compare how different sources show different views about the land, and use peer critique to make our atlas pages more accurate and fair.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Imagine you let a neighbor use your yard to plant a garden. Years later, the neighbor says the yard belongs to them. How might each of you tell the story differently?
Who wrote today's reading?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Every source has a point of view. A point of view is the way a person or group sees something. To read a source well, ask: who wrote it, when and why? This is called sourcing.
Two views of the same agreement. Colonists wrote deeds, papers that said land now belonged to them. They saw the goods they gave as payment. The Delaware Tribe explains that the Lenape saw land as something people share and use, not something one person owns. Both groups could look at the same agreement and believe different things happened.
Worked example 1: Zoe sources two documents. Zoe compares a colonial deed with the Delaware Tribe’s web page. The deed was written by colonists in the 1600s or 1700s who wanted land. The web page was written by the Lenape nation today to tell its own history. She writes: “Each source shows the view of the people who made it. I need both to understand what happened.”
Worked example 2: Andre corroborates a date. Andre reads that the Delaware signed the first Indian treaty with the United States in 1778. The Point State Park history page also says the first peace treaty between American Indians and the United States was signed at Fort Pitt in 1778. Two different sources agree, so he trusts the date more.
Today is gallery critique. Teams post their draft pages. You will walk the gallery and leave feedback based on our criteria: accurate, fair, clear and complete. Kind, specific and helpful feedback is the rule. Say one “glow” (something strong) and one “grow” (something to improve), and point to the exact place on the page.
| Criterion | What it means |
|---|---|
| Accurate | Every fact traces to a named source. |
| Fair | We name specific nations, such as the Lenape, Susquehannock, Shawnee and Seneca. We never show the land as empty. We show Native nations as living peoples today. |
| Clear | Every map has a title, a key, a compass rose and a scale. Captions use short sentences a family member can read. |
| Complete | Each page shows a place, its land and water, its people and one change. |
| Constraints | One main map per page. A caption of 80 words or fewer. A source list on every page. No images of human remains or sacred objects. No costumes or role-play. |
Compare the views first. Then use the criteria during the gallery walk.
Use the feedback on your own page.
Read the feedback on your page. Choose the most important grow. Write what you will change and why.
Add one sentence to your page that shows a Native nation's own view or voice, and credit the source.
Listening to more than one voice does not make history confusing. It makes it true.
Exit ticket: why does it matter that today's reading was written by the Delaware Tribe itself?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 7 minutes, mini lecture 7, career 2, viewpoint comparison 8, gallery walk 12, revision note 2, closure 2.
Likely misconceptions: that one side must be lying; that Native nations had no system for agreements; that a recent source cannot tell us about the past. Unit 2 examines the 1737 Walking Purchase in detail. Today stays with the general difference in views.
Supports: provide glow and grow sticky-note frames tied to each criterion. Pair readers for the gallery walk. Stretch: find what the reading leaves out and where we could look next.
Answer guide: comparisons should say the Lenape saw agreements as shared use and goods as gifts, while colonists saw sales and payment, and should explain that ideas about land ownership differed. Exit tickets: the nation is telling its own history, which is the Lenape point of view. Career facts are from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics Occupational Outlook Handbook page on cartographers and photogrammetrists.
Delaware Tribe of Indians, About Us · Copyright Delaware Tribe of Indians; retold in our own words with a link to the source
The Delaware Tribe of Indians is a nation of Lenape people. Lenape means about “The People.” Europeans named the Delaware River after an English lord, and then called the people Delaware too.
The Lenape lived along the Delaware River. Their ancestors were among the first Native people to meet Dutch, English and Swedish colonists in the early 1600s. Other nations called them the “Grandfather” tribe and respected them as peacemakers.
The tribe explains that the two sides saw land agreements in different ways. The Lenape believed the land belonged to the Creator and could not be sold. To them, an agreement was more like sharing the use of the land. They saw the goods they received as gifts. Europeans saw the same goods as payment for land they now owned.
On September 17, 1778, the Delaware signed the first Indian treaty with the new United States. Losing land pushed the people west to Ohio, Indiana, Missouri, Kansas and Oklahoma. Today the Delaware Tribe is a sovereign nation, with offices in Bartlesville, Oklahoma, a tribal council, a court, a museum and language classes.
Source: Delaware Tribe of Indians, About Us (delawaretribe.org)