use archaeological evidence to explain how Monongahela villagers depended on and adjusted to their environment, and what changed over time.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Archaeologists dig up a village. In some trash pits they find lots of burned corn. In others, they find almost none. What questions would you ask?
If a village had less corn than usual, what might that tell us?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Who were the Monongahela? “Monongahela” is a name archaeologists use for villages along the Monongahela, Allegheny and Ohio valleys and nearby. We do not know what the people called themselves. They farmed corn, beans and squash, hunted, fished and gathered wild foods.
Depend, adjust, change. People depend on their environment for water, food and building materials. They adjust to it by changing how they live. Sort the clues from the reading into these columns.
Worked example 1: sorting a clue. Chloe reads that corn appeared in only 34 percent of the later pits. She writes under depended on: “They depended on corn, so a cooler climate that hurt crops would make life hard.”
Worked example 2: change over time. Andre compares the two big villages. “Around 1170, houses were round with a stockade. Around 1330, houses were smaller and people ate more snails. Something changed, maybe the climate.” He used the word maybe, because the author says this is his belief.
What happened next? The State Museum of Pennsylvania says Monongahela villages disappear from the archaeological record by about 1635. That does not mean the people vanished. They may have moved or joined other nations. Archaeology alone cannot tell us who their descendants are.
Respect the site. Archaeological sites cannot be replaced. If you ever find an artifact, leave it in place and tell an adult or a park ranger.
Use your depend-adjust-change chart and the reading.
Write an atlas caption.
Write a three-sentence caption for a picture of a Monongahela village. Include one fact about the land, one about food and one thing archaeologists are not sure about.
We used evidence from the ground. Next we hear from a Lenape nation itself about life along the Delaware River.
Exit ticket: why should our atlas say “may have” when it explains the Monongahela villages' hard times?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 10, mini lesson 8, practice 12, closure 5.
Accuracy: Monongahela dates differ by source (this site about 900 to 1600; the State Museum gives about 1000 to 1635). The Carnegie article is from 1997 and gives one archaeologist’s interpretation. Do not say the people “mysteriously vanished.”
Likely misconceptions: that Native people only hunted (they farmed); that one site explains all Monongahela life.
Supports: a three-column chart with picture icons. Stretch: why would archaeologists compare this site with three others?
Answer guide: depended on corn, river snails, wood for houses and stockades, streams for water. Adjusted: ate snails when corn was scarce, built smaller houses. Exit ticket: the evidence suggests, but does not prove, a cause.
Carnegie Museum of Natural History, Richard L. George, A Prehistoric Food Crisis in Washington County (Carnegie Magazine, 1997) · Copyright Carnegie Museums; summarized in our own words with a link
From 1989 to 1991, archaeologists from Carnegie Museum of Natural History dug at a site on the old Wylie Farm in Washington County, south of Pittsburgh. Volunteers from a local archaeology club helped. Most of the artifacts were left by Monongahela people.
The team found that people lived there four different times, between about 900 and 1600. The two biggest villages were around 1170 and 1330. The earlier village had round houses and a stockade, a wall of wooden posts. The later village had somewhat smaller houses.
The clues suggest hard times in the later village. Corn showed up in only 34 percent of its trash pits. At three other Monongahela sites, it showed up in half or more. People also ate small river snails, which the author thinks were a poor food.
The author explains why. In the 1200s and 1300s the climate cooled, and some scholars think there were more people and fewer resources. He says this is his belief based on the evidence, and that more digging could teach more.
Source: Carnegie Museum of Natural History, Richard L. George, A Prehistoric Food Crisis in Washington County (Carnegie Magazine, 1997) (carnegiemuseums.org)