
design, build, test and refine a cushion that protects an egg in a cart collision, use momentum and impulse to explain its performance, model it with a simulation, and evaluate it against prioritized criteria.
Instruction
The challenge. A toy car or truck carrying a raw egg sealed in a zip-top bag rolls down a ramp and hits a wall. Your job is to design a cushion, attached to the front of the car, so that the egg survives. It is the crash-cushion problem at tabletop scale: the same job MoDOT’s sand barrels do at the end of a work-zone barrier.
Criteria and constraints. Success criteria: the egg does not crack in three runs from your standard ramp height; the car’s stopping time, measured from slow-motion phone video, is as long as possible. Constraints: the cushion’s mass is at most 100 g (weigh it on a kitchen scale); it extends no more than 15 cm in front of the car; it uses only household materials (paper, cardboard, straws, tape, rubber bands, craft foam, bubble wrap); and the egg may not be wrapped in padding itself, so the cushion does the work. Build the ramp from a board or a stiff piece of cardboard propped on books, record its height, and keep it the same for every run; measure the car’s speed at the bottom in a trial run by timing it over the last 0.50 m.
Process. (1) Use your sub-problem breakdown from Lesson 1.4. (2) Sketch at least two designs and predict which will stop the car over a longer time. (3) Build the first design and test it with a hard-boiled egg or an egg-sized water balloon in a bag before using raw eggs. (4) Film each test in slow motion and measure the stopping time frame by frame (many phones film at 240 frames per second, so each frame is about 0.004 s). (5) Refine and test the second iteration. Record every test, including failures; failed tests are data. Run tests over a tray or old towel, keep raw eggs sealed in their bags, and wash your hands after handling raw eggs.
Calculations the report must include. The car’s momentum at impact (p = mv with measured mass and speed); the average force for each design (F = p ÷ Δt, using the measured stopping time); and a comparison of the two iterations. Example with illustrative numbers: a 0.80 kg car and egg at 1.5 m/s has momentum 1.2 kg·m/s; stopping in 0.020 s gives 60 N, while stopping in 0.080 s gives 15 N.
Model it (9-12.ETS1.B.2). Use the PhET Collision Lab to model your crash: a ball with your car’s mass and speed hitting a very heavy ball, first perfectly elastic and then perfectly sticky. Compare the momentum change in each and explain why a cushion that absorbs the collision (sticky) rather than bouncing back also halves the momentum change the egg experiences. State one way the simulation does not match your real test.
Evaluate (9-12.ETS1.B.1). Rank your criteria and constraints, score your final design against them, and state the trade-offs you made (for example, a longer cushion stops more gently but risks breaking the size limit; stiffer materials survive more runs but stop faster). Compare your design with one of the two reference designs in this lesson’s reading.
Stages. Plan, draft report, review, revise, and present your design in a four-minute talk, live or recorded, answering one question about it. Follow every step of your test procedure exactly (RST.9-10.3) so that your results can be compared with the reference designs and repeated by anyone who reads your report.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
A 0.80 kg cart at 1.5 m/s stops in 0.040 s. The average force on it is
A failed test that cracks the egg should be left out of the engineering report.
Draft your plan: sketch two designs, predict which gives the longer stopping time and why, and list your ranked criteria and constraints.
How confident are you that you can design, test and refine a device that reduces collision force and evaluate it against criteria?
Unit 1 checkpoint
Do this before you start the task. It covers the whole unit and tells you what to review first.
A car goes from 10 m/s to 22 m/s in 4.0 s. Its acceleration is
A net force of 30 N acts on a 6.0 kg object. Its acceleration is
A straight-line graph of acceleration against net force at constant mass supports Newton’s second law.
The slope of an acceleration-force graph is 2.5, so the mass is kg.
Momentum is
A 1.0 kg cart at 4.0 m/s sticks to a 3.0 kg cart at rest. Their speed afterward is
Total momentum is conserved in a collision only if no net outside force acts on the system.
Crash cushions reduce the force on a car mainly by
A momentum change of 12 kg·m/s over 0.20 s requires an average force of N.
Which is the best example of breaking down a design problem?
A simulation of a collision can help predict a design’s performance, but its results must be checked against real tests.
A longer cushion stops the cart more gently but breaks the 15 cm limit. This is an example of
Submit: Crash Cushion engineering report (900-1,300 words) + four-minute presentation
Task: Build and test at least two iterations of a cushion (at most 100 g, at most 15 cm long) that stops a toy car carrying a raw egg in a sealed bag. Report the measured impact speed, momentum, stopping times and average forces for each iteration; model the collision in the PhET Collision Lab; and evaluate the final design against ranked criteria and constraints, comparing it with one of the reference designs in this lesson’s reading. If you cannot test at home, complete every calculation and the evaluation from the reference designs’ test logs and say so in your report.
Submission workflow
- Stage 1 — Plan. Sub-problem breakdown, two sketched designs with predictions, the test procedure and a data table.
- Stage 2 — Reviewed draft. Recompute every momentum and force a second time from your raw data (or have a parent, guardian or other reader recompute them with you), check your impulse reasoning, and mark unsupported claims; submit the review notes and your revision plan.
- Stage 3 — Final report. 900-1,300 words with data from every test, calculations, the simulation comparison and the criteria evaluation.
- Stage 4 — Presentation and defense. Four minutes, live or recorded, with a demonstration video; answer one question about your design.
How it is scored
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Design and refinement (9-12.PS2.A.3) | Two tested iterations; changes justified by data and impulse reasoning. |
| Calculations (SEP.6, 9-12.PS2.A.3) | Momentum, stopping time and average force computed correctly from measured values. |
| Problem breakdown and modeling (9-12.ETS1.A.2, 9-12.ETS1.B.2) | Sub-problems tested separately; simulation used to model the crash with its limits stated. |
| Evaluation (9-12.ETS1.B.1) | Ranked criteria and constraints, honest trade-offs, comparison with a reference design. |
| Procedure and communication (RST.9-10.3, CCC.4) | Test procedure followed exactly; clear report and presentation. |
The Design Brief, Two Reference Designs’ Test Logs, and the Simulation Comparison
Design brief for the Lesson 1.5 challenge; two reference designs’ test logs at 240 frames per second, constructed for this course and illustrative; TrafFix Devices, Big Sandy Inertial Crash Cushion System manual (Rev. A1, 2020) and MoDOT Engineering Policy Guide 612 quoted for the real-world criteria; PhET Collision Lab predictions computed from conservation of momentum; retrieved November 5, 2026 · SLS original (constructed teaching data), with brief quotations from a manufacturer’s manual and a MoDOT public record
Why this reading. The performance task asks for measured impact speeds, momenta, stopping times and forces for two iterations, a comparison with one of the reference designs, and a simulation comparison. A student working alone at home needs all three to exist on paper. This reading gives the brief in one place, two complete reference test logs, and the simulation numbers. Use the logs to practice every calculation before you make your own, to compare against, or to complete the report if you cannot test. Both logs are constructed teaching data and are labeled illustrative.
1. The brief
| Criteria (what success means) | Constraints (what you may not exceed) |
|---|---|
| The egg is intact after three runs from the standard ramp height | Cushion mass at most 100 g |
| Stopping time, from slow-motion video, as long as possible | Cushion extends at most 15 cm in front of the cart |
| Average force on the cart (momentum ÷ stopping time) as small as possible | Household materials only: paper, cardboard, straws, tape, rubber bands, craft foam, bubble wrap |
| Survives repeated runs without rebuilding | The egg itself may not be wrapped; the cushion does the work |
Compare this with the real thing. The sand-barrel array in the Lesson 1.1 reading was tested at “TL-3 (62.1 mph/ 100 km/hr),” stopping an 1,100 kg car and a 2,270 kg pickup within the limits of the national test manual, which MoDOT requires of every impact attenuator made after January 1, 2023. Its manual also states a limit: the tests “are not intended to represent the systems performance when impacted by every vehicle type or every impact condition existing on the roadway.” Your report should do the same two things: state the test your device passed, and state what it is not designed for.
2. Reference Design A: test log
Each reference design was built by one student at home with a toy truck as the cart and a board propped on books as the ramp. Ramp set so the cart crosses the last 0.50 m before the wall in about 0.33 s. Speed = 0.50 m ÷ time over the last 0.50 m. Stopping time = frames from first contact to the frame the cart is fully stopped, at 240 frames per second (each frame 1/240 s = 0.0042 s). Iteration 1: three flat layers of craft foam taped to the cart’s bumper, 62 g, 4 cm long. Iteration 2: a folded-cardboard accordion with two straws as guides and a bubble-wrap face, 94 g, 14 cm long.
| Iteration | Run | Cart + egg mass (kg) | Time over last 0.50 m (s) | Speed (m/s) | Momentum (kg·m/s) | Frames to stop | Stopping time (s) | Average force (N) | Egg |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1 | 0.80 | 0.33 | 1.52 | 1.21 | 5 | 0.021 | 58 | cracked |
| 1 | 2 | 0.80 | 0.34 | 1.47 | 1.18 | 6 | 0.025 | 47 | cracked |
| 1 | 3 | 0.80 | 0.33 | 1.52 | 1.21 | 5 | 0.021 | 58 | intact |
| 2 | 1 | 0.83 | 0.33 | 1.52 | 1.26 | 18 | 0.075 | 17 | intact |
| 2 | 2 | 0.83 | 0.34 | 1.47 | 1.22 | 19 | 0.079 | 15 | intact |
| 2 | 3 | 0.83 | 0.33 | 1.52 | 1.26 | 20 | 0.083 | 15 | intact |
Design A’s iteration 1 cracked the egg in two runs of three; the force was about 58 N in the 5-frame runs (about 55 N averaged over all three). Iteration 2 lengthened the average stop about three and a half times (from 0.022 s to 0.079 s) and cut the force to about 16 N, and all three eggs survived. The extra 32 g of cushion changed the cart’s mass by 4%, which slightly raised the momentum, but the stopping time did far more.
3. Reference Design B: test log
Same ramp. Iteration 1: a bubble-wrap roll, 48 g, 9 cm. Iteration 2: the same roll with a cardboard cone in front to crush first, 71 g, 15 cm (at the limit).
| Iteration | Run | Cart + egg mass (kg) | Time over last 0.50 m (s) | Speed (m/s) | Momentum (kg·m/s) | Frames to stop | Stopping time (s) | Average force (N) | Egg |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1 | 0.86 | 0.34 | 1.47 | 1.26 | 11 | 0.046 | 28 | intact |
| 1 | 2 | 0.86 | 0.33 | 1.52 | 1.30 | 10 | 0.042 | 31 | cracked |
| 1 | 3 | 0.86 | 0.34 | 1.47 | 1.26 | 12 | 0.050 | 25 | intact |
| 2 | 1 | 0.88 | 0.33 | 1.52 | 1.33 | 14 | 0.058 | 23 | intact |
| 2 | 2 | 0.88 | 0.34 | 1.47 | 1.29 | 15 | 0.062 | 21 | intact |
| 2 | 3 | 0.88 | 0.33 | 1.52 | 1.33 | 14 | 0.058 | 23 | intact |
Design B started better (about 28 N) and improved less (about 22 N). Both final designs protect the egg, so the “egg intact” criterion does not separate them; the stopping time does. Design A’s final stop is longer, but Design A used 94 g of its 100 g and Design B used 71 g. Which is the better design depends on how the criteria are ranked, and that ranking is what 9-12.ETS1.B.1 asks you to make and defend.
4. The mini-lecture’s example and the quiz, checked
0.80 kg at 1.5 m/s: momentum 0.80 × 1.5 = 1.2 kg·m/s. Stop in 0.020 s: 1.2 ÷ 0.020 = 60 N. Stop in 0.080 s: 15 N. Stop in 0.040 s (the quiz): 30 N. At 240 frames per second, 0.020 s is about 5 frames and 0.080 s about 19 frames, which is why Design A’s iteration 1 (5 to 6 frames) lands near 58 N and iteration 2 (18 to 20 frames) near 16 N. When you count frames, report the count and the time together; a one-frame miscount is a 20% error at 5 frames and a 5% error at 19.
5. The simulation comparison (9-12.ETS1.B.2)
In the PhET Collision Lab, model the cart as a 0.80 kg ball at 1.5 m/s hitting a very heavy ball at rest (set the second mass to the maximum). Conservation of momentum predicts:
| Elasticity | Cart velocity after (m/s) | Cart momentum change (kg·m/s) |
|---|---|---|
| 100% (perfectly elastic: the cart bounces back) | about −1.5 | 0.80 × (−1.5 − 1.5) = −2.4 |
| 0% (perfectly sticky: the cart stops) | about 0 | 0.80 × (0 − 1.5) = −1.2 |
A cushion that absorbs the collision instead of bouncing the cart back halves the momentum change, and by impulse halves the average force for the same stopping time. That is the sentence the task asks you to explain. The simulation’s limits, which you must also state: it has no stopping time (the collision is instantaneous), no crushing distance, and no egg; it tells you the momentum change, and nothing about how long the stop took. Your video supplies the time.
Your turn
- Recompute every speed, momentum, stopping time and force in Design A’s log from the raw columns (mass, time over 0.50 m, frames), carrying full precision until the last step. The values in the table should reproduce.
- Rank the four criteria in the brief, score Design A’s and Design B’s final versions against your ranking, and state the trade-off each design made.
- Write one sentence for your report, in the style of the sand-barrel manual, that says what your cushion is designed for and what it is not designed for.
Sources: TrafFix Devices, Big Sandy Inertial Crash Cushion System manual, Rev. A1 (2020) (media.trafficsafetystore.com); MoDOT Engineering Policy Guide, Category 612 Impact Attenuators (epg.modot.org)