describe ways people got income and explain how rewards, penalties and scarcity changed people’s choices.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. In 1755 a British army needed wagons, but there were not enough. Benjamin Franklin had to convince Pennsylvania farmers to rent out their wagons. What would you offer them? Read how he did it.
What is it called when there is not enough of something that people want?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Income is money people receive. People get income in different ways. They can work for wages, like a wagon driver. They can rent property to others, like a farmer renting out a wagon. They can also receive gifts, like money from a family member.
Scarcity forces choices. Scarcity means there is not enough of something people want. In 1755 the army had too few wagons. When something is scarce, people must decide how to use what they have, and sometimes they must pay more to get it.
Incentives change choices. An incentive is a reward or a penalty that makes people act. Franklin used a positive incentive: good daily pay and pay in advance. He also mentioned a negative incentive: soldiers might take wagons by force. Penn used an incentive too. He advertised land that was cheaper than in Europe, and that drew many settlers to Pennsylvania.
Worked example 1: Hannah sorts income. Hannah sorts three examples. “A teamster driving the wagon: work. A farmer renting his wagon to the army: renting property. A grandparent giving coins: a gift.” She uses the reading for the first two.
Worked example 2: Eli weighs costs and benefits. Eli imagines a Lancaster farmer deciding whether to rent his wagon. Benefits: 15 shillings a day and pay in advance. Costs: the farmer has no wagon for his own harvest, and the wagon might be lost. Eli writes: “The farmer might say yes because the pay was good and losses would be repaid, but it was still a risk.”
A fair reminder. Wages are income for work. Enslaved people worked without wages; others took the value of their labor. Our guide will never list people as property for rent or sale.
Use Franklin’s account and the worked examples.
Draft a box for the Land and Work page.
Write a 40-word guide box called “Three Ways to Earn Income in the Colony.” Give one example each of work, renting property and a gift.
Explain how cheap land worked as an incentive that drew settlers to Pennsylvania. Who gained, and whose land was it before?
Incentives are everywhere: a sale price, a late fee, a reward chart.
Exit ticket: name one positive and one negative incentive in your own life and tell how each changes your choices.
Pacing: warm-up and reading 9 minutes, mini lecture 9, guided practice 11, guide box 8, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: that income only means a paycheck; that incentives are only rewards; that cheap land was empty land. Remind students that Pennsylvania land was Lenape and other nations’ homeland, connecting to Part 1 and the Walking Purchase.
Supports: a three-picture sort (work, rent, gift); a reward/penalty T-chart. Avoid any activity that sets prices on people. Stretch: why did Franklin’s promise to pay for lost wagons put him at risk?
Answer guide: cost: losing the wagon for the farm or risk of loss; benefit: daily pay, advance pay, repayment. Incentive answers: cheap land was a reward that drew settlers; settlers and Penn’s family gained, while Lenape people lost homeland. Dollar figures should not be converted; shillings and pounds are British money of the time.
Standard Ebooks, The Autobiography of Benjamin Franklin, chapter 16 · Public domain text (Standard Ebooks edition released under CC0)
In 1755, British General Edward Braddock planned to march toward the French fort where Pittsburgh is now. His army did not have enough wagons and horses. Benjamin Franklin offered to help.
On April 26, 1755, Franklin put up a notice in Lancaster. He would rent wagons and horses from farmers. A wagon with four good horses and a driver would earn 15 shillings a day. A horse with a pack saddle would earn 2 shillings a day. Owners could get seven days’ pay in advance. If a wagon or horse was lost, the owner would be paid what it was worth.
Franklin also warned that if farmers did not agree soon, soldiers might come and take wagons by force. Within about two weeks, farmers sent 150 wagons and 259 carrying horses.
Braddock’s army was defeated. Many wagons and horses were lost, and the owners asked to be paid. The claims came to nearly 20,000 pounds. Franklin had promised payment, so he worried until officials agreed to pay the claims.
Source: Standard Ebooks, The Autobiography of Benjamin Franklin, chapter 16 (standardebooks.org)