explain the causes and results of the Walking Purchase and why Lenape leaders called it a fraud.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. A friend says, “You can have as many crayons as you can carry in one hand.” You bring a giant bucket and call it your hand. Is that fair?
A 1737 deed said land would reach as far as a man could walk in a day and a half. What do you think the colony's officials did?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
A chain of events. Historians link events like a chain. Each link is a cause or a result. Today we build the chain for the Walking Purchase.
Causes. Penn’s sons were in debt. Settlers kept arriving and wanted land. Selling land brought money to the Penn family. These causes pushed the Penns to claim more Lenape land.
How it was done. The Penns used a deed that the Lenape had never seen. They used a Lenape way of measuring, a day and a half’s walk, but they turned it into a race. This was trickery, not a fair walk.
Worked example 1: cause and result. Priya writes, “Because the Penns hired trained walkers and scouted the path, the walk covered much more land than the Lenape expected.” She used the word because to link a cause to a result.
Worked example 2: a long-term result. Ethan writes, “In 1742 the Lenape were ordered off the land, so many moved west, far from their homeland.” He found a result that came years later.
Lenape leaders resisted. Lenape leaders protested. They called the deal a fraud and stayed on their land until they were forced out. Their protest is part of the record. Anger over lost land later helped lead to war on the frontier, which is a story for another course.
Put the events in order and find the causes and results.
Build a cause-and-result chain for our guide.
Draw a chain of four links: one cause, the deed, the walk, and one result. Write one sentence in each link.
Look back at our puzzle. How does the Walking Purchase help explain how a colony with freedom of worship could also take Lenape land?
We built the chain of the Walking Purchase. Next we meet the many peoples who came to Pennsylvania.
Exit ticket: name one person or group who gained from the Walking Purchase and one who lost. Explain.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 10, mini lesson 10, guided practice 10, chain 5.
Do not re-enact or race the walk. Do not have students act as walkers or Lenape leaders. Use a timeline and chain only.
Accuracy: the PHMC page uses “Delaware”; we use “Lenape” and explain both names. Signers named on the page: Tisheekunk (Teeshakomen, often spelled Tishcohan), Nutimus, Lappawinzoe and Manawkyhickon. The page dates the Iroquois order to 1741; most histories place Canasatego’s order at the July 1742 Philadelphia council, so lessons say 1742. The page says the Iroquois insulted the Lenape; we leave out the insult for grade 4. The frontier war of the 1750s is taught in the French and Indian War course; only name it here.
Likely misconceptions: that the Lenape agreed to give up their land; that William Penn ran the walk (he had died in 1718).
Answer guide: gained: the Penn family, land buyers and settlers; lost: Lenape families who lost homes and hunting lands. The opinion question: it is a judgment, strongly supported by facts (unknown deed, trained walkers, scouted path, angled line).
Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, Our Documentary Heritage, The Walking Purchase · Pennsylvania state agency page (archived 2015); the 1737 deed is public domain; commentary retold in our own words
William Penn died in 1718. His sons John, Thomas and Richard Penn now ran the colony. They were in debt, and many settlers wanted land. The sons even sold some land before buying it from its Native owners.
The Penns and their official James Logan showed Lenape leaders an old deed from 1686. They said it sold land along the Delaware and Lehigh Rivers. The Lenape leaders had never heard of it. The reading says the 1686 sale likely never happened.
On August 25, 1737, Lenape leaders, including Nutimus and Tishcohan, signed a deed. The land would reach as far as a man could walk in a day and a half. That was a Lenape way to measure distance.
The Penns hired trained walkers. Paths were scouted ahead of time. Two walkers dropped out, and the third nearly collapsed. The walk went up to twice a normal distance. Then surveyors drew the last line at an angle that added even more land.
The Lenape called the deal a fraud and refused to leave. A few years later the Iroquois, asked by Pennsylvania, ordered them off the land. Many Lenape moved west.
Source: Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, Our Documentary Heritage, The Walking Purchase (phmc.state.pa.us)