test four white solids for solubility, conductivity in solution and behavior when warmed, and use the results to infer the relative strength of the forces between their particles.
Instruction
The investigation question. Table salt, sugar, candle wax and fine sand all look like white or pale solids. They are held together by very different forces. Today you measure bulk properties, the properties of a sample big enough to hold, and use them as evidence about particles you cannot see. This is 9-12.PS1.A.3: from structure at the bulk scale, infer the strength of electrical forces between particles.
What each test tells you.
- Behavior when warmed. A substance melts when its particles gain enough energy to overcome the forces holding them in place. In a bowl of hot water at about 70 °C, a substance with weak forces between its particles (wax, melting point roughly 50-65 °C depending on the blend) will melt. Substances with stronger forces will not. Published melting points complete the picture: sugar about 186 °C (it also begins to decompose), salt 801 °C, and quartz sand about 1,700 °C.
- Solubility in water. Water molecules are polar: the oxygen end is slightly negative and the hydrogen ends slightly positive. They can pull ions out of a lattice and surround them, and they can attract polar molecules such as sugar. Nonpolar substances like wax do not dissolve. Sand is a covalent network: every atom is bonded to its neighbors through the whole grain, so water cannot pull pieces away.
- Conductivity of the solution. Electric current is moving charge. A solution conducts only if it contains mobile ions. Dissolved salt separates into Na+ and Cl−, so the LED lights. Dissolved sugar stays as whole neutral molecules, so it does not, even though it dissolved. That single test separates ionic from molecular substances.
From evidence to inference. Put the three tests together. Dissolves, conducts in solution, very high melting point: an ionic lattice with strong forces. Dissolves, does not conduct, moderate melting point: polar molecules with moderate intermolecular forces. Does not dissolve, melts easily: nonpolar molecules with weak intermolecular forces. Does not dissolve and does not melt at any temperature we can reach: a covalent network with very strong bonds throughout.
Worked reasoning. Suppose an unknown dissolves (a level 1/4 teaspoon in 2 teaspoons of water clears after 1 minute of stirring), the LED stays dark, and it does not melt in the bath. The data rule out ionic (no conduction) and weak nonpolar forces (did not melt). The best inference is a polar molecular substance, such as sugar. Notice the reasoning uses more than one test; one test alone often cannot decide.
Fair testing. Use the same amount of solid (a level 1/4 teaspoon, or 1.0 g if you have a kitchen scale), the same volume of water (2 teaspoons, about 10 mL), the same stirring time, and the same tester. Rinse and dry the tester probes between samples, because a trace of salt left on a probe will make the next sample appear to conduct. Test tap water alone first as your control: tap water contains a few ions and may make the LED glow faintly, so record its brightness for comparison.
Safety. An adult heats the water on the stove and pours it; you never heat a sample directly, and there are no flames. Safety glasses stay on because you are handling liquids and hot water. Nothing is tasted, even the sugar. No LED tester at home? Use the recorded data set for the conductivity column and run the other two tests yourself.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Lab: Inferring Particle Forces from the Properties of Four White Solids
Question. What do the solubility, conductivity in solution and melting behavior of salt, sugar, wax and sand tell us about the strength and type of forces between their particles?
Materials
- A level 1/4 teaspoon (a little more for the bath test) each of table salt, granulated sugar, paraffin wax shavings (peeled from an unscented candle with a vegetable peeler) and fine clean play or aquarium sand, plus an unknown: a family member secretly puts one of the four in a cup labeled “unknown” (working alone? use the unknowns in the recorded data set)
- Measuring spoons (1/4 teaspoon and 1 teaspoon), five clear cups or glasses, spoons or craft sticks for stirring, masking tape and a marker for labels; a kitchen scale is optional
- Conductivity tester: two AA batteries taped end to end or in a holder, one small LED (from a craft kit or old string of battery lights) and two strips of aluminum foil or wire as probes, plus paper towels for drying probes. No LED or batteries? Use the recorded data set for the conductivity column
- A heat-safe bowl of water heated on the stove by an adult to about 70 °C (steaming, small bubbles on the bottom, not boiling), five small foil cups folded from aluminum foil, a spoon or tongs, and a kitchen thermometer if you have one
- A magnifying glass or a phone camera zoomed in; safety glasses or sunglasses-style eye protection
- Wear safety glasses throughout: the lab uses liquids and hot water.
- An adult heats and pours the hot water; there are no flames. Lower and lift the foil cups with a spoon or tongs and never put your fingers in the hot water.
- Use only the two-battery tester; never connect anything to a wall outlet.
- Do not taste any sample. Put wax and sand in the trash, not the sink; salt and sugar solutions may go down the drain with water. Wash the cups and spoons when you finish.
Procedure
- Examine each solid with the magnifying glass or phone zoom and record crystal shape, texture and whether grains are hard or soft.
- Test 2 teaspoons of tap water alone with the conductivity tester and record the LED brightness (0 dark, 1 faint, 2 bright) as your control. (No tester: copy the control and conductivity readings for one run of the recorded data set and say which run you used.)
- Put a level 1/4 teaspoon of each solid into its own labeled cup, add 2 teaspoons (about 10 mL) of water and stir for 1 minute. Record whether it dissolves completely, partly or not at all.
- Test each mixture with the conductivity tester, holding the two probes the same distance apart each time. Rinse and dry the probes between samples. Record brightness on the 0-2 scale.
- Put a pea-sized amount of each dry solid in its own labeled foil cup and float the cups on the bowl of hot water for 3 minutes. Record the water temperature (or “steaming, not boiling” if you have no thermometer) and whether each sample melts.
- Repeat steps 3-5 for the unknown, then identify it, record your reasoning and check your answer with the family member who chose it.
Data
| Sample | Appearance (magnifier) | Dissolves in water? (all / part / none) | LED brightness in solution (0-2) | Melts in hot water at ___ °C? | Inferred force type and strength |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Water only (control) | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | |
| Table salt | |||||
| Sugar | |||||
| Wax | |||||
| Sand | |||||
| Unknown |
Analysis
- Claim: rank the four known solids from strongest to weakest forces between particles. Evidence: cite at least two tests for each. Reasoning: explain each placement with the type of particle (ions, polar molecules, nonpolar molecules, covalent network).
- Sugar dissolved but did not conduct. Explain what this tells you about the particles in sugar solution compared with salt solution.
- Identify the unknown and explain which single test was most decisive and why one test alone might not have been enough.
- Name two sources of error (for example, salt left on the probes, or a bath that cooled during the test) and how each could mislead you.
- Return to the phenomenon: use your results to explain why white salt is left behind on a Missouri highway when the water in a brine stripe evaporates.
If you cannot do this lab in person: Use the recorded data set of eight home runs in the lesson reading (it includes the unknowns), and explore melting and the forces between particles with the PhET States of Matter simulation (Solid, Liquid, Gas and Phase Changes screens). You can still do the hand-lens and dissolving tests with only salt, sugar and water.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which solution will make the LED light up?
An unknown does not dissolve in water, does not conduct and melts in 70 °C water. The best inference is
Testing plain water with the conductivity tester before any samples is unnecessary, because water never conducts.
Write your claim-evidence-reasoning paragraph ranking the four solids by the strength of forces between their particles. Use data from at least two tests and name one source of error.
How confident are you that you can infer the strength of forces between particles from solubility, conductivity and melting behavior?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- A solid dissolves in water and the solution lights the LED. What kind of particles does the solution contain?
Check your answer
Answer: Mobile ions; the solid is ionic. - A solid dissolves in water but the solution does not conduct. What can you infer?
Check your answer
Answer: It dissolves as neutral molecules, so it is a (polar) molecular substance, such as sugar. - Which of salt, sugar, wax and sand melted in the 70 °C water, and what does that tell you?
Check your answer
Answer: Only the wax; its particles are held by weak intermolecular forces. - Name the independent variable, the dependent variables and two controlled variables in the mystery-solids lab.
Check your answer
Answer: Independent: the solid tested. Dependent: dissolving, LED brightness, melting. Controlled: the same amount of solid (a level 1/4 teaspoon), 2 teaspoons of water, stirring time, same tester and hot-water temperature. - Order salt (801 °C), sugar (about 186 °C), wax (about 60 °C) and quartz (about 1,700 °C) from weakest to strongest forces between particles.
Check your answer
Answer: Wax < sugar < salt < quartzHigher melting point, stronger forces holding the particles in place.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- About 35.9 g of salt dissolves in 100 g of water at 20 °C, and about 202 g of sugar does. How much of each would dissolve in 250 g of water at 20 °C?
Check your answer
Answer: About 90 g of salt and about 505 g of sugarScale by 2.5: 35.9 × 2.5 = 89.75 g; 202 × 2.5 = 505 g. - A student’s sugar solution made the LED glow faintly, the same brightness as the tap-water control. Should the student conclude sugar is ionic? Explain.
Check your answer
Answer: No. The faint glow matches the control, so it comes from ions already in the tap water, not from the sugar. Sugar did not add conducting particles.Compare every result with the control before drawing a conclusion. - Unknown X: dissolves completely, LED bright (2), does not melt in the bath. Unknown Y: does not dissolve, LED dark (0), does not melt in the bath. Identify each from the four lab solids and give your reasoning.
Check your answer
Answer: X is salt: dissolving and conducting show mobile ions. Y is sand: insoluble, nonconducting and unmelted fits a covalent network with very strong bonds.Use the combination of tests, not one test alone.
Challenge
Stretch problems. Expect to think before you write.
- Design a test to decide whether an unknown white solid is sugar or baking soda (sodium hydrogen carbonate, an ionic compound), using only equipment from this lab. Say what result would identify each.
Check your answer
Answer: Dissolve a level 1/4 teaspoon in 2 teaspoons of water and test with the conductivity tester. Baking soda forms ions, so the LED lights; sugar solution stays at the control’s brightness.Both dissolve and neither melts in the hot water, so conductivity is the deciding test.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- What volume does 13.5 g of aluminum (density 2.7 g/cm3) occupy?
Check your answer
Answer: 5.0 cm3Volume = mass / density. - Bromine is 50.69% Br-79 (78.9183 u) and 49.31% Br-81 (80.9163 u). Find its average atomic mass.
Check your answer
Answer: 79.90 u0.5069 × 78.9183 + 0.4931 × 80.9163 = 79.90 u.
Four White Solids: Reference Properties and a Recorded Home-Lab Data Set
SLS original recorded data set for the Lesson 2.2 at-home procedure (illustrative, n = 8 runs); melting points and solubilities are reference values from standard compilations · SLS original (constructed teaching data, labeled illustrative), with reference values
Why this reading. The lab’s data route calls for “the recorded data set.” This is it, together with the published reference properties of the four solids so that you can judge whether the recorded results make sense, and so that you can compare your own kitchen run with eight others. The recorded set is SLS original and illustrative, constructed to match what this procedure typically produces with kitchen materials; it is not an agency measurement. The reference values in the first table are published.
Reference properties of the four solids
Values as tabulated in standard compilations (the CRC Handbook and similar), reproduced on public data pages; they are reference values, not NIST measurements.
| Solid | Formula or make-up | Melting point | Solubility in water | Particles |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Table salt | NaCl | 800.7 °C (boils 1,413 °C) | 360 g per L at 25 °C | Na+ and Cl− ions in a cubic lattice |
| Granulated sugar | Sucrose, C12H22O11 | About 186–189 °C, and it begins to decompose (caramelize) below its melting point | Very soluble: 259 g per 100 mL at 50 °C | Polar molecules with many O–H groups |
| Paraffin wax | Mixture of alkanes with 20–40 carbon atoms | About 46–68 °C depending on blend | About 1 mg per L (insoluble for our purposes) | Nonpolar molecules |
| Sand (quartz) | SiO2 | About 1,670–1,713 °C | Insoluble | A continuous network of SiO4 tetrahedra, each oxygen shared by two silicon atoms |
Quartz is the defining mineral for hardness 7 on the Mohs scale, which is why it scratches steel and why sand grains keep their edges after years in a river.
The recorded runs
Eight home runs of the procedure (n = 8), each by a different tester. Each used a level 1/4 teaspoon of solid in 2 teaspoons (about 10 mL) of tap water, stirred for 1 minute, tested with the same kind of two-battery LED tester (0 dark, 1 faint, 2 bright), rinsed and dried the probes between samples, and floated a pea-sized dry sample in a foil cup on a bowl of stove-heated water for 3 minutes. Bath temperatures at the start of the 3 minutes ranged from 66 to 73 °C and are recorded per run.
| Run | Bath (°C) | Water-only LED | Salt: dissolves / LED / melts | Sugar: dissolves / LED / melts | Wax: dissolves / LED / melts | Sand: dissolves / LED / melts |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 71 | 0 | all / 2 / no | all / 0 / no | none / 0 / yes | none / 0 / no |
| 2 | 68 | 1 | all / 2 / no | all / 1 / no | none / 0 / yes | none / 1 / no |
| 3 | 73 | 0 | all / 2 / no | all / 0 / no | none / 0 / yes | none / 0 / no |
| 4 | 66 | 0 | all / 2 / no | part (after 1 min) / 0 / no | none / 0 / partly (softened) | none / 0 / no |
| 5 | 70 | 1 | all / 2 / no | all / 1 / no | none / 0 / yes | none / 0 / no |
| 6 | 72 | 0 | all / 2 / no | all / 0 / no | none / 0 / yes | none / 0 / no |
| 7 | 69 | 0 | all / 2 / no | all / 2 / no | none / 0 / yes | none / 0 / no |
| 8 | 71 | 1 | all / 2 / no | all / 1 / no | none / 0 / yes | none / 0 / no |
Read the exceptions before the pattern. Runs 2, 5 and 8 saw a faint glow from tap water alone, and the same runs saw a faint glow from sugar water: their sugar reading is the tap water’s ions, not sugar’s. Run 7’s bright sugar reading is the classic probe error; that tester reported afterward testing salt first and not drying the probes. Run 2’s faint sand reading has the same cause. Run 4’s bath was the coolest (66 °C) and its wax only softened, which is what a melting range of 46–68 °C predicts for a wax at the top of that range. Run 4’s sugar dissolved only partly in one minute, consistent with the larger sugar crystals in that run’s sample; with more stirring it dissolves.
The unknowns
| Runs | Unknown: dissolves / LED / melts | Identification | The decisive test, in the testers’ words |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1–4 | all / 0 (Run 2: 1, same as its water) / no | Sugar | “It dissolved but did not conduct above the water control, and it did not melt, so it is not wax; sugar is the only one left.” |
| 5–8 | all / 2 / no | Salt | “Bright LED means ions; only salt gave that.” |
In every run a family member chose the unknown in secret. Notice that the sugar runs needed two tests (solubility and conductivity) and the salt runs could have done it with one, but only because the control had already told them what the water alone did.
Ranking from the recorded runs
Strongest forces to weakest, with the evidence each placement rests on: sand (never dissolved, never melted; network of covalent bonds through the grain), salt (never melted in the bath; conducts when dissolved, so its particles are ions; reference melting point 800.7 °C), sugar (dissolves, does not conduct, does not melt at 70 °C; polar molecules; reference melting point about 186 °C), wax (melted in the bath in 7 of 8 runs; does not dissolve; nonpolar molecules). Salt and sand cannot be ordered by the bath test alone, because neither melted; the reference melting points settle it (1,700 against 800 °C), and that is a legitimate use of published data alongside your own.
Back to the road
Water molecules attract each other by hydrogen bonds strong enough to make water a liquid but weak enough to separate at everyday temperatures, so a wet road dries; the ions in salt attract each other so strongly that separating them takes 800 °C. So evaporation removes the water from a brine stripe and leaves the ions, which, with no water between them, lock into the cubic lattice: the white streak on the pavement. The conductivity test in this lab is the same fact from the other direction: as long as water is present the ions are free to move and carry current; in the dry crystal they are not.
Sources: Melting points, boiling points and solubilities: reference values as tabulated in standard compilations (CRC Handbook values as reproduced on public data pages) (en.wikipedia.org)