The Colonial Pennsylvania Market Guide
How did William Penn’s ideas, the land and the work of many different people make colonial Pennsylvania grow, and who gained or lost?
The mystery: In 1682 William Penn promised freedom of worship, yet in 1737 the Walking Purchase took a huge part of the Lenape homeland. How could both happen in one colony?
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
tell the difference between fact, opinion and legend in the story of Penn’s treaty with the Lenape.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. Read these three sentences. “Our school opened in 1990.” “Our school is the best school ever.” “A ghost lives in the gym.” Which one can be checked with records?
Which sentence is a fact that can be checked?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Three kinds of statements. A fact can be checked with evidence. An opinion tells what someone thinks or feels. A legend is a story passed down over time that may have some truth, but its details cannot be proved.
Why it matters for our guide. Families will trust our Market Guide. If we print a legend as a fact, we break that trust. So we label each idea clearly.
Evidence can come in many forms. Europeans wrote on paper. The Lenape also kept important agreements with wampum belts and spoken memory. Both are real records. A careful historian looks at all of them.
Worked example 1: sorting a sentence. Keisha reads, “Penn was the kindest leader in history.” She asks, “Can this be checked?” No. It is an opinion. She writes it in the Opinion column.
Worked example 2: a legend with some evidence. Omar reads that Penn signed a Great Treaty under an elm tree. He checks the reading. There is no treaty paper, and the famous painting came 90 years later. But there is a wampum belt. Omar writes, “Penn and the Lenape likely made peace agreements. The tree story is a legend.”
Quaker beliefs and Lenape ways. Penn’s Quaker faith taught peace and fair dealing. Lenape leaders also valued agreements made face to face and kept with wampum. For almost 50 years, these ways helped keep the peace.
With your team, sort each statement. Use the reading as your evidence.
Use the Wonder Board questions from last lesson.
Write one fact, one opinion and one legend about Penn and the Lenape. Label each one and explain how you knew.
Pick one Wonder Board question. What kind of source could answer it: a law, a map, a wampum belt, a record of numbers, or a tribal nation's history?
We learned to label facts, opinions and legends. Next we will read Penn’s own plan for government.
Exit ticket: in one sentence, explain the difference between a fact and a legend.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 10, mini lesson 10, sorting 10, Wonder Board 5.
Accuracy: the elm-tree “Great Treaty” is a tradition. The Delaware Nation’s history also says no paper documents survive and that Lenape records show complaints about Penn’s unpaid debts (used in lesson 2.05). Do not teach that Penn was perfect or that the Lenape simply “gave” land.
Likely misconceptions: that only written papers count as evidence; that a legend is a lie. A legend may hold some truth, but its details are not proved.
Supports: a three-column chart (Fact, Opinion, Legend). Stretch: why might people in the 1770s want a happy picture of Penn’s treaty?
Answer guide: wampum belts were how Lenape leaders recorded agreements; different peoples keep records in different ways. Exit tickets should say a fact can be checked and a legend’s details cannot.
Haverford College Libraries, Penn Treaty Elm project, “The Legend of Penn's Treaty with the Lenape” · Copyright 2017 Haverford College Libraries; retold in our own words
Many people have heard a story about William Penn. It says that in 1682 Penn met Lenape leaders under a great elm tree at Shackamaxon, beside the Delaware River. In the story, Penn promised to live in love with the Lenape. A Lenape leader named Tamanend promised peace for as long as the sun, moon and stars last.
The reading explains that much of this story grew from a painting by Benjamin West. He made it about 90 years after the meeting. He was not there.
So what is the evidence? No written treaty paper has been found. But there is a wampum belt, a belt of shell beads, that shows two people holding hands. It is said to have been given to Penn. Today it is at a Philadelphia museum. Early writers also said Penn made friendship treaties. The Lenape kept records in their own ways, such as wampum, not only on paper.
The writers think Penn probably made several agreements of peace, not one “Great Treaty.” Peace lasted almost 50 years. Then, in 1737, the Walking Purchase ended the goodwill.
Source: Haverford College Libraries, Penn Treaty Elm project, “The Legend of Penn's Treaty with the Lenape” (ds-archive.haverford.edu)