The Pennsylvania Places and Peoples Atlas
How can we make an atlas that shows how Pennsylvania’s land shaped the lives of its first peoples, and how those nations are still here today?
The mystery: Rivers like the Susquehanna, the Delaware and the Allegheny carried canoes and trade long before there were roads. Why did so many towns grow where rivers meet?
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
identify who made a source, when and why, and sort our Wonder Board questions by the kind of source that could answer them.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. Imagine a visitor comes to our school for one day. Later, the visitor writes a book about it. Would the book tell everything about our school? What might it miss?
A traveler writes a book years after a short visit. What should a careful reader do?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
A source is anything that gives us information about the past. A primary source was made at the time, such as Smith’s 1608 map or journal. A secondary source was made later by someone studying the past, such as today’s Park Service article.
Three sourcing questions. Every time you meet a source, ask: Who made it? When? Why? The answers help you decide what the source can teach you, and what it might leave out.
Worked example 1: sourcing Smith’s book. Priya asks the three questions. Who? John Smith, an English explorer. When? 1624, sixteen years after the meeting. Why? He wanted to tell English readers about his trips and about land England might claim. Priya decides the book is a useful primary source, but it shows an outsider’s view, and it may stretch the truth.
Worked example 2: whose voice is missing? Marcus notices that no Susquehannock person wrote down their side of the meeting. He writes, “We only have the English story. The Susquehannock leaders had their own reasons for meeting Smith, but we have to look for other evidence.” That other evidence includes archaeology and the histories Native nations keep themselves.
More than writing. Many first peoples of Pennsylvania did not keep written records. So we also learn from the things they made and left behind, which is archaeology. Native nations keep knowledge through oral history, history passed down by speaking.
Today’s workshop. We will sort the Wonder Board into four groups: questions for maps and the land, for artifacts and sites, for written records, and for the voices of Native nations today.
Use the reading and our three sourcing questions. Talk with your team before you answer.
Source something on your own.
Pick any object in your backpack or classroom. Imagine a historian finds it in 500 years. Who made it, when and why? What could it teach, and what could it not teach?
Our questions are sorted, and we have our three sourcing questions. Next we open the map and learn to say exactly where a place is.
Exit ticket: why should we be careful when we use John Smith's book as evidence about the Susquehannock?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 10, sorting workshop 12, exit ticket 5.
Setup: a four-column chart: maps and the land; artifacts and sites; written records; Native nations’ voices today.
Likely misconceptions: “primary means true”; “people without writing have no history.” Treat oral history as a real source with its own methods. Note that the Susquehannock name for themselves was never recorded; “Susquehannock” came from another language (see 1.11).
Supports: a three-box who/when/why organizer. Stretch: why might an explorer who wanted support for more trips make his story more exciting?
Answer guide: Smith was an outsider, he wrote years later for English readers, and the Park Service warns parts may be embellished. Strong answers add that the Susquehannock side is missing.
National Park Service, A Closer Look: John Smith's Chesapeake Voyages · U.S. government work, public domain
In 1608, the English explorer John Smith sailed up the Chesapeake Bay. His second trip lasted from July 24 to September 7. His crew reached the mouth of the Susquehanna River, which flows down from Pennsylvania.
Smith wanted to meet the Susquehannock people. He waited at a town of the Tockwogh people from August 2 to 7 while Susquehannock leaders decided what to do. Then about sixty Susquehannock people, with five leaders called weroances, came down the river. The two groups traded goods and shared a feast. The page says Smith was impressed by the Susquehannock. Their languages were Iroquoian, like those of the Great Lakes region.
Smith had several goals. He wanted to make maps, look for gold and silver, learn about Native peoples and claim land for England. His trips produced a map and journals. In 1624 he published a longer book about them.
The Park Service gives a warning. Smith’s later book has more detail than his journals. Some parts may have been embellished, which means made more exciting, or even made up.
Source: National Park Service, A Closer Look: John Smith's Chesapeake Voyages (nps.gov)