plan a Market Guide page with criteria and a historical question that evidence can answer.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Picture a busy market in Philadelphia in the 1760s. Barrels are rolling toward the ships. What do you think is inside most of them? Read today’s reading to check.
What was packed into many of the barrels leaving Philadelphia?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Junior historians, welcome to Build. In the last lessons you studied Penn’s ideas, the land and the many people of the colony. Now you will turn that evidence into the Colonial Pennsylvania Market Guide. It is a guide, like one you might pick up at a museum. It is not a play. We explain the past; we do not act it out.
Our audience is real. Families and neighbors in our East Allegheny community will read the guide. It answers our driving question: how did Penn’s ideas, the land and the work of many people make the colony grow, and who gained or lost?
The guide has four pages. Penn’s Plan explains his charters and ideas. Land and Work shows how people earned a living. Roads, Rivers and Markets follows goods on the move. Who Gained and Who Lost shows cooperation, conflict and slavery. A shared Guide Map and Timeline ties them together. The topics you chose in lesson 2.14 fit here: government goes on Penn’s Plan; iron, farms and flour go on Land and Work; routes and wagons go on Roads, Rivers and Markets; and the Lenape, many peoples, and slavery and resistance go on Who Gained and Who Lost.
Every page starts with a research question. A good historical question can be answered with evidence. “Was colonial life fun?” is hard to prove. “What did Pennsylvania farms sell, and who bought it?” can be answered from sources.
Worked example 1: Mateo’s question. Mateo first writes, “Were farmers rich?” That is too big and has no clear evidence. He checks the reading and revises: “Why did so much flour leave Philadelphia?” Now he can answer with two causes from the reading: crop failures in Europe and food needs in the West Indies.
Worked example 2: Aisha compares regions. Aisha’s page is Roads, Rivers and Markets. She asks, “How was Pennsylvania’s main crop different from Virginia’s?” Pennsylvania farms grew wheat for flour. Southern colonies such as Virginia grew tobacco to sell. Both are cash crops, which means crops grown to sell. Each one shaped its region.
Our criteria and constraints. The class will judge every page by these rules. Read them with your team.
| Criterion | What it means |
|---|---|
| Accurate | Every claim traces to a named source. |
| Fair | We show more than one viewpoint. We name specific nations, like the Lenape. We show enslaved people as people who had families, skills and ways of resisting. |
| Clear | A neighbor can read it without help. |
| Complete | It tells who, where, when, what changed, and who gained or lost. |
| Constraints | One page per team. Main text of 100 words or fewer. People are never listed as goods or given prices. No costumes or role-play. Any made-up number is labelled sample. |
Work with your team and keep the reading open.
Start your own page plan.
List the parts of your page: headline, main text, one source card, one map or timeline item, and a source list. Next to each, write the evidence you have or a question mark.
Use the reading to explain how the flour trade changed life in the colony. Name one group that gained and one group that did not.
A guide makes a promise to its readers: we will tell you something true, and we will show how we know.
Exit ticket: write your research question. Circle the word that tells what evidence you need to find.
Pacing: warm-up and reading 8 minutes, mini lecture 9, team guided practice 13, page plan 7, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: that a plantation always meant a Southern slave labor camp (in colonial Pennsylvania it meant a large farm, but some Pennsylvania farms did use enslaved labor); that a guide is a play; that any question is a research question.
Supports: offer the frame “Why did ___ happen in ___?” Pre-assign the four pages so every team has an owner; any team may add to the Guide Map and Timeline. Stretch: ask for a second question that compares two regions.
Answer guide: strong questions ask why, how or what changed, and name a place or time. The exit check on the trade should name a cause (demand in Europe and the West Indies) and note that farm families and merchants gained, while enslaved people and indentured servants worked without sharing fairly in the gain.
Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia (Rutgers University-Camden), Plantations · Copyright Rutgers University; retold in our own words with a link to the source
In the 1700s, a plantation in Pennsylvania meant a large piece of land, about 100 to 1,000 acres. Smaller places were called farms. Most were run by families. They had a farmhouse, a springhouse to keep milk cool, a smokehouse for meat and barns for animals.
By 1750, wheat was one of the most wanted crops in the world. Mills ground the wheat into flour. From 1768 to 1772, the British colonies sent out about 1,989,000 barrels of flour every year. Much of it came from southeastern Pennsylvania, Delaware and New Jersey.
Who bought it? Crops had failed in parts of Europe. On the sugar islands of the West Indies, the number of enslaved people forced to work was growing, and the islands needed food. Ships carried flour from Philadelphia to meet these needs.
Farm work took many hands. Some farmers used indentured servants, and some held people in slavery. Moving crops was slow, too. One team of oxen could take three days to haul grain 25 miles, so merchants wanted better roads.
Source: Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia (Rutgers University-Camden), Plantations (philadelphiaencyclopedia.org)