tell primary sources from secondary sources and explain what William Penn meant when he wrote about government and the people.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. A clock does not run by itself. Someone has to wind it. In 1682, William Penn compared a government to a clock. What do you think he meant? Read on.
In Penn's comparison, who gives a government its motion?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Two kinds of sources. A primary source was made by someone who was there at the time. Penn’s Frame of Government is a primary source because Penn wrote it in 1682. A secondary source was made later by someone who studied the past, like an encyclopedia article or your textbook.
Both are useful. A primary source lets us hear a person’s own words. A secondary source helps us understand them, adds background and often compares many sources. Historians use both and check them against each other.
Penn’s big idea. Penn wrote that a government is free when the laws rule and the people help make those laws. His clock comparison means that a government is only as good as the people who run it. If people are good, he believed, the government will not be bad.
Worked example 1: Grace sorts two sources. Grace has Penn’s 1682 preface and the reading summary we wrote today. She labels the preface primary because Penn wrote it in 1682. She labels our summary secondary because we wrote it much later. Her source card says, “Penn’s words, 1682, retold by our class.”
Worked example 2: Omar explains the clock. Omar writes: “Penn compared government to a clock. A clock needs someone to wind it. Penn meant that people make a government work, so people should take part and act well.” He states the idea, then explains it in his own words.
Be fair about limits. Penn’s plan gave a say to freemen, but not to everyone. Women, enslaved people and people who were not Christian could not vote or hold office. A fair guide page shows both the new idea and who was left out.
Use the reading and the worked examples.
Add to the Penn’s Plan page or your own team page.
Write a source card for Penn's Frame of Government: who wrote it, when, primary or secondary, and one big idea in your own words.
Find one secondary source in our unit folder that helps you understand a primary source. Explain how the two work together.
Penn’s words are a primary source. Our guide will be a secondary source that helps neighbors understand them.
Exit ticket: in one or two sentences, explain Penn's clock idea to a second grader.
Pacing: warm-up and reading 8 minutes, mini lecture 9, guided practice 12, source card 8, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: that old means primary (a 1900 book about 1682 is secondary for 1682); that secondary sources are untrustworthy; that Penn’s colony gave everyone a vote.
Supports: a two-column sort with picture icons; read the Penn quotation aloud and paraphrase it together. The full preface uses 1600s English, so share only the short quotation. Stretch: compare Penn’s idea with how our school board is chosen today.
Answer guide: source cards name Penn, 1682, primary, and a big idea such as “people make the government work.” Open responses should note women, enslaved people and non-Christians could not vote or hold office, and that showing this keeps the page fair. Council size (72) and the Christian office-holding rule come from the Frame and its Laws Agreed Upon in England on the Avalon page.
Yale Law School, The Avalon Project, Frame of Government of Pennsylvania (May 5, 1682) · Primary source text in the public domain; retold in our own words
In 1682, William Penn wrote a plan for governing his new colony. He called it a Frame of Government. Before the rules, he wrote a preface, a short opening that explains his ideas.
Penn said a government is free for the people under it when the laws rule and the people take part in making those laws. He compared governments to clocks. A clock runs because someone winds it. A government runs well or badly because of the people who run it.
The plan set up a governor, a Provincial Council and a General Assembly. The freemen, meaning men who could vote, chose the members. The Council had 72 members. The Assembly voted yes or no on the laws the Council proposed.
The laws that came with the plan protected people who believed in God and lived peacefully from being punished for their religion. That was unusual for the time. But it had limits. Only Christians could hold office or vote, and women and enslaved people could not vote at all.
“Governments, like clocks, go from the motion men give them” (William Penn, Preface to the Frame of Government, 1682)
Source: Yale Law School, The Avalon Project, Frame of Government of Pennsylvania (May 5, 1682) (avalon.law.yale.edu)