barn claims to it.
Supports: a revision checklist from the criteria table; partner read-aloud. Stretch: compare how Lenape and Pennsylvania German cultures each show up on the land today.
Answer guide: culture answers name a language (German), customs (building styles, central chimney, room names) and religion (Pietists, Mennonites, Quakers), linked to visible marks on the land. Revision reflections should match each change to a criterion.
Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, Pennsylvania German Traditional 1700-1870 (archived architecture guide) · Commonwealth of Pennsylvania (PHMC) web page; retold in our own words with a link to the source
In the early 1700s, settlers from German-speaking parts of Europe began arriving in southeastern Pennsylvania. Later they spread across the state. The name “Pennsylvania Dutch” comes from Deutsch, the German word for German.
Their early houses were made of log or stone, with steep roofs, thick walls and small windows. Many had two or three rooms around a central chimney. One plan had a kitchen, called a kuche, on one side and a living room, called a stube, on the other. Some stone houses were built over springs for cool water. Some were built into hillsides.
Religion shaped the land too. In 1732, a German religious community began the Ephrata Cloister in Lancaster County. They came because Pennsylvania allowed freedom of worship. By 1750 the community had a chapel, homes, mills, a bake house and barns. Today the state cares for it as a historic site.
Source: Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, Pennsylvania German Traditional 1700-1870 (archived architecture guide) (phmc.state.pa.us)