compare the viewpoints of the 1688 Germantown protesters and the Quaker meetings that set it aside, separating fact from opinion.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. The Golden Rule says: treat others the way you want to be treated. How could someone use that rule to argue against slavery?
In 1688 four men asked their Quaker meeting to stand against slavery. What do you think the meeting did?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Same faith, different choices. The four Germantown writers and the meetings that set aside their protest were all Quakers. They shared beliefs about peace and fairness. But they did not agree on what to do about slavery. Comparing their viewpoints helps us see how hard change can be.
Fact or opinion? “The protest was written in 1688” is a fact. “Slavery is wrong because it breaks the Golden Rule” is the writers’ belief, an argument they made. Today almost everyone agrees with it. A historian still labels it as their argument and shows the evidence they used.
Worked example 1: comparing viewpoints. Isabel writes, “The Germantown writers said slavery broke the Golden Rule. The meetings said the question was too weighty to decide. The writers wanted action now. The meetings put it off.”
Worked example 2: cause and result over time. Darnell uses lesson 2.08. He writes, “Because the meetings put off the question, slavery went on. Quaker leaders did not tell members to stop buying and selling enslaved people until 1754 and 1758.”
Voices we do not hear. The protest was written by white colonists. Enslaved Africans in Pennsylvania did not leave many written records from this time. But their actions, running away, keeping families together and building community, were their own strong protest.
Back to our puzzle. Penn’s colony promised freedom of worship. Some colonists used that same faith to argue for freedom for all. Others looked away. Both are part of the story.
Compare the two viewpoints using the reading.
Write a viewpoints box for our guide.
Make a two-column box: Germantown writers and the Quaker meetings. Write what each believed and what each did.
Write a CER: Did the Germantown protest matter, even though no one acted on it in 1688? Use one fact.
We compared viewpoints. Next we pull everything together: who gained and who lost as the colony grew?
Exit ticket: name one fact and one argument from today's reading.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 10, mini lesson 10, guided practice 10, viewpoints box 5.
Accuracy: NPS says the petition went from the Monthly Meeting at Dublin/Abington to the Philadelphia Quarterly Meeting and then the Yearly Meeting held in Burlington, NJ. The 1754 and 1758 Quaker steps come from the NPS timeline in lesson 2.08. The Golden Rule wording is quoted as it appears on the NPS page.
Do not stage a debate in which students argue for slavery. Compare what historical groups did; do not have students take the enslavers’ side.
Likely misconceptions: that all Quakers opposed slavery from the start; that one protest ended slavery.
Answer guide: same beliefs (fairness, the Golden Rule) led the writers to act, while the meetings feared the weight of the decision and delayed. CER: yes, it was the first such protest and inspired later abolitionists who found it in 1844.
National Park Service, “Germantown Quaker Petition Against Slavery” · U.S. government work, public domain
In 1688 four Quakers in Germantown, Pennsylvania, wrote a protest. One was Francis Daniel Pastorius, a young German lawyer. They sent it to their Quaker meeting. It was the first protest against the slavery of Africans by a religious group in the English colonies.
The writers used the Golden Rule: do unto others as you would have them do unto you. They argued that every person, no matter their color or beliefs, has rights that should not be taken away. They asked the Quakers to end slavery.
The local meeting agreed that the question was important and just. But it said the question was too hard to decide. It sent the protest to a larger meeting. That meeting called it a “weighty matter” and passed it on again. No meeting acted on it.
The protest was set aside and forgotten. Abolitionists found it again in 1844. It was lost again and found in 2005 in a vault at a Philadelphia meeting house. Today it is cared for at Haverford College.
“Do unto others as you would have them do unto you.”
— the Golden Rule, as quoted on the NPS page about the 1688 petition
Source: National Park Service, “Germantown Quaker Petition Against Slavery” (nps.gov)