The Colonial Pennsylvania Market Guide
How did William Penn’s ideas, the land and the work of many different people make colonial Pennsylvania grow, and who gained or lost?
The mystery: In 1682 William Penn promised freedom of worship, yet in 1737 the Walking Purchase took a huge part of the Lenape homeland. How could both happen in one colony?
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
use the 1681 charter to explain why William Penn started Pennsylvania, and ask how a colony built on freedom of worship could also take Lenape land.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. Imagine a leader who makes a big promise: everyone may worship in their own way. Fifty years later, people from the same colony take a huge piece of land from their neighbors. Can one place have both stories?
Why might a colony keep one promise but break another kind of promise?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Welcome, junior historians and economists. In Unit 1 we built an atlas of Pennsylvania’s land and first peoples. Now we will make a Colonial Pennsylvania Market Guide. Families will read it to learn how people made a living in the colony, how goods moved, and who gained or lost.
Our puzzle. In 1682 William Penn promised freedom of worship. In 1737 the Walking Purchase took a huge part of the Lenape homeland. How could both happen in one colony? We will look for causes, the reasons something happens, and results, what happens because of it.
Two goals at once. Today’s reading shows that Penn had more than one goal. He wanted religious freedom for Quakers and others. He also wanted money from selling land. Both goals pushed people to come. But selling land needed land, and that land was the Lenape homeland.
Worked example 1: finding a cause. Amara reads that Quakers were jailed in England. She writes, “One cause of Pennsylvania was that Quakers were treated badly in England, so Penn wanted a safe place for them.” She named a fact and linked it to what happened next.
Worked example 2: noticing what is missing. Diego notices that the charter lists rivers, forests and minerals, but not the Lenape. He writes, “The charter treats the land as if the king could give it away. It leaves out the people who already lived there.” A good historian notices who is left out.
Our promise to readers. Our guide will use real evidence. We will tell the stories of the Lenape, of the many settlers who came, and of the enslaved Africans who were forced to work without pay. All of them are part of how the colony grew.
Work with a partner. Point to the sentence in the reading that gives each answer.
Start your page for the class Wonder Board.
Write the two reasons Penn wanted a colony. After each one, write a result it might have for the people who lived there.
Write one question about our puzzle: how could freedom of worship and the loss of Lenape land happen in the same colony?
We met our puzzle and our guide. Next time we will test a famous story about Penn and the Lenape. Is it fact, opinion or legend?
Exit ticket: name one cause of the founding of Pennsylvania and one group the charter left out.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 10, mini lesson 10, guided practice 10, Wonder Board 5.
Likely misconceptions: that Pennsylvania was empty land; that Penn had only one goal; that the king “owned” Lenape land. Explain that European kings claimed land by their own laws, while the Lenape had lived there for thousands of years.
Supports: sentence frame “Because ___, ___ happened.” Stretch: why might a landowner who needs money sell land quickly?
Answer guide: causes: Quakers were persecuted in England; Penn needed income from land. Strong answers to the open question note that the charter treated the land as the king’s to give, which made later land sales seem lawful to colonists but not to the Lenape.
Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, Our Documentary Heritage, Pennsylvania Charter · Pennsylvania state agency page (archived 2015); the 1681 charter is public domain; commentary retold in our own words
On March 4, 1681, King Charles II of England signed a charter for William Penn. A charter is an official paper that gives someone rights or land. This one gave Penn a huge piece of land west of the Delaware River. The charter called it “Pensilvania.”
Penn became the proprietor, or owner, of the colony. He could make laws, choose judges, set up towns and counties, and sell land. In return, he had to send the king two beaver skins every year.
Why did Penn want a colony? The reading gives two reasons. First, Penn was a Quaker. In England, Quakers were fined and jailed for their beliefs. Penn himself was locked in the Tower of London. He wanted a place where people could worship freely and live in peace. Second, Penn needed money. Selling land in a new colony could help him.
The charter talked about the land, the rivers, the forests and the minerals. It did not say anything about the Lenape people who already lived there. The Penn family kept control of the colony until the American Revolution.
Source: Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, Our Documentary Heritage, Pennsylvania Charter (phmc.state.pa.us)